Brian Taylor???

[Bill James]

I counted about 4 Menadues. :clap

Menadue, Short and Rioli........... I must have missed one.

 

[Tames]

He's just lazy. Thinks he can turn up and call a game, without knowing who is who.

Huddo the best caller by far.

 

[Silent Bob]

I must be the odd one out coz i like his call.

 

[Tigerhealer]

i liked his call too , especially when Lloyd kicked the winner
Bristol sounded genuinely excited that the tigers won

 

[Chiang Mai Tiger]

If he says 'hand candy' once more I'll jump on the next plane to Australia and thump him!

 

[Tenacious]

I must be the odd one out coz i like his call.

Always thought I was in a minority of one - but maybe there's two of us!

 

[CarnTheTiges]

Most of them seemed to get Lloyd and Rioli confused. The just see a small player and the number 7 and take a guess. BT was better than usual the other night. Seemed to stay on the right edge of hysteria and didn't make too many stupid comments or needle his fellow commentators. Possibly because the game was close for most of the night.

 

[realtiger]

Boy o boy !!! What are u talking about ? BT is the best caller in the game . He's exciting and passionate! Seriously it was an amazing call! Loved every second!

 

[LeeToRainesToRoach]

Credit where due, a great call the other night. Made it seem like a big game. Makes a huge difference when they're not focusing on Richmond's errors all the time.

Most of them seemed to get Lloyd and Rioli confused. The just see a small player and the number 7 and take a guess.

I've done that a few times this year!

 

[Bunnerz]

Each too their own but i prefer Bruce over Brian anyday.

 

[Sintiger]

I thought his calling at the end was pretty good. Darcy on the other hand was cringeworthy

 

[bringbakflemmo]

Repetitive sayings, loud and doesn't know the players (bit like big Rex when he was on his way down).
Agree with others that he and Zemplis are ordinary commentators.

 

[tigerlove]

I prefer commentators who know who the players are and knows how to describe the game accurately and can provide some insight. I am not interested in the theatrics of commentators, for me its about the game not the commentator.

 

[smasha]

Didn't mind bristle.
Christian on 3aw was the best.
They played all the calls on AFL 360 and Christian went orrrff and he's a Collingwood man.

 

[acatman]

I prefer commentators who know who the players are and knows how to describe the game accurately and can provide some insight. I am not interested in the theatrics of commentators, for me its about the game not the commentator.

THIS, though lets not forget the top rating shows on tv are contrived reality shows, thats the mentality that they aim at these days.
My fav BT was the other week when he said coach "x" was going to implode from the inside!!!! :spin

 

[yandb]

Average commentator, meh.

 

[Harry]

Average commentator, meh.

Disagree. His *smile*.

 

[TOT70]

Credit where due, a great call the other night. Made it seem like a big game. Makes a huge difference when they're not focusing on Richmond's errors all the time.

It never ceases to amaze me how lazy commentators can be. How often do they see a Richmond turnover and start a rant about Richmond turnovers, whilst the images on the screen show the other team turning it back over. This, of course, passes without comment.

 

[Tigers of Old]

I was at the ground and there were no commentators. Much better.

 

[Ian4]

doing Friday nights