Baloo said:To think that list is the result of 5 years work from "The List Manager"
If you ask Terry none of that was his fault. :
5 year sham.
Baloo said:To think that list is the result of 5 years work from "The List Manager"
tigertim said:There was a first Hardwicke?
plus Newyspook said:Ben Cousins 253 17
Troy Simmons 190 7
Graham Polak 108 3
Richard Tambling 95 13
Kelvin Moore 65 22
Luke McGuane 54 51
Will Thursfield 53 24
Dean Polo 52 4
Mitch Morton 50 21
Adam Thomson 30 2
Tom Hislop 19 8
Angus Graham 18 30
Daniel Connors 10 19
Andrew Collins 10 15
Jayden Post 7 23
Mitchell Farmer 3 28
Andrew Browne 1 11
Matt Dea 0 31
Troy Taylor 0 4
Jeromey Webberley 0 16
Ben Nason 0 23
Alroy Gilligan 0 0
David Gourdis 0 4
Jamie O’Reilly 0 4
Robert Hicks 0 3
Pat Contin 0 0
Relton Roberts 0 2
Nick Westhoff 0 0
![]()
Ferguson in for Bailey and McCrae for ClarkeRancey18 said:So what have the changes been to the coaching team over the off season - is it just McCrae in for Bailey and Clarke?
Sintiger said:Ferguson in for Bailey and McCrae for Clarke
antman said:Top four list for sure. Should have gone from 15th to premiership favourites in one season if Dimma was a competent coach
lamb22 said:2012Port Adelaide 22 5 16 1 1691 2144 78.87 22
Sintiger said:2015 Port Adelaide 22 12 10 0 2002 1874 106.8 48
2015. Richmond 22 15 7 0 1930 1568 123.1 60
Excuses.lamb22 said:If we are talking rebuilds shouldn't you be comparing Hinkley's third year with Hardwick's third year or perhaps mentioning Hinkley won three finals games in his first two years of the rebuild and missed a GF spot by a whisker.
Also 12 wins not bad seeing Port played top 8 sides more than any other team.
Sintiger said:Excuses.
Fact is that based on 2015 we are ahead of Port Adelaide.
lamb22 said:If we are talking rebuilds shouldn't you be comparing Hinkley's third year with Hardwick's third year or perhaps mentioning Hinkley won three finals games in his first two years of the rebuild and missed a GF spot by a whisker.
Also 12 wins not bad seeing Port played top 8 sides more than any other team.
BTW other than a few superstars including Wingard and Grey Port's list is pretty ordinary, especially back half and vastly inferior to ours.
Now now Lamby, let's not bring out the silly post argument hidden with an olive branch ;D . Whether we or Port had a worse list is opinion onlylamb22 said:Your better than that Sin.
Silly post when discussing rebuilds which clearly Hinkley has done faster and better ( 3 finals wins) with what I consider a worse list.
Sintiger said:Ferguson in for Bailey and McCrae for Clarke
lamb22 said:Lets not get silly.
2012Port Adelaide 22 5 16 1 1691 2144 78.87 22
2013Port Adelaide 22 12 10 0 2051 2002 102.45 48 plus a finals win
Richmond
2009 15 Richmond Tigers 22 5 16 1 25.00% 22 1774 2388 74.29%
2010 15 Richmond Tigers 22 6 16 0 27.27% 24 1714 2348 73.00%
Not to mention that both Scott and Hinkley inherited lists that were in better shape than ours was when Hardwick first came in.Sintiger said:Now now Lamby, let's not bring out the silly post argument hidden with an olive branch ;D . Whether we or Port had a worse list is opinion only
Comparisons with Hinkley and B Scott get trotted out and the facts are that based on home and away results Dimma compares pretty well against them, especially in the last 3 years. Then there is the issue of finals of course and that is the achilles heal of Dimma's record, no doubt. I am not denying it nor trying to argue against it. He and the team need to set that right for him to be considered a real success.
Dimma has managed to get us into the finals the last 3 years which is something Scott and Hinkley haven't done so that's a tick for him. Win a few finals and he definitely can lay claim to be their equal.
lamb22 said:Well even if they are D grade coaches its an improvement.
The Port list that win them 5 games in 2012 (and 3 in 2011)? The RFC list won 5 games in 2009.CarnTheTiges said:Not to mention that both Scott and Hinkley inherited lists that were in better shape than ours was when Hardwick first came in.
tigertim said:The Port list that win them 5 games in 2012 (and 3 in 2011)? The RFC list won 5 games in 2009.