-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Changes v Skunks
- Thread starter craig
- Start date
I think Broady may be an out, courtesy of the mro.
I think we need some pace and run in. Who? Unsure
I think we need some pace and run in. Who? Unsure
Se
From half forward averaging 17 dis 1 goal,that's pretty good.
Really out dusty,he normally takes 6 rounds to play well, is very hard to beat 1 on 1 and beautiful delivery.
From half forward averaging 17 dis 1 goal,that's pretty good.
Its only a stupid act because the AFLs rules are so *smile*.
If the bloke wasnt knocked out, nothing happens.
And if broady does a soft half tackle, we all call him soft.
Whats he suppose to do? A mid-tackle MRI for brain tethering strength?
In the context of the rules and where concussion is at politically and medically,
He'll get 2 weeks, and im ok with it.
However, they say you cant chose to bump,
Broady didnt -he tackled
K Pickett got 2 for choosing to bump but no concussion,
The crow got 3 for choosing to bump but with concussion.
Logic should dictates the decision to not tackle is 2 and concussion is 1
So broad should be 1?
But its a circus.
Pull out a bazooka and if the blokes not concussed, it all good.
Concuss a bloke with a gentle breath on the cheek, and you get a fortnight.
Its not protecting the head at all,
Its revenge for hurting the head.
You're more reasonable than that Ezy, he had made a hard tackle just fine, he didn't need to make the second motion and slam him.
Thought Young and Ryan did enough to play again.
Broad will be out and I'd promote Mansell to the 22.
Assuming Hopper and Dustin come up I'd leave it at that.
Broad will be out and I'd promote Mansell to the 22.
Assuming Hopper and Dustin come up I'd leave it at that.
To be clear,
I think its worth a week, i wont be outraged if he gets 2.
I beleive the head needs protecting.
I was responding to the idea broady committed a stupid act.
I think it was a hard tackle gone dangerously wrong. Its fast and instinctive - nothing stupid about it - especially when a half hearted tackle looks absurd and will get you a gig in the 2nds.
And i think the umps bear some responsibility with inconsistent holding the ball adjudication -sometimes a 720 degree spin goes unrewarded.
I think Broady will get a month , is Dusty playing ????
So Dusty and Broad out
Is Taz a possibility
Just for the purpose of added class I’d like to see Sonsie and Clarke come in , maybe there’s a possibility of a debut if they go well tomorrow, wouldn’t be against Biggie coming in for Cox if Broad out
So Dusty and Broad out
Is Taz a possibility
Just for the purpose of added class I’d like to see Sonsie and Clarke come in , maybe there’s a possibility of a debut if they go well tomorrow, wouldn’t be against Biggie coming in for Cox if Broad out
I think Young should keep his place. Not to say I'm a fan. But if you play em you give em a go. Short, can't jump. Light. Weak. But can use.
Ryan was too big a few times. I loved the way Lynch pushed up to the wing and Jack pushed out of the arc to let Samson own the area. (Q2.) We froze the ball before sending it in. Samson did not hit up. Then he got very quiet. Ryan worked a bit harder over the course of the game.
Young is not an AFL player but will work. Ryan is but won't. Yet.
Mansell is close.
Ryan was too big a few times. I loved the way Lynch pushed up to the wing and Jack pushed out of the arc to let Samson own the area. (Q2.) We froze the ball before sending it in. Samson did not hit up. Then he got very quiet. Ryan worked a bit harder over the course of the game.
Young is not an AFL player but will work. Ryan is but won't. Yet.
Mansell is close.
i Do the best I can with the English language Ezyyyy, it’s such a hard language
