Dane Swan behind play.....

[Bunnerz85]

Now that the match review panel has looked over the matches..... I don't understand why nothing was said about an incident in the 2nd Qtr involving Dane Swan when he dropped a Richmond player that was well off the ball... seeing as i was at the ground and haven't seen a replay, there might not have been anything in it, but as it was off the ball, surely something should have been said about it...

From what I seen of the incident, it looked to be high contact to the richmond players face... but not one word said of the incident at all :S

Did anyone else notice the incident? it was just before the tigers kicked two late goals in the 2nd Qtr.....

 

[Mrs Richo]

howatt got shot even tho there was lack of video evidence

"while a lack of video evidence means Collingwood's Dane Swan is in the clear over a second-quarter incident with Tigers' vice-captain Chris Newman during Sunday's MCG clash."

bloody pies get away with n e thing

 

[Bunnerz85]

absolute joke!

did anyone else see the incident?

 

[geoffryprettyboy]

Nothing in it mate.

 

[Bunnerz85]

so.....Newman is just weak for falling to the ground?? or playing for a free.... even though there wasn't any umpire in sight..

 

[seven]

howatt got shot even tho there was lack of video evidence

"while a lack of video evidence means Collingwood's Dane Swan is in the clear over a second-quarter incident with Tigers' vice-captain Chris Newman during Sunday's MCG clash."

bloody pies get away with n e thing

Adam Goodes got off - despite the footage showing him hitting the guy in the guts

 

[Willo]

so.....Newman is just weak for falling to the ground?? or playing for a free.... even though there wasn't any umpire in sight..

He may have fainted

 

[jb03]

howatt got shot even tho there was lack of video evidence

"while a lack of video evidence means Collingwood's Dane Swan is in the clear over a second-quarter incident with Tigers' vice-captain Chris Newman during Sunday's MCG clash."

bloody pies get away with n e thing

Is that what they said. That is unbelievable, HOwat's video was very inconclusive. Osborne from the Hawks was lucky to get off.

 

[geoffryprettyboy]

so.....Newman is just weak for falling to the ground?? or playing for a free.... even though there wasn't any umpire in sight..

Of course not. Swan made Newman earn it well after he disposed of the ball. You think if he had clobbered him with his fist Jake King would have just given Swan just a shove?

 

[jackfrost]

so.....Newman is just weak for falling to the ground?? or playing for a free.... even though there wasn't any umpire in sight..

Correct.............

 

[DragicevicFan]

Is that what they said. That is unbelievable, HOwat's video was very inconclusive. Osborne from the Hawks was lucky to get off.

How can any AFL vision be inconclusive any more? how many cameras are at the game?

 

[Port1870]

Everything is 'inconclusive' when it comes to the collywobbles