Cast offs?

[Inspector]

Most of these players are bit part players at their clubs maybe except for White who is 30 Hansen not fit & Charmen just seeing if anyone thinks any of them would be benefit the Tigers? My thoughts maybe Charmen & Moore Charmen being a tough big ruckman who likes to throw his weight around & can go forward & Moore similar type to Foley(not as quick) hasn't had the chance due to Bolton Kirk Buchanan Ablett etc.

 

[IanG]

Charman and Wood are the only 2 who are worth it.

 

[Inspector]

Charman and Wood are the only 2 who are worth it.

Seems that way along with Hansen according to the votes.

 

[King of the Jungle]

Think we need a strong second ruck who can move forward & get his own ball Hale, Charmen & White might be worth a go for 2 years?

 

[Phar Ace]

Young Max Bailey is coming along nicely

 

[nccc]

Charman the only one from this list I would be keen on. He would be a great foil for Simmonds. Is only 24 or 25, goes in hard, has pretty good skills and is also capable of a bobbing up with a goal or two. Make him an offer and hopefully get in preseason draft.

A few other names that I didn't see on list:

Ess :
Angus Monfries

Geel :
Kane Tenace
David Johnson
Josh Hunt
Tim Callan

StK :
Barry Brooks
James Gwilt

WB:
Wayde Skipper

Port:
Damon White
Brad Symes

Frem:
Ryan Murphy
Andrew Browne
Marcus Drum

Hope there's no double ups there with original list

I'm not saying any of these blokes (or those on original list either) would be the answer, but let's face it, there should be several spots on our list available. A trade or two wouldn't do any harm... Maybe Krakouer, *smile* and some draft swaps with Port for Symes???

 

[craig]

Charman the only one from this list I would be keen on. He would be a great foil for Simmonds. Is only 24 or 25, goes in hard, has pretty good skills and is also capable of a bobbing up with a goal or two. Make him an offer and hopefully get in preseason draft.

A few other names that I didn't see on list:

Ess :
Angus Monfries - They wont trade him

Geel :
Kane Tenace - Soft as, and cant kick
David Johnson - Good player wont be traded
Josh Hunt - Good skills but has been found out dropping his head and shirking, now rated as Soft down at Corio
Tim Callan - not worth trading for

StK :
Barry Brooks - Slow - injury prone dud
James Gwilt - No Thanx

WB:
Wayde Skipper Dud

Port:
Damon White Wouldnt be traded
Brad Symes Wouldnt be traded

Frem:
Ryan Murphy Wont be traded
Andrew Browne Wont be traded
Marcus Drum Wont be traded

Hope there's no double ups there with original list

I'm not saying any of these blokes (or those on original list either) would be the answer, but let's face it, there should be several spots on our list available. A trade or two wouldn't do any harm... Maybe Krakouer, *smile* and some draft swaps with Port for Symes???

 

[taraba]

Young Max Bailey is coming along nicely

How's that when he's out for the year with a knee injury?

 

[nccc]

Charman the only one from this list I would be keen on. He would be a great foil for Simmonds. Is only 24 or 25, goes in hard, has pretty good skills and is also capable of a bobbing up with a goal or two. Make him an offer and hopefully get in preseason draft.

A few other names that I didn't see on list:

Ess :
Angus Monfries - They wont trade him

Geel :
Kane Tenace - Soft as, and cant kick
David Johnson - Good player wont be traded
Josh Hunt - Good skills but has been found out dropping his head and shirking, now rated as Soft down at Corio
Tim Callan - not worth trading for

StK :
Barry Brooks - Slow - injury prone dud
James Gwilt - No Thanx

WB:
Wayde Skipper Dud

Port:
Damon White Wouldnt be traded
Brad Symes Wouldnt be traded

Frem:
Ryan Murphy Wont be traded
Andrew Browne Wont be traded
Marcus Drum Wont be traded

Hope there's no double ups there with original list

I'm not saying any of these blokes (or those on original list either) would be the answer, but let's face it, there should be several spots on our list available. A trade or two wouldn't do any harm... Maybe Krakouer, *smile* and some draft swaps with Port for Symes???

So what about a big go at Charman then?

 

[Inspector]

Charmen will be a target Monfries would be a good get!!

 

[nccc]

With new coach coming in at Demons, will there be a purge and maybe a player or two let go that might be worth looking at?

Carlton and Freo too maybe.........

 

[feisty tige]

Hansen and Wood.

 

[casper68]

wood only forget the rest

 

[tigers#7]

I dont want or like him, but Carroll?

 

[tannerztigers]

I dont want or like him, but Carroll?

I like Carroll, but i think that Melbourne will keep him.

 

[Turbo Tiger]

Nathan Lovett-Murray is just what we need. Another soft outside player with skills...

 

[craig]

No way known Sheedy would trade Lovett-Murray.

 

[tannerztigers]

There are some ok players been thrown up here, but the reality is that least 80% of these players wont leave their clubs.