Brando Compo | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Brando Compo

Odd he mentioned what Hawks got for Franklin but neglected to mention the Frawley compo pick for Melbourne. Must have been an oversight.
Didn't Gaddy Loin chops Smelbourne team get pick 3 for Chip Frawdley? Was outrageous when compared to the compo that Hawforn got for losing Flanklin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I should point out, we don't make the rules, however, rules are rules until changed. Compo pick in first round, bring it on!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I should point out, we don't make the rules, however, rules are rules until changed. Compo pick in first round, bring it on!

But the rules state the AFL can make it up as they go along
 
But the rules state the AFL can make it up as they go along

So true Baloo.

Watch them come up with a different formula this year to disadvantage us !

AFL house will make sure the commission or whoever decides the compo make sure it’s a second round.
 
Is there any commentary at the moment about Daniher supposedly being worth two top 10 picks? Who would be stupid enough to do that. The bloke is cooked.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Not only Garry Lyon Harry, Damian Barrett and Mitch Cleary even got a Podcast campaigning against likely compensation :mad:

"IT'S A MESS"

Listen back to AFL.com.au's Mitch Cleary and Damian Barrett on the free agency compensation system this morning.

"Richmond has been dominant for three seasons. To lose Brandon Ellis and get a first round pick... it's everything that is wrong with free agency."


Ain't it great being hated again;) :

Whatttttt????

So we get Tom Lynch for free and they whinge - This is whats wrong with free agency they said last year, the top clubs get stronger as they can sign the best players
Fast forward 12 months and we have a player that we would prefer to keep poached from us so we should get some compo and now - This is whats wrong with free agency.

But but I thought what was wrong with free agency was when the big clubs can sign who they want, but when one of the big clubs lose their players to FA its also whats wrong with FA!! Can't have it both ways!!

There is either free agency or there isn't, they need to go and complain to the players association who wanted this in the first place.

Also, Buddy left the Hawks in 2013 just after the hawks had won the minor premiership and had also won the GF. There was no outcry then about the best team getting a 1st round pick, in fact the narrative in the media was that the pick 19 they got wasn't enough!!

Crazy times we live in, I can hear Yoda in the background. Fear leads to anger, anger leads to hate, hate leads to suffering. Yoda's a genius, everyone fears is and are angry about it leading to their suffering (and the Tigers joy).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I think we're still the only side to finish last and not get the number 1 pick?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I think we're still the only side to finish last and not get the number 1 pick?
Did it twice, didn’t we? Once to Cartoon (they got Kreuzer and we got Cotchin) then Egobourne (they got Scully AND Trengove and we got Martin). Karma is such a *smile*.
 
  • Love
Reactions: 1 user
Tiger John Ralph is stating it as fact that we will get pick 20. (Which we should). But I recall he also stated as fact that Toby Greene would get off on appeal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
For goodness sakes I hope the AFL don't listen to these cretins.

Just have a look at the player we're losing, he's a 1st round draft pick, is 26 has played 176 games, is a 2 times Premiership Player, was 3 times nominated for the best under 22 year old team in the AFL, was runner up for our B&F & is entering into the Prime of his career. He is of exceptional character.

We're not talking about a bloke who MAY become a good player, he already IS a very good player, who the RFC would rather NOT lose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
I think I have just figured out what is wrong with free agency- Richmond have won two flags in three years.
that is it- two flags in three years. Not one in four, or 2 in 9.

TWO. IN THREE YEARS!!!!!!!!

I kid you not, they have won the Premiership twice, no less, in three years.

Does anyone want me to repeat this? I know it is a challenging concept.

And I blame free agency.

I also blame the fact that they beat all their rivals for the flag during August and September. Some of them twice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
I think I have just figured out what is wrong with free agency- Richmond have won two flags in three years.
that is it- two flags in three years. Not one in four, or 2 in 9.

TWO. IN THREE YEARS!!!!!!!!

I kid you not, they have won the Premiership twice, no less, in three years.

Does anyone want me to repeat this? I know it is a challenging concept.

And I blame free agency.

I also blame the fact that they beat all their rivals for the flag during August and September. Some of them twice.
I also blame our habit of finding gold in the last 50 picks of each draft.

The system is a rort.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Is there any commentary at the moment about Daniher supposedly being worth two top 10 picks? Who would be stupid enough to do that. The bloke is cooked.

Exactly Tigerflag!

If the Swans are stupid to pay Essendon 2 first round picks for a player who has barely played in 2 years, well what can i say.

Essendon will try and drive a hard bargain with their list manager whatever his name is but the Swans should hold firm.

At the end of the day Daniher is contracted so Essendon may have to stick with liability still.
Swans should stand firm.
 
I should point out, we don't make the rules, however, rules are rules until changed. Compo pick in first round, bring it on!

I saw that idiot Barrett going on about it would be all wrong if we got a 1st round compo for Brando despite the current AFL rules
 
  • Wow
Reactions: 1 user