ARC Appeal

[Bennnny]

You nailed it YT.

But it's not.

 

[achillesjones]

If a Field umpire makes a silly mistake and gives a fifty for a certain goal, we bleat for a while, then move on...
Why are goal umpires not allowed to make an occasional error?
Ditch the arc and we will all watch in anticipation for the double hand signal and rejoice like we used to. Right when it happens.
Waiting for peanuts to adjudicate with dodgy inconclusive technology adds an unnecessary anti-climactic and ugly layer to our game.

 

[graystar1]

If a Field umpire makes a silly mistake and gives a fifty for a certain goal, we bleat for a while, then move on...
Why are goal umpires not allowed to make an occasional error?
Ditch the arc and we will all watch in anticipation for the double hand signal and rejoice like we used to. Right when it happens.
Waiting for peanuts to adjudicate with dodgy inconclusive technology adds an unnecessary anti-climactic and ugly layer to our game.

Could not agree more.

 

[TigerMasochist]

Easy solved ….just have 50 metre high posts

Too much flex in a breeze, you'd have the goal posts flappin about trying to swat the footy like it was some kind of large dunny budgie goin past.

 

[Quickdraw]

Too much flex in a breeze, you'd have the goal posts flappin about trying to swat the footy like it was some kind of large dunny budgie goin past.

Lasers?

or

“sharks with *smile*’ laser beams attached to their heads.”

 

[Stackey]

If a Field umpire makes a silly mistake and gives a fifty for a certain goal, we bleat for a while, then move on...
Why are goal umpires not allowed to make an occasional error?
Ditch the arc and we will all watch in anticipation for the double hand signal and rejoice like we used to. Right when it happens.
Waiting for peanuts to adjudicate with dodgy inconclusive technology adds an unnecessary anti-climactic and ugly layer to our game.

Just use the Goal umpire...it's traditional!

 

[gold1]

Currently only 15m high. Would need to be more than 3 times it's current height!

The flagpoles off the West Gate should cover it!

 

[Stackey]

The flagpoles off the West Gate should cover it!

Goal umps will need binoculars to see if the footy goes over their top!!!

 

[gold1]

Goal umps will need binoculars to see if the footy goes over their top!!!

Ah,but that is where the AFL will use drones.

 

[TT33]

Ah,but that is where the AFL will use drones.

And triangulation

 

[Willo]

Goal umps will need binoculars to see if the footy goes over their top!!!

AFL supply only
One each for:
OOF, touched, behind, goal

 

[Razorgang2]

Lasers?

or

“sharks with *smile*’ laser beams attached to their heads.”
View attachment 17795

Like it.

 

[The Big Richo]

If a Field umpire makes a silly mistake and gives a fifty for a certain goal, we bleat for a while, then move on...
Why are goal umpires not allowed to make an occasional error?
Ditch the arc and we will all watch in anticipation for the double hand signal and rejoice like we used to. Right when it happens.
Waiting for peanuts to adjudicate with dodgy inconclusive technology adds an unnecessary anti-climactic and ugly layer to our game.

Because people are sooks and the moment a mistake is made it will be bleated about for days with the constant carping about a 'professional competition' and 'what if it costs someone a Grand Final one day?'.

 

[Stackey]

Because people are sooks and the moment a mistake is made it will be bleated about for days with the constant carping about a 'professional competition' and 'what if it costs someone a Grand Final one day?'.

Well it certainly did just that!

 

[The Big Richo]

Well it certainly did just that!

You could have been the difference if you pulled your head in Sydney!