Damien Hardwick

[waiting]

A

Yeah there was a Suns player flapping his arms about and yelling at the ump for a good 5 seconds and the ump did nothing.

Anyone see Finlayson from PA going ‘nuts’ in last evenings game?

Warranted 100 metres but obviously not yellow & black jumpers were worn.

Warming up to ‘common sense’ next Friday when the Tigers play PA..

 

[Cooper O'Reilly]

Dimma made a comment that got lost in all the Dusty stuff. When Robbo asked if he was a Richmond man he said he was for now. He would do a reset but not a rebuild. When the time comes to rebuild the list he’ll be gone.
I thought his comments would have created a major story but seem to have gone unnoticed.
I’m thinking when Cotch, Jack, Shedda and Dusty go Dimma will too. That may only be a couple of seasons away

Yep saw that too Broders. First time I've heard him talking about leaving Richmond. "I won't do a rebuild" were his exact words.

Ah well, the cemetery is full of people we couldn't live without.

 

[Cooper O'Reilly]

A

Anyone see Finlayson from PA going ‘nuts’ in last evenings game?

Warranted 100 metres but obviously not yellow & black jumpers were worn.

Warming up to ‘common sense’ next Friday when the Tigers play PA..

He went off his head didn't he. Waving his arms around and even pointed at the umpire whilst mouthing off.

It probably warranted a penalty before the descent rule and yet no penalty applied. Nothing like being consistent is there

 

[DavidSSS]

He went off his head didn't he. Waving his arms around and even pointed at the umpire whilst mouthing off.

It probably warranted a penalty before the descent rule and yet no penalty applied. Nothing like being consistent is there

It's a *smile* rule and it is badly enforced. Just needs to go back to what it used to be, you carry on it's 50, you look a bit p!ssed off no 50.

By the way it's dissent.

DS

 

[Tigers2011]

He went off his head didn't he. Waving his arms around and even pointed at the umpire whilst mouthing off.

It probably warranted a penalty before the descent rule and yet no penalty applied. Nothing like being consistent is there

Not much ‘common sense’ from the umpire!!

 

[davidc0055]

It's a *smile* rule and it is badly enforced. Just needs to go back to what it used to be, you carry on it's 50, you look a bit p!ssed off no 50.

By the way it's dissent.

DS

How do we determine what is actually meant by "carry on"?

 

[St Kevin]

A

Anyone see Finlayson from PA going ‘nuts’ in last evenings game?

Warranted 100 metres but obviously not yellow & black jumpers were worn.

Warming up to ‘common sense’ next Friday when the Tigers play PA..

Nic Newman of Carlton had one which was very funny. He was actually awarded a free kick and still went troppo (I think due to the delay in giving the free kick). If he was dissenting as the recipient of a free kick, should it have been reversed? Somehow I don't think the brains trusts canvassed that issue with Kerry Stokes' focus groups.

 

[davidc0055]

Nic Newman of Carlton had one which was very funny. He was actually awarded a free kick and still went troppo (I think due to the delay in giving the free kick). If he was dissenting as the recipient of a free kick, should it have been reversed? Somehow I don't think the brains trusts canvassed that issue with Kerry Stokes' focus groups.

The same was true for Reiwoldt and a few others on Friday -- their dissent for not getting that 50 could have lead to the free being reversed. PRE would have melted down if that happened.

 

[mad_tiggy911]

Play Pickett in Castagnas role Dimma.

 

[Brodders17]

How do we determine what is actually meant by "carry on"?

Common sense obviously.

 

[gold1]

How do we determine what is actually meant by "carry on"?

When the player drops his dacks and moons the umpire..............

 

[seven]

How do we determine what is actually meant by "carry on"?

His he referring to the ‘carry on’ movies

 

[Sintiger]

It probably warranted a penalty before the descent rule and yet no penalty applied.

Descent rule ….Freudian slip ?

 

[wigglyworm]

Anyone get the sense that there is something quite no right with Dimma at the moment. He seems quite frustrated most of the time and seems to be quite Snarky. i.e Twitter stuff.

I dont think I know of any other coaches that are going the twitter remarks after games to get their points across.

 

[ceehook2]

look at the free kick ladder , then add the likes of Bolton's sloppy 50 mtr penalties on top and then get asked about Dusty moving to Sydney , might be cause for frustration

 

[MD Jazz]

Yeah there was a Suns player flapping his arms about and yelling at the ump for a good 5 seconds and the ump did nothing.

This is what annoys about the rule. Zero consistency. All subjective. One umpire pays it, one doesn't.

Completely unnecessary, and has the opposite effect of it's intention to encourage respect for umpires.

 

[tigertim]

His he referring to the ‘carry on’ movies

“Carry on up the Khyber“, classic.

 

[jb03]

Anyone get the sense that there is something quite no right with Dimma at the moment. He seems quite frustrated most of the time and seems to be quite Snarky. i.e Twitter stuff.

I dont think I know of any other coaches that are going the twitter remarks after games to get their points across.

He thought he was shacking up with a young babe but if you follow their instagram she has him doing one DIY project after another.

 

[TigerForce]

Anyone get the sense that there is something quite no right with Dimma at the moment. He seems quite frustrated most of the time and seems to be quite Snarky. i.e Twitter stuff.

I dont think I know of any other coaches that are going the twitter remarks after games to get their points across.

Cold War.

 

[Broders]

He thought he was shacking up with a young babe but if you follow their instagram she has him doing one DIY project after another.

Ah the old “Honey Do” list