2008 PRE Player of the Year ( vsHawks starts on Page 88) | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2008 PRE Player of the Year ( vsHawks starts on Page 88)

tigerdave

Ya just gotta stand in line
Feb 1, 2006
7,843
3
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

Great stuff!! :clapping
 

ronnit

Tiger Superstar
Sep 25, 2007
1,106
0
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

thankyou panthera...what a lot of hard work for you,....really really great job :)
 

Panthera tigris FC

Full Blown Chimp Crush
Oct 28, 2004
4,808
2
Torquay
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

Fighting Fury said:
Outstanding PT. All year...simply outstanding.
Is it all just natural Excel ability or do you have your own software program?
Thanks alot.

Thanks all for the comments.

I use Access to collate and organise the data and Excel to do some of the analysis and presentation. I am certainly no expert on them!
 

Danarchy

Tiger Rookie
Feb 25, 2008
272
0
Dromana
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

Great effort all year Panthera. As a first year PREnder it has been a highlight, both participating and reading your Round analysis. Thanks alot! :clap
 

Willo

Tiger Legend
Oct 13, 2007
16,707
3,761
Aldinga Beach
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

Danarchy said:
Great effort all year Panthera. As a first year PREnder it has been a highlight, both participating and reading your Round analysis. Thanks alot! :clap
I'll second that. Great job, PT, we all appreciate the work you put in. :clap
 

Tigerhart04

Tiger Superstar
May 19, 2007
2,264
0
Australia
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

Congrats Pants on a huge effort. It will be very interesting to see how this tally matches up on Wednesday night.

:cupgold
 

Panthera tigris FC

Full Blown Chimp Crush
Oct 28, 2004
4,808
2
Torquay
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

Just the comparison between the PRE votes and the JDM results. I have included the normalised results in brackets for comparison.

RICHMOND FC PLAYER PUNT ROAD END DIFFERENCE
1 Brett Deledio 2 (1) +1 (-)
2 Shane Tuck 3 (3) +1 (+1)
3 Matthew Richardson 1 (2) -2 (-1)
4 Chris Newman 6 (5) +2 (+1)
5 Kelvin Moore 12 ( 8 ) +7 (+3)
6 Troy Simmonds 9 (11) +3 (+5)
7 Nathan Foley 4 (4) -3 (-3)
8 Jordan McMahon 14 (14) +6 (+6)
9 Nathan Brown 7 (6) -2 (-3)
10 Kane Johnson 10 (13) - (-3)

Players in the top 10 in the PRE Player of the Year that did not appear in the JDM top 10: Jake King (5) and Joel Bowden ( 8 ).

Not too bad. It certainly seems we underrated Moore, McMahon and perhaps Simmonds compared to the RFC. We over-rated King, Bowden and perhaps Foley.
 

Baloo

Delisted Free Agent
Nov 8, 2005
42,070
14,830
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

Though if you look at the PRE Brownlow you created it's a lot closer

1 Brett Deledio 26
2 Matthew Richardson 22
3 Shane Tuck 14
4 Nathan Foley 10
5 Chris Newman 8
=6 Nathan Brown 7
=6 Joel Bowden 7
8 Jake King 6
=9 Kane Johnson 5
=9 Kelvin Moore 5
 

tigersnake

Tear 'em apart
Sep 10, 2003
21,251
6,636
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

fantastic effort pantera. Better than the bloody club site. This thread should be be positioned near the top of page 1 so it doesn't slide down, otherwise people like me who get on the site irregularly may get to see it after its slid down off page 1. Thanks again
 

Panthera tigris FC

Full Blown Chimp Crush
Oct 28, 2004
4,808
2
Torquay
Re: The 2008 Punt Road End Player of the Year Awards Thread

Thanks snake. I actually quite enjoy looking after the voting. Watching Lids creep back in the second half and Tucky rise from nowhere was very interesting. I also find it interesting to see where the fans differ from the coaching staff in their assessment.