Alistair Neville | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Alistair Neville

rinso17

Tiger Superstar
Feb 2, 2005
1,812
151
Has Neville fallen right off the radar? No mention of him for months.
He is ready to play round one! Why no interest?
 
According to the recent "permission to train" list on AFL web site he is training with Melbourne.
 
the last thing we need. an expert ball destroyer/killer.
'He cant kick' for all you simpletons!
 
Bengal said:
the last thing we need. an expert ball destroyer/killer.
'He cant kick' for all you simpletons!


The games I saw on TV playing for Coburg - I AGREE !! He gets plenty of the ball but his "whoofy" kicking lets him down !
 
Cutterst said:
The games I saw on TV playing for Coburg - I AGREE !! He gets plenty of the ball but his "whoofy" kicking lets him down !

not only that, he's slow. a good vfl player but will never make it at AFL level
 
We've got Rainsey, Petts and Richo who have got "the hospital pass" down to a fine art.
I think we should steer clear.
 
Tigerman91 said:
agree neville is a very good player

At VFL level. Alistair hasnt played at AFL but may be rookied by another club possibly Demons or even the Saints.

Wont be taken by Tigers imo.

Likes of Collard and Gourdis will be taken in front of him.
 
From al accounts Gourids is up himself and a bit o f a c**k.. Lets get him! we need a bit of that at the tigers!!
 
McGinnity or Collard over Neville and Howat thanx.

Gourdis worth a shot too as a rookie no harm in giving him a run.
 
we wont get gourdis and collard, its one or the other imo

dont mind neville myself, would take him over howat anyday
 
Yes when looking at the bigger picture Rocky ... i dont believe the Tigers will get both either, but i wouldnt say its impossible as only 6 players will be taken PSD unless im wrong on that score but i believe only 6.

McGinnity may probably go to Windy Hill and Dogs have pretty much committed to Welsh, all depends on who the Blues will sniff at i reckon as to what show the tigs have of snatching both boys.

To get 2 of Collard, Gourdis, Pfieffer and McGinnity would be a very good result.

Others such as Renton, Casey Leigh could be looked at also for Rookie spots.

No Howat ffs.
 
There is something just quite not right about Gourdis. Don't know what it is but gut feeling says that there are some underlying issues that have kept clubs away from committing to this kid. Thats why I think we will go Collard with Pick 1 in the PSD with the view of Gourdis falling to the Rookie Draft which we then will snap him up.
 
IrockZ said:
we wont get gourdis and collard, its one or the other imo
Collard wasn't taken in the National Draft as a recycled player, so why would he be such a monty for the PSD?
There will only be about 4 kids taken in the PSD as half the teams will take more mature players, I think it's very likely that we'll get both Gourdis & Collard, but Gourdis has to take priority
 
Gourdis won't get past the WCE. He wasn't taken by them in the national as all there picks where way too high. If he is available i think he will be an eagle. Also if the Dons take Bellchambers or Arrowsmith, look for Freo to take McGinnity.