2017 Panthera Punt Road End Player of the Year 2017 Grand Final Vs Crows | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2017 Panthera Punt Road End Player of the Year 2017 Grand Final Vs Crows

hutstar

Tiger Superstar
Dec 17, 2002
2,359
778
Florida
hutstar said:
This is never happening, is it.

Could we form a committee to tally the votes?

Here are the rounds that Sammy C posted the round tally for. We need some rounds tallied, so how about we nominate a round, go count it, then post it?

We need talliers for rounds 6, 7, and each round including and after round 12, and finals. We won't end up with all the awesome stats of past years, but at least will will have a winner (Dusty) and place-getters for our premiership year.

I'll start by doing round 6.

Votes previously tallied:

Round 1 Voting 66 Votes

1. Dustin Martin 66 x 3 Total 198
2. Dion Prestia 95
3. Shaun Grigg 30
4. Toby Nankervis 24
5. Dan Butler and Jason Castagna 15
7. Reece Conca 9
8. Daniel Rioli 6
9. Trent Cotchin 4

Round 2 Votes

Trent Cotchin 192
Dustin Martin 87
Toby Nankervis 54
Alex Rance 22
Bachar Houli 15
Josh Caddy 7
Dylan Grimes 5
Reece Conca Shaun Grigg 3
Dion Prestia Shane Edwards 1

Round 3 vs West Coast Voting
Dustin Martin 161
Trent Cotchin 145
Alex Rance 41
Reece Conca 33
Bachar Houli Kane Lambert 2
Dylan Grimes David Astbury Daniel Rioli Toby Nankervis Dan Butler Jason Castagna 1

Round 4 vs Brisbane Voting
1. Shaun Grigg 126
2. Jason Castagna 57
3. David Astbury 49
4. Jack Riewoldt 45
5. Trent Cotchin 20
6. Reece Conca 11
7. Dylan Grimes 9
8. Brandon Ellis 5
9. Bachar Houli Daniel Rioli 3
11. Toby Nankervis Dion Prestia 1

Round 5 vs Melbourne Voting
Jack Riewoldt 196
Toby Nankervis 70
Bachar Houli 54
Dylan Grimes 25
Alex Rance 18
Shaun Grigg 11
Trent Cotchin 8
Dustin Martin 7
Daniel Rioli 4
Reece Conca 2
Josh Caddy 1

No Tally for round 6.

No Tally for round 7.

Votes for Round 8
Alex Rance 107
Shaun Grigg 40
Dustin Martin 39
Dylan Grimes Shane Edwards 18
Kamdyn McIntosh 17
Josh Caddy 5
Jack Riewoldt Toby Nankervis 4

Round 9 Voting
Alex Rance 107
David Astbury 37
Dustin Martin 35
Toby Nankervis 22
Dylan Grimes 18
Shaun Grigg 8


Round 10 Votes
Dustin Martin 108
Brandon Ellis 87
Trent Cotchin 63
Alex Rance 59
David Astbury 3
Bachar Houli 2
Jayden Short
Toby Nankervis 1

Round 11 Voting
Dustin Martin 184
Trent Cotchin 69
Bachar Houli 43
Dion Prestia 30
David Astbury 22
Alex Rance Toby Nankervis Kamdyn McIntosh 7
Kane Lambert 5
Brandon Ellis 4
 

hutstar

Tiger Superstar
Dec 17, 2002
2,359
778
Florida
Round 6 Vs Adelaide Votes:

Cotchin 120
Lambert 51
McIntosh 20
Rance 19
Nankervis 12
Rioli 10
Astbury 3

Jump in and do one of these: 7, and each round including and after round 12, and finals.
 

LeeToRainesToRoach

Tiger Legend
Jun 4, 2006
33,186
11,544
Melbourne
I've compiled all the votes in a database/spreadsheet. If anyone wants to do a countdown a la Panthera tigris, let me know and I'll post a Dropbox link where you can download all the data.

NB There are two votes that I was unable to discern, ttry as I might.

R17 v Brisbane - easy,tiger awarded two votes to 'Geezer'. I have this down provisionally as Astbury
Likewise, QF v Geelong - ToraToraTora gave three votes to 'G.O.A.T.' Have assumed this to be Rance but not sure as these were the only votes he got for the match.

Have no PM facility at present so if someone wants to PM these posters for clarification, go right ahead.

Other anomalies were decided as follows:

Blind Faith R1 - voted twice; second set of votes used
Coburgtiger R2 - listed votes as 1-2-3; interpreted as 3-2-1
Joshnbeks Dad R5 - shared third vote - awarded to Grimes (first named)
Joshnbeks Dad R16 - no third vote awarded
taztiger4 R18 - voted twice; second set of votes used
craig R19 - shared third vote - awarded to Ellis (first named)
Smoking Aces R21 - informal third vote (for umpire Stevic)
Baloo PF - multiple players listed; 3-2-1 awarded to to first three named
Tenacious Tiges GF - listed votes as 1-2-3; interpreted as 3-2-1
fuzztiger & Total Tiger GF - voted twice; second votes of votes used

if nobody is inclined to make a production out of it (i.e. no response in the next 24 hours or so), I'll just blurt out the results in table format. :)
 

LeeToRainesToRoach

Tiger Legend
Jun 4, 2006
33,186
11,544
Melbourne
The following eight posters share the Charlie Callander award for fronting up every week, win lose or draw, and posting their votes:

Fighting Fury
fuzztiger
JimJessTorp
MB78
mrposhman
Platinum member
Tigers of Old
WesternTiger


24 games - 5 posters
23 games - 8
22 games - 5
21 games - 2
20 games - 4
19 games - 1
18 games - 2
17 games - 5
16 games - 5
14 games - 1
13 games - 2
12 games - 1
11 games - 4
10 games - 1
9 games - 2
8 games - 4
7 games - 4
5 games - 2
4 games - 5
3 games - 5
2 games - 9
1 game - 21

106 voters in all.
 

LeeToRainesToRoach

Tiger Legend
Jun 4, 2006
33,186
11,544
Melbourne
Highest voting posters for each player:

Astbury - Fighting Fury (15)
Bolton - MorrisMinor, Platinum member, tigersnake (1)
Broad - saigon tiger (2)
Butler - saigon tiger (4)
Caddy - MalenyTiger, shawry, taztiger4 (5)
Castagna - arlobill, mainland (5)
Conca - bringbakflemmo (4)
Cotchin - Bullarto Tiger (28)
Edwards - mk33 (6)
Ellis - MB78, scottyturnerscurse (9)
Graham - K3, Tenacious Tiges (2)
Grigg - JimJessTorp (13)
Grimes - Fighting Fury (11)
Houli - Tigers of Old (12)
Lambert - fuzztiger, Tiger Ghost (12)
Lloys - tigerlove (1)
Martin - Jason King (46)
McIntosh - tigerdave (5)
Menadue - Total Tiger (3)
Miles - MorrisMinor (3)
Nankervis - MorrisMinor (14)
Prestia - easy,tiger (13)
Rance - Gypsy__Jazz (27)
Riewoldt - LeeToRainesToRoach (10)
Rioli - Joshnbeks Dad (6)
Short - happytige, MorrisMinor (3)
Townsend - St Kevin, Total Tiger (5)
Vlastuin - happytige (14)
 

MorrisMinor

Tiger Rookie
Mar 24, 2014
277
20
Round 7 vs Bulldogs
Martin 54
Grigg 41
Riewoldt 41
Astbury 40
Rance 38
Cotchin 17
Lambert 4
Houli 2
KMac 2
Butler 1