Barry Hall for 2 years

[kb7882]

Simmonds at CHB :rofl

Playing on who ? Mick Nolan ?

 

[CoachSheedy]

Simmonds at CHB :rofl

Playing on who ? Mick Nolan ?

Well instead of knocking others ideas mr HartBalme why dont u think up some answers. Do you think?

 

[Massai]

1. Great foil for Mitch and Jack whilst they learn the trade
2. the tough nut we need, and would make the others stand taller (we don't protect our own, a la jacko on the weekend)
3. Not as bad as Cousins misdeamenours

thoughts pls folks as if it was my decsion I would take him whilst releasing Brown

Not as bad as Cousins misdemeanors, you've got to be kidding yourself. What Cousins did was off the field, what Hall does is on the field, striking out at players for no reason, yep fantastic example of a fair player NOT.

Hall is a ticking timebomb, he's got some issues of that there is no doubt. The Swans have obviously tried to address those issues with Hall, but thus far it hasn't worked out for either of them.

I don't think Hall going to a new club would work either. As for coming to Richmond, lets get off this trading crap once and for all. I for one would not trade a draft pick (even if it was Round 4) for Hall, the focus at our club should be "develop our own players", not pick up retreads McMuffin being a case in point and yes Hall is a far superior player but his tribunal record in my book goes totally against him.

 

[kb7882]

It's been said over and over, Mr. CoachSheedy-peanut.

Draft kids and play them. We've already started with Vickery and Silvester, and Post coming in this week. That's how you get KPP's, not playing slow ruckmen at CHB.

 

[CoachSheedy]

Gee that was very thought provoking plan. Did you think of that one. Id rather win games while we developing kids. You need balance of experience and youth.

 

[Al Bundy]

This is a joke I hope. If not


NO !

 

[kb7882]

OK genius.

Go get Barry Hall.

Then go get a Sandilands/Ottens ruckman.

Then go get a "career full back". Which one would you like ? Scarlett ? Rutten ? Glass ?

Now tell me what we have to give up to get these players. Cotchin + Riewoldt + our first 5 draft picks should almost do it.

Fair dinkum mate, get a grip :

 

[chislop]

1. Great foil for Mitch and Jack whilst they learn the trade
2. the tough nut we need, and would make the others stand taller (we don't protect our own, a la jacko on the weekend)
3. Not as bad as Cousins misdeamenours

thoughts pls folks as if it was my decsion I would take him whilst releasing Brown

I'd rather eat my liver than see Bawwy Hall at the Toigs.

 

[Chiang Mai Tiger]

I was hoping this thread was about the Thug going 'inside' for 2 years.