Brayden Shaw?

[crackertiger]

Vic Metro captain, plenty of potential. Seems to be a victim of the Tony Shaw v Collingwood War.

Worth a look in my opinion!

Invite him to training and see how he performs.

 

[geoffryprettyboy]

This has been discussed on an earlier thread.

No rejects, has been tryed.

 

[craig]

NO THANX.

 

[mb64]

Discussed before-pass.

 

[Stuart]

This has been discussed on an earlier thread.

No rejects, has been tryed.

Fair enough, though hadn't Shane Tuck been tried at Hawthorn.
Let him train with us, doesn't cost anything & if he shows a bit, he could be a late selection or a rookie list option.
Plenty of players over the years for plenty of reasons haven't made it at the first club & have gone on to have decent careers.
Worth a look, better to have a look & know he isn't up to it rather than be negligent & just say no straight out.

 

[WesternTiger]

This has been discussed on an earlier thread.

No rejects, has been tryed.

Fair enough, though hadn't Shane Tuck been tried at Hawthorn.
Let him train with us, doesn't cost anything & if he shows a bit, he could be a late selection or a rookie list option.
Plenty of players over the years for plenty of reasons haven't made it at the first club & have gone on to have decent careers.
Worth a look, better to have a look & know he isn't up to it rather than be negligent & just say no straight out.

The difference there is Shane Tuck went to the SANFL and worked his arse off for a season before we picked him up

 

[Stuart]

This has been discussed on an earlier thread.

No rejects, has been tryed.

Fair enough, though hadn't Shane Tuck been tried at Hawthorn.
Let him train with us, doesn't cost anything & if he shows a bit, he could be a late selection or a rookie list option.
Plenty of players over the years for plenty of reasons haven't made it at the first club & have gone on to have decent careers.
Worth a look, better to have a look & know he isn't up to it rather than be negligent & just say no straight out.

The difference there is Shane Tuck went to the SANFL and worked his arse off for a season before we picked him up

Yes, we all know that.
What I am saying is that just because a player has been elsewhere doesn't mean we should not even consider them.

 

[the claw]

Vic Metro captain, plenty of potential. Seems to be a victim of the Tony Shaw v Collingwood War.

Worth a look in my opinion!

Invite him to training and see how he performs.

cracker having seen very little of this guy almost nothing in fact i have 3 very simple questions for you.with the shaw name obviously he plays small so firstly does he have good pace 2nd does he have good skills and 3rd can he find the footy.if he has these 3 basics maybe then some one can then go and have a closer look at him ie vision awareness aerobic capacity etc.

 

[mainlandy]

CT, surely the tiges will not consider this? A home grown player who does not make it his club surely will not be picked up by another club? (exception tuck). Bad move IMO.

 

[craig]

??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? ??? :-X :-X :-X :-X :-X :-X :-X :-X :-X :-X :-X :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\ :-\