Changes v Cats | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Changes v Cats

bowden4president said:
Is Broad really that fast? Grimes ran past him like he was standing still in the chase down tackle on the weekend

maybe he was slow cause he was sore?

Ive always thought of Broady as pretty quick.

our depth is being tested, but we still have some *smile* good player IN, and geelong arent that good.
 
easy said:
maybe he was slow cause he was sore?

Ive always thought of Broady as pretty quick.

our depth is being tested, but we still have some *smile*ing good player IN, and geelong arent that good.

Yeah thought same on broady. Our depth is being tested for sure. That has it benefits, and is better happen when 2 games clear on top. I don't think menadue is soft, no towner of course but not soft. And he has pace. I'm OK with that in. But as a whole yes a lot of fringe players in at once.
 
easy said:
maybe he was slow cause he was sore?

Ive always thought of Broady as pretty quick.

our depth is being tested, but we still have some *smile*ing good player IN, and geelong arent that good.

This is the salient part ET. Tiges by 23 points for me. Cant see Tom being dominent against Rance/Grimes, and we have no crumbers in the forward line
 
acatman1 said:
This is the salient part ET. Tiges by 23 points for me. Cant see Tom being dominent against Rance/Grimes, and we have no crumbers in the forward line
Haaarrrrgh! You're about as optimistic as my little bro acatman.

Told him he should be looking forward to a five goal win considering half our mids n a couple of handy others were out n he's happy praying for a one point win while whingeing about that old pensioner Taylor not playing.
 
acatman1 said:
This is the salient part ET. Tiges by 23 points for me. Cant see Tom being dominent against Rance/Grimes, and we have no crumbers in the forward line

Is Pricky Scott trying to beat us by playing Abbott? (i.e. 2 ruckmen against Nanks)
 
Baron Samedi said:
Ellis will go back for broad. KMac defensive winger. Menadue offensive winger.

Ellis is already playing back, keeping Houli's spot warm.

Menadue will play back tomorrow night.
 
Menadue make or break for him tomorrow night. Got to get his hands dirty from whoa to go.
 
Is Scott still pissed at Dimma for contributing to ruining the Lions 4 peat?

Can't figure the *smile* out.

Maybe he's just a *smile*.
 
Could it be that one of the sub plots in the Lynch recruitment has us transferring a couple of pretty good fringe players in Lloyd and Menadue to GC in return for a mid range draft pick and that one of the reasons for playing them both tomorrow is to get them worked up for their audition the following week?
 
James said:
Could it be that one of the sub plots in the Lynch recruitment has us transferring a couple of pretty good fringe players in Lloyd and Menadue to GC in return for a mid range draft pick and that one of the reasons for playing them both tomorrow is to get them worked up for their audition the following week?
No.
 
mad_tiggy911 said:
Is Scott still p!ssed at Dimma for contributing to ruining the Lions 4 peat?

Can't figure the *smile* out.

Maybe he's just a *smile*.

Maybe Scott sacking Blake who then came to us and helped us win the GF has something to do with it
 
And Hardwick on cue....(although he does use 'them' and 'they're')

Firing Tomahawk gives Rance the chance to dance with a worthy foe
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/nrl/firing-tomahawk-gives-rance-the-chance-to-dance-with-a-worthy-foe/news-story/8a36a002e4400db5d88ceb064dd6384c


The prospect of champion defender Alex Rance manning Geelong spearhead Tom Hawkins at the MCG tonight shapes as a throwback to the great battles of last century when prolific goal-kickers were the biggest names in the game.
But as intriguing as that battle may be, Richmond coach Damien Hardwick yesterday said it was far from certain the match-up would occur.
Hawkins became the first forward since North Melbourne’s Drew Petrie in 2012 to kick at least seven goals in consecutive weeks, in a pair of matchwinning performances against Melbourne and Brisbane.
As a result, he has closed to within five goals of Coleman Medal leader Ben Brown with four weeks to go and Hardwick is mindful of just how well the 30-year-old is performing.

“He’s in great form, isn’t he? He is that beacon down forward,” he said.

“I think he maybe kicked three the last time we played them. He’s such a good player, he only needs five or six kicks to damage a game. That’s what good players do.”

But just as Geelong face the toughest task in football tonight by tackling the record-breaking Tigers, who have won 18 matches in succession at the MCG, there is no more difficult prospect for a forward than being manned by Rance.
The 28-year-old is the current All Australian captain and has been named at full-back in the nominal representative time since 2014. St Kilda legend Nick Riewoldt said the key for Hawkins was to continue “really launching into the footy” as his teammates were kicking towards him.

But he also said Hawkins teammates needed to provide assistance opening space in attack for the spearhead to roam and ensure their kicking towards him was advantageous.
“The chemistry between himself, the timing of his leads and the chemistry up the field (is important),” Riewoldt said of Fox Footy’s AFL 360.

“Some of the kicks up the field from (Mitch) Duncan and (Joel) Selwood and (Patrick) Dangerfield have been unbelievable. But it is incumbent on his teammates to make sure this continues to happen, or they allow it to happen.

“He needs his teammates to play really smart football this week if he is to continue the same way he is going, because if you are dumb or lazy as forward against the Tigers, then they are so good at creating issues for your teammates.”

Rance tends to play closer to goal or in an intercepting role, which means that if Hawkins roams further afield, he will almost certainly be manned by David Astbury, while Dylan Grimes also has a key role to play.
And Geelong has options including Daniel Menzel or Dangerfield, should he be used forward, who are also capable of mesmerising football in attack.

“We’ve got to make sure we pay attention to Tom, but they’ve got some really capable players up in that forward part of the ground that can kick goals,” Hardwick said.

“So it won’t be focused purely on Tom. It will be a team-based approach for us.”