2019 Punt Road End Player of the Year 2019 Champion Dusin Martin

Sammy Cougar

Goodness Gracious me The Tigers have got Another
Mar 6, 2004
931
33
54
Final Voting for 2019
1585
Dustin Martin
900
Dion Prestia
775
Shane Edwards
634
Bachar Houli
629
Nick Vlastuin
622
Dylan Grimes
585
Tom Lynch
523
Sydney Stack
295
Shai Bolton
283
Trent Cotchin
279
Kane Lambert
219
Toby Nankervis
209
Kamdyn McIntosh
197
Liam Baker
190
Jack Graham
100
Brandon Ellis
92
Jason Castagna
73
Mabior Chol
53
Jack Ross
37
Noah Balta
33
David Astbury
33
Jack Riewoldt
31
Jack Higgins
28
Marlion Pickett
26
Ivan Soldo
23
Connor Menadue
19
Nathan Broad
19
Daniel Rioli
12
Josh Caddy
9
Patrick Naish
3
Derek Eggmolesse-Smith
2
Jayden Short
2
Ryan Garthwaite
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8 users

eZyT

Tiger Legend
Jun 28, 2019
11,115
1,855
Great Work thanks Sammy.

In all seriousness, there should be an actual PRE player of the year medal struck and presented.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users

Gypsy__Jazz

Tiger Champion
Nov 21, 2004
2,520
28
31
Great Work thanks Sammy.

In all seriousness, there should be an actual PRE player of the year medal struck and presented.
Agree, Ezy. Fantastic to see the best player in the AFL win the coveted award in such dominant fashion. He certainly wasn’t taken for granted by PREnders. Personally, I would’ve made him All-Australian captain as well as giving him the Brownlow despite jobbing someone. But not even Dustin Martin can win everything at once.

And thanks again, Sammy C. You’ve done a power of work and it is very much appreciated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users

Harry

Tiger Legend
Mar 2, 2003
19,631
966
a suggestion.

The points get skewed by the number of posters that vote.

The top 5 or so vote getters for the round should be awarded points for the round ie top vote getter gets 5, 2nd 4, 3rd 3, 4th 2 and 5th 1.

This way a player won't get a massive amount of points in one game like dusty in the gf for example.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users

Sammy Cougar

Goodness Gracious me The Tigers have got Another
Mar 6, 2004
931
33
54
a suggestion.

The points get skewed by the number of posters that vote.

The top 5 or so vote getters for the round should be awarded points for the round ie top vote getter gets 5, 2nd 4, 3rd 3, 4th 2 and 5th 1.

This way a player won't get a massive amount of points in one game like dusty in the gf for example.
Idea Taken on Board for 2020
If anymore from anyone else all welcome
 

spook

It is only the intellectually lost who ever argue.
Jun 18, 2007
11,083
1,196
Thanks Sammy, great job again. I'd favour giving 5-4-3-2-1 instead of 3-2-1, but that's probably a bit more work for you!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

Sammy Cougar

Goodness Gracious me The Tigers have got Another
Mar 6, 2004
931
33
54
Thanks Sammy, great job again. I'd favour giving 5-4-3-2-1 instead of 3-2-1, but that's probably a bit more work for you!
i was thinking about trying The 5 4 3 2 1 Voting system this year but in the end a lot more work so i may try it next year
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

hutstar

Tiger Superstar
Dec 17, 2002
1,895
87
Florida
a suggestion.

The points get skewed by the number of posters that vote.

The top 5 or so vote getters for the round should be awarded points for the round ie top vote getter gets 5, 2nd 4, 3rd 3, 4th 2 and 5th 1.

This way a player won't get a massive amount of points in one game like dusty in the gf for example.
Perfectly reasonable Harry, but the current method is different and interesting, because it does skew based on the result or importance of the game. I like that being the best player in a big win is worth more than the best player in a poor loss- at least I like it in our voting as a point of difference.
I do think 3-2-1 isn’t great, but I think 5-1 isn’t much better.
 

UKTiger

Tiger Champion
Jul 11, 2010
4,589
418
Shipston on Stour, UK
To semi quote Monty Python in the Life of Brian. Just what has Dustin Martin done for us as a club? All he has done to date is be BOG countless times, two permierships, two Norm Smiths, one Brownlow, one Leigh Mathews trophy, one AFLCA champion player, three AA’s , two Jack Dyer’s, two Gary Ayres, two Yipoken’s, two Ian Stewarts and two under 22 teams. I am sure I have missed something out but it just shows what a freak player he is and we are so lucky to have such a loyal guy in out playing group
 

LeeToRainesToRoach

Get out Gillon
Jun 4, 2006
23,799
994
Melbourne
Idea Taken on Board for 2020
If anymore from anyone else all welcome
Each player scores his percentage of total votes per round, e.g.

Round 1 - 64 voters provide a 3-2-1

Martin 175 votes
Prestia 88
Nankervis 52
Vlastuin 40
Cotchin 16
Pickett 7
McIntosh 5
Short 1

Martin scores 175 / (64 x 6) = 46% = 46 points
Prestia 23%
Nankervis 14%
Vlastuin 10%
Cotchin 4%
Pickett 2%
McIntosh 1%
Short 0%

Votes total 100 each round, no matter how many people vote. The most a player can poll in a round is 50 (if everyone gives him the 3).

If you want to get fancy, make losses total 90 votes and wins total 110.
 

Tigers of Old

Twitter: @Tigers_of_Old
Jul 26, 2004
64,225
1,261
Fair discrepancy once again between the PRE & JDM.
Dusty wins ours by a street, yet polls sixth in the JDM...

Thanks Sammy for running the tally over the course of the year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user