Coaches votes- 2013

Rosy

Tiger Legend
Mar 27, 2003
54,347
4
Panthera tigris FC said:
I think it would be fascinating to compare the voting patterns of a secret ballot vs the current open system.
that would be very interesting. i think we'd get quite different results. without really studying the weekly voting it seems to me that people are influenced by others votes. there might be similar votes for a while then someone throws in another name and all of a sudden that player starts getting votes.
 

bruntonave.

Tiger Matchwinner
Nov 18, 2010
526
0
LeeToRainesToRoach said:
Season totals:

Rank Player Vt Ma VM AVMa AFLRank
-------------------------------------------
1st Martin, Dustin 58 22 11 2.64 eq 17th
/ snip /
22nd Grigg, Shaun 2 22 1 0.09 eq302nd

24th Newman, Chris 1 18 1 0.06 eq336th

Stephenson, Orren 0 6 - - eq367th
Grimes, Dylan 0 8 - - eq367th

McGuane, Luke 0 12 - - eq367th
Thanks as always to L2R2R
So. Of the above, who plays on Sunday?
 

mld

hi
Apr 1, 2006
9,643
0
Melbs
Panthera tigris FC said:
I think it would be fascinating to compare the voting patterns of a secret ballot vs the current open system.
Must admit that I stopped voting when I saw people using people's voting history for point-scoring in arguments. Can't see how a secret ballot would be practical though.
 

Baloo

Delisted Free Agent
Nov 8, 2005
34,995
1,527
mld said:
Can't see how a secret ballot would be practical though.
Wouldn't be hard. If anything it could make it easier for PT

Online Voting form where the names are selectable from a drop down list could be added straight into a database for PT to play with.
 

mld

hi
Apr 1, 2006
9,643
0
Melbs
Baloo said:
Wouldn't be hard. If anything it could make it easier for PT

Online Voting form where the names are selectable from a drop down list could be added straight into a database for PT to play with.
Okay cool. If this doesn't happen for next season, Dimma must go.
 

Rosy

Tiger Legend
Mar 27, 2003
54,347
4
Baloo said:
Wouldn't be hard. If anything it could make it easier for PT

Online Voting form where the names are selectable from a drop down list could be added straight into a database for PT to play with.
i suspect if it was secret and not readily visible on the forum far less people would be inclined to participate.
 

Baloo

Delisted Free Agent
Nov 8, 2005
34,995
1,527
mld said:
Okay cool. If this doesn't happen for next season, Dimma must go.
Hater

rosy23 said:
i suspect if it was secret and not readily visible on the forum far less people would be inclined to participate.
yeah, tend to agree. I was just addressing the technical aspects, not the human ones. I don't understand humans.
 

YinnarTiger

Opening goal, 23 Sept 2017
May 2, 2007
6,788
77
70
Gippsland
zippadeee said:
What more would you expect from Grigg. Rated 22nd and has played in every game. That's shocking
What's so shocking about a player ranked 22 by the coaches being included in our best 22?
 

ToraToraTora

Piccadilly anyone?
Mar 21, 2005
9,211
433
QLD
zippadeee said:
What more would you expect from Grigg. Rated 22nd and has played in every game. That's shocking
That is your most mental post ever. Almost Dyeresque. Awesome.
 

seven

Super Tiger
Apr 20, 2004
19,540
748
zippadeee said:
What more would you expect from Grigg. Rated 22nd and has played in every game. That's shocking
Wasn't even considered for the Australian squad.
 

zippadeee

Tiger Legend
Oct 8, 2004
26,878
1,406
YinnarTiger said:
What's so shocking about a player ranked 22 by the coaches being included in our best 22?
What's he played 20-21 games this year and he hasn't been able to snag votes?
He makes no impact.. Wake up
A 19 year old has shown him up thus year
 

LeeToRainesToRoach

Get out Gillon
Jun 4, 2006
23,662
875
Melbourne
rosy23 said:
thanks lee2. would it be possible to see last year's results as well for comparison. i reckon we'd have a few changes and a more even spread.
Hopefully this makes sense.

Rank Player Vt Ma VM AVMa AFLRank RFC AFL Rank Player Vt Ma VM AVMa AFLRank
---------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------
1st Martin, Dustin 58 22 11 2.64 eq 17th +12 +162 1st Cotchin, Trent 107 22 20 4.86 1st
2nd Cotchin, Trent 52 21 8 2.48 24th -1 -23 2nd Deledio, Brett 73 22 13 3.32 10th
3rd Jackson, Daniel 46 22 8 2.09 27th +13 +282 3rd Maric, Ivan 39 21 7 1.86 eq 43rd
4th Deledio, Brett 42 22 7 1.91 eq 33rd -2 -23 4th Tuck, Shane 39 22 9 1.77 eq 43rd
5th Ellis, Brandon 29 20 6 1.45 eq 64th +15 +281 5th Grigg, Shaun 28 22 4 1.27 eq 75th
6th Rance, Alex 28 22 5 1.27 eq 66th +3 +85 6th Riewoldt, Jack 21 22 4 0.95 100th
7th Houli, Bachar 21 20 6 1.05 eq 96th +4 +66 7th Edwards, Shane 14 20 2 0.70 eq134th
8th Conca, Reece 19 16 5 1.19 eq105th +2 +57 8th Foley, Nathan 13 10 3 1.30 eq137th
9th Riewoldt, Jack 19 21 6 0.90 eq105th -3 -5 9th Rance, Alex 11 22 5 0.50 eq151st
10th Vickery, Tyrone 16 20 4 0.80 eq120th +8 +225 10th Conca, Reece 10 18 3 0.56 eq162nd
11th Vlastuin, Nick 14 17 2 0.82 eq138th NA NA 11th Houli, Bachar 10 22 3 0.45 eq162nd
12th Chaplin, Troy 13 21 3 0.62 eq149th NA +72 12th Grimes, Dylan 9 9 3 1.00 eq179th
13th Edwards, Aaron 12 8 2 1.50 eq154th NA +104 13th Martin, Dustin 9 20 5 0.45 eq179th
14th King, Jake 8 17 2 0.47 eq193rd +4 +152 14th Morris, Steven 3 21 1 0.14 eq258th
15th Maric, Ivan 8 19 3 0.42 eq193rd -12 -150 15th Nahas, Robin 3 22 2 0.14 eq258th
16th Edwards, Shane 6 19 3 0.32 eq224th -9 -90 16th Jackson, Daniel 1 19 1 0.05 eq309th
17th Tuck, Shane 4 10 1 0.40 eq257th -13 -214 17th Newman, Chris 1 22 1 0.05 eq309th
18th Foley, Nathan 4 16 1 0.25 eq257th -10 -120 18th Elton, Todd 0 1 - - eq345th
19th Petterd, Ricky 3 11 1 0.27 eq280th NA +65 Graham, Angus 0 1 - - eq345th
20th White, Matt 3 16 2 0.19 eq280th -2 +65 Webberley, Jeromey 0 1 - - eq345th
21st Morris, Steven 2 21 1 0.10 eq302nd -7 -44 Astbury, David 0 2 - - eq345th
22nd Grigg, Shaun 2 22 1 0.09 eq302nd -17 -227 Connors, Daniel 0 2 - - eq345th
23rd Knights, Chris 1 5 1 0.20 eq336th NA +9 Derickx, Tom 0 2 - - eq345th
24th Newman, Chris 1 18 1 0.06 eq336th -7 -27 Moore, Kelvin 0 3 - - eq345th
25th Griffiths, Ben 0 1 - - eq367th -7 -22 Helbig, Brad 0 5 - - eq345th
Helbig, Brad 0 1 - - eq367th -7 -22 White, Matt 0 7 - - eq345th
McDonough, Matt 0 1 - - eq367th NA NA O'Hanlon, Brett 0 8 - - eq345th
Lonergan, Sam 0 2 - - eq367th NA -58 Post, Jayden 0 8 - - eq345th
Dea, Matt 0 3 - - eq367th -7 -22 Griffiths, Ben 0 9 - - eq345th
Arnot, Matthew 0 4 - - eq367th NA NA McGuane, Luke 0 9 - - eq345th
Astbury, David 0 5 - - eq367th -7 -22 Vickery, Tyrone 0 9 - - eq345th
Nahas, Robin 0 6 - - eq367th -10 -109 Maric, Addam 0 10 - - eq345th
Stephenson, Orren 0 6 - - eq367th NA -22 Miller, Brad 0 10 - - eq345th
Grimes, Dylan 0 8 - - eq367th -13 -188 King, Jake 0 12 - - eq345th
Batchelor, Jake 0 9 - - eq367th -7 -22 Batchelor, Jake 0 14 - - eq345th
McGuane, Luke 0 12 - - eq367th -7 -22 Dea, Matt 0 14 - - eq345th
Ellis, Brandon 0 21 - - eq345th
 

Tigers of Old

Twitter: @Tigers_of_Old
Jul 26, 2004
64,160
1,077
Wow that would suggest Jacko has had a massively improved season.

Martin & Ellis too.

Maric has dropped right off. As has Grigg, Tuck & Foley.
 

Rosy

Tiger Legend
Mar 27, 2003
54,347
4
the peer voted mvp awards have heaps of respect from me

gazza 5th time mvp and by a record margin. an absolute superstar. i can't imagine the excitement of having him play for your team. 2nd in coaches award

i don't understand the vitriol towards joel selwood on here. i'd love him as a tiger. 1st most courageous player, 1st best captain and runner up mvp. 3rd in coaches award.
 

zippadeee

Tiger Legend
Oct 8, 2004
26,878
1,406
rosy23 said:
the peer voted mvp awards have heaps of respect from me

gazza 5th time mvp and by a record margin. an absolute superstar. i can't imagine the excitement of having him play for your team. 2nd in coaches award

i don't understand the vitriol towards joel selwood on here. i'd love him as a tiger. 1st most courageous player, 1st best captain and runner up mvp. 3rd in coaches award.
me too RoseZip. I would give them Deldeio and a first rounder for him
The bloke is a gun footballer