Coaches votes- 2013

[Tiger Rob]

As high as 10? I know the chimp is good but...

Haha. That's what happens when you try and post at work when your under the pump. Should read as high as 7.

 

[GoodOne]

By my reckoning Chimp would be on 5 Brownlow votes based on the coaches votes - a 3, a 1 and a 1. But the umpires love him, so could be as high as 10 Brownlow votes.

If Judd can get 10 votes in 3 games so can Chimp.

 

[TOT70]

If Judd can get 10 votes in 3 games so can Chimp.

Cotch is going to get more votes this season than Julia gets in the election.

 

[Dyer'ere]

Cotch is going to get more votes this season than Julia gets in the election.

:hihi

 

[Brodders17]

Richmond vs Collingwood
10 Cloke (Coll)
8 Sidebottom (Coll)
6 Swan (Coll)
3 Lynch (Coll)
2 O'Brien (Coll)
1 Hudson (Coll)

 

[Tommo37]

Richmond vs Collingwood
10 Cloke (Coll)
8 Sidebottom (Coll)
6 Swan (Coll)
3 Lynch (Coll)
2 O'Brien (Coll)
1 Hudson (Coll)

Hard to argue with that.

 

[Tigers of Old]

About right. We didn't have a single clear winner on the ground. :-\

 

[Tigermad2005]

coaches votes

Just wondering who got them last week?

 

[YinnarTiger]

Re: coaches votes

Just wondering who got them last week?

http://puntroadend.com/yabbse/index.php?topic=47959.msg1560623#msg1560623

 

[zippadeee]

Who gave Hudson 1 vote??
Was he actually on the ground.

 

[GoodOne]

Surely they didn't have 6 players better than our best. It was really only 15 minutes of footy that they blew us away. Guess it's still only an opinion.

 

[zippadeee]

Surely they didn't have 6 players better than our best. It was really only 15 minutes of footy that they blew us away. Guess it's still only an opinion.

Which player of us worthy of half a vote let alone 2 or 3 votes.
Pettard? Edwards? Deledio? Cotchin? Rance? Knights??

 

[Ocker]

Richmond vs Collingwood
10 Cloke (Coll)
8 Sidebottom (Coll)
6 Swan (Coll)
3 Lynch (Coll)
2 O'Brien (Coll)
1 Hudson (Coll)

Well, that's a kick in the ass innit?

No more parties at training boys.

 

[KnightersRevenge]

Which player of us worthy of half a vote let alone 2 or 3 votes.
Pettard? Edwards? Deledio? Cotchin? Rance? Knights??

Reckon Conca was our best. Was he worth a vote? I don't know. Do coaches sometimes play ducks and drakes with their voting? I reckon they do and I reckon Hardwick was sending a message he was pretty strong in his presser not looking for positives Frawley style.

 

[zippadeee]

Reckon Conca was our best. Was he worth a vote? I don't know. Do coaches sometimes play ducks and drakes with their voting? I reckon they do and I reckon Hardwick was sending a message he was pretty strong in his presser not looking for positives Frawley style.

It was one of those games you couldn't even say we had anyone worthy to be our best.

 

[GoodOne]

Which player of us worthy of half a vote let alone 2 or 3 votes.
Pettard? Edwards? Deledio? Cotchin? Rance? Knights??

Deledio or Reiwoldt in my opinion were arguably better than Lynch, O'Brien or Hudson.

 

[zippadeee]

Deledio or Reiwoldt in my opinion were arguably better than Lynch, O'Brien or Hudson.

Were you watching the right game last week against collingwood,

 

[GoodOne]

Were you watching the right game last week against collingwood,

Yes I was. Reiwoldt for example was involved in 6 of our 11 goals. Why would a Hudson who managed just 10 possessions and 20 hitouts and 3 marks and no goals get votes over Reiwoltd, let alone his primary opponent Maric who had 15 possessions, 25 hitouts, 5 marks and a goal? Not sure what the hitouts to advantage were but I can't remember it being that obvious. O'Brien was missing for half a game, sparked it up later in the game which is the part that is remembered most. Probably take back Lynch, he was superb.

 

[Dyer'ere]

Fremantle vs Richmond

9 McPharlin (Frem)
8 Griffin (Frem)
5 Vickery (Rich)
4 Ballantyne (Frem)
2 Martin (Rich)
1 Ellis (Rich)
1 Knights (Rich)

To have a stab-

Coach A Coach B
5 - Griffin 5 - McPharlin
4 - Ballantyne 4 - Griffin
3 - McPharlin 3 - Vickery
2 - Vickery 2 - Martin
1 - Knights 1 - Ellis

You can switch the italicised votes. Coach A's vates are guesstimated to be based on a preference for goal-kickers in a game where they were hard to score. But the 1 votes can be switched.

IMO Griffin was clearly BOG.

 

[GoodOne]

Fremantle vs Richmond

9 McPharlin (Frem)
8 Griffin (Frem)
5 Vickery (Rich)
4 Ballantyne (Frem)
2 Martin (Rich)
1 Ellis (Rich)
1 Knights (Rich)

To have a stab-

Coach A Coach B
5 - Griffin 5 - McPharlin
4 - Ballantyne 4 - Griffin
3 - McPharlin 3 - Vickery
2 - Vickery 2 - Martin
1 - Knights 1 - Ellis

You can switch the italicised votes. Coach A's vates are guesstimated to be based on a preference for goal-kickers in a game where they were hard to score. But the 1 votes can be switched.

IMO Griffin was clearly BOG.

Bad stab Dyer, for McPharlin and Griffen at least.