BloodOath said:Tigers of Old said:Davey is the guy Tambling needs to look at. 8)
Just take 'em on Bling!
Davey? Where did that come from.
How can you compare these two? Because they are both quick or both aboriginal?
There is no comparison. Davey hasn't been near a contest ever adn Richard gets his own ball in close! Richard plays in the midfield and Davey is a specialist small forward - worlds apart! Don't see the comparison as a fair one!
hellenictiger said:He is still young, but he is too flashy at times.
Every team need a few players like Thomas, but he is still young, dont know what he is like consistancy wise, i havent seen him that much.
But from what I have seen, I dont think we is the same league as Deledio.
tigerjoe said:Recruited by the maggots in the 2005 draft at pick 2 this kid can surely play.
Not sure how many games he played in '06 but he debuted early and has been in their 22 for alot of '06 and this year.
Malthouse doesn't stuff around with his players, Thomas was recruited as a midfielder/forward and that's where he has played all his games.
Why on earth is Brett Deledio playing only small parts in our midfield and mainly on Half Back?
I rate Lids higher than Thomas in all departments, yet he can't get a full game in the midfield for a struggling team like us?
WTF??????
Tigerbob said:Tries to run, buddy I was at the game and can tell you all the kid did was run, run, run. Dale Thomas is a midfielder and a very good one at that. Too early to judge that draft but Collingwood would have to be happy so far. Im starting to rate Thomas over Murphy.
Was thinking the same thing tigerjoe about Lids - Brett has way more talent but is not given the chance of Thomas - again bad coaching by Wallace!
linuscambridge said:For the untrained eye it appears that Lids is playing in the backline for Richmond, but for the long suffering Tigers supporters, we all know that to play in the Tigers backline is to play "on the ball". Terry is doing the right thing for Delidios developement, playing him where the ball is most, in the Tigers backline.
Tigerbob said:Thomas is a dead set gun.
He runs extremely hard all day long, his kicking is fine, he hit most targets, has that confidence about him.
He is way ahead of Ellis at this time, so is Pendlebury who also is silk. The Pies did well out of that draft.
BBC said:Brett Deledio is not playing as a midfielder beacuse he would be attracting the number one tagger from the opposition which, aged 19, he would not able to shake off.
Hence he is playing off a back flank, a very good move for his development.
pokey said:There are a few pretty hand HBFs running around the league who could be reasonably compared with the role that Lids has at the moment. Andrew McLeod, Jason Gram and Heath Shaw come immediately to mind.
It gives him the whole ground in front of him, enabling him to use his pace and break the lines.
Our midfield is ordinary, but I like him at HBF at the moment.
pokey said:There are a few pretty hand HBFs running around the league who could be reasonably compared with the role that Lids has at the moment. Andrew McLeod, Jason Gram and Heath Shaw come immediately to mind.
It gives him the whole ground in front of him, enabling him to use his pace and break the lines.
Our midfield is ordinary, but I like him at HBF at the moment.