Blair's Boys - 2012 Trade Week Targets | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Blair's Boys - 2012 Trade Week Targets

How's about this:

Delist: Derickx, Graham, White, Webberley, McGuane, Connors, McDonald, Miller, A.Maric, Wright
Newman veteran off the list.

Trade: Alex Rance for Jack Steven and Sam Blease (no idea how it would work)
Restricted Free Agent: Troy Chaplin
PSD: Jesse White (no idea about contract situation)

Use draft picks on midfielders and HFFs, use rookie picks on a ruckman, and midfielders.

Boom, September '13 rollin'.
 
Is Harper out of contract? He would be right up there for me. Game breaker.

Blease, Steven, Chaplin all good gets too.
 
Potential end of year trades i would look at:

Crowley (Hard bodied midfielder, hasnt signed a contract yet), Sam Blease (Real gamebreaker), Shannon Byrnes (free agent, good small forward), Brent Maloney (out of contract, hard bodied midfielder, would add some serious depth).
 
TuesdayswithTerry said:
Would have been good to get Steven at the end of last year. His currency would have gone up a bit this year.

There is no way steven is leaving. We need a line breaker like him though. Hardworker aswell.
 
Giardiasis said:
How's about this:

Delist: Derickx, Graham, White, Webberley, McGuane, Connors, McDonald, Miller, A.Maric, Wright
Newman veteran off the list.

Trade: Alex Rance for Jack Steven and Sam Blease (no idea how it would work)
Restricted Free Agent: Troy Chaplin
PSD: Jesse White (no idea about contract situation)

Use draft picks on midfielders and HFFs, use rookie picks on a ruckman, and midfielders.

Boom, September '13 rollin'.

Jesse White will be delisted so we could pick him up as a Free Agent. Don't think he's much good tbh.
No chance in hell we will trade Rance.
Piva Wright would be stiff too I think. We would have taken him on knowing he'd take more than 1 year. The rest I agree with though.
 
No chance of getting Steven or Blease. Melbourne supporters would revolt if the latter happened. Might be a chance to get Sylvia though. Pettard also seems out of favour, who I thought could play.

Jesse White will be got for steak knives. He's an athlete thats never progressed though. Kicked 5 goals against us once at the G and looked good. Never went on with it.

Otherwise best to look at who's not getting games at the better clubs and go after them (e.g. Maric last year).
 
Tigers2011 said:
No chance of getting Steven or Blease. Melbourne supporters would revolt if the latter happened. Might be a chance to get Sylvia though. Pettard also seems out of favour, who I thought could play.

Jesse White will be got for steak knives. He's an athlete thats never progressed though. Kicked 5 goals against us once at the G and looked good. Never went on with it.

Otherwise best to look at who's not getting games at the better clubs and go after them (e.g. Maric last year).

Lewis Stevenson.
 
tigs2010 said:
Jesse White will be delisted so we could pick him up as a Free Agent. Don't think he's much good tbh.
No chance in hell we will trade Rance.
Piva Wright would be stiff too I think. We would have taken him on knowing he'd take more than 1 year. The rest I agree with though.
I'd bring in JW as a depth player, ruck and forward. Think of an upgraded Miller.

For list balance I think one of Wright and Darrou should be moved on.

If we could pull a Barry Hall style trade for Rance, we could plug a big chunk of our midfield problem.
 
Sylvia is not a free agent which must mean he is contracted but if Melbourne were willing to trade for him and we could get the right deal I would do it. He would be a very good player for us surrounded by Lids, Cotch, Dusty and Foley.
 
Smoking Aces said:
Will Minson - Doggies offering a 1 year contract. Give him 2 years and let him help out Maric.

Minson is strictly a first ruck IMO, has no smarts at all around the ground. And nowhere near Maric as a first ruck. Would prefer Roughead from the bulldogs, has flexibility to relief ruck and play forward.
 
Big Cat Lover said:
Minson is strictly a first ruck IMO, has no smarts at all around the ground. And nowhere near Maric as a first ruck. Would prefer Roughead from the bulldogs, has flexibility to relief ruck and play forward.
I am thinking of Minson as a cheap back up. Bash and crash type. But if we do go down that path we must make sure that we draft/trade in another developing ruckman.
 
Its very hard to get a ruckman across when he knows he will play second fiddle. Why would Minson leave when he is guaranteed first ruck duties at the Dogs.
 
Not really the fringe type any more eh?

Agree though. We need to trust Browne or recruit from the state leagues to solve the back up ruck problem. Vickery is also the big unknown here. If he gets back on track he's automatically next in line and a very good alternative.
 
Don't know too much of him but Cruise Gartlett always seems to be in the bests for the Roos 2nds.
Cheap midfield depth player perhaps?
 
Disco08 said:
Not really the fringe type any more eh?

Just about any other club he is.

Good point on Vickery, he shouldnt be forgotten in future ruck talks. Think thats where he ends up in a few years.