Full List of 2005 Draftees

[TigerForce]

There's a poll on http://afl.com.au/ about which team did best in the draft and you don't even get the choice of Scumwood.  :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl

Because too many Scumwood supporters would clog up the website clicking continously.... :hihi

 

[Tigerblood]

Yes, interesting poll... we are coming last!

 

[blaisee]

greg beck is not at collingwood.


So dont blame it on him.


Blame it on Malthouse, he once again has overulled the recruiting department.

 

[RemoteTiger]

Great to see a NSW lad make the draft - no. 27 Bulldogs selected Dylan Addison from St George District NSW - that happens to be the club my 15yo son (previous marriage) plays at - there is a lot of raw talent up in Sydney - just needs some professional mentoring to polish it up.

Hope this is the start of the AFL inflitrating into the minds and hearts of Sydney's sporting youth........RT

 

[mattyc]

i thought carlton did very well with murphy kennedy bower and edwards the son of butch.in one draft they have almost obtained a spine.

agree Carlton and Dawks did well but they did have top pics ..I was a bit suprised the Dawks went for so many KPPs would have thought they needed midfielders
Was suprised at the Bulldogs ,Scumwoods and Aints pics (interesting that Rix went to the Aints)
Hoping we pick up Scott Meyer in the PSD

Word up. Hawks fan here.

We only took 1 KP, in Dowler. Ellis, Tuck and Muston are mids, Bailey is a ruck and Birchall is a utility/mid/wing/flanker that could potentially be moulded into a KP.

 

[Skills]

There was alot of talk back in November about Collingwood's draft selections.
Would be interested to hear comments almost nine months on?
I've also heard some compare Scott Pendlebury to a Nick Dal Santo type. I'll go one step better and say, he has Anthony Koutafides written all over him.
I've watched Pendlebury play four games now and I dont think I've seen him make a mistake.
Futhermore, you may try linking this post with another top five pick readily discussed on this site and attempt to understand the difference between players who may be as good as the McLeods of this competition.

 

[geoffryprettyboy]

There was alot of talk back in November about Collingwood's draft selections.
Would be interested to hear comments almost nine months on?
I've also heard some compare Scott Pendlebury to a Nick Dal Santo type. I'll go one step better and say, he has Anthony Koutafides written all over him.
I've watched Pendlebury play four games now and I dont think I've seen him make a mistake.
Futhermore, you may try linking this post with another top five pick readily discussed on this site and attempt to understand the difference between players who may be as good as the McLeods of this competition.

Who is the other top 5 pick?

 

[checkside]

There was alot of talk back in November about Collingwood's draft selections.
Would be interested to hear comments almost nine months on?
I've also heard some compare Scott Pendlebury to a Nick Dal Santo type. I'll go one step better and say, he has Anthony Koutafides written all over him.
I've watched Pendlebury play four games now and I dont think I've seen him make a mistake.
Futhermore, you may try linking this post with another top five pick readily discussed on this site and attempt to understand the difference between players who may be as good as the McLeods of this competition.

You didnt see him make a mistake against Melbourne?

 

[Skills]

There was alot of talk back in November about Collingwood's draft selections.
Would be interested to hear comments almost nine months on?
I've also heard some compare Scott Pendlebury to a Nick Dal Santo type. I'll go one step better and say, he has Anthony Koutafides written all over him.
I've watched Pendlebury play four games now and I dont think I've seen him make a mistake.
Futhermore, you may try linking this post with another top five pick readily discussed on this site and attempt to understand the difference between players who may be as good as the McLeods of this competition.

You didnt see him make a mistake against Melbourne?

For the record, no I didn't..and if you want to continue this discussion, your avatar may read checkmate by the end of the night.

 

[checkside]

There was alot of talk back in November about Collingwood's draft selections.
Would be interested to hear comments almost nine months on?
I've also heard some compare Scott Pendlebury to a Nick Dal Santo type. I'll go one step better and say, he has Anthony Koutafides written all over him.
I've watched Pendlebury play four games now and I dont think I've seen him make a mistake.
Futhermore, you may try linking this post with another top five pick readily discussed on this site and attempt to understand the difference between players who may be as good as the McLeods of this competition.

You didnt see him make a mistake against Melbourne?

For the record, no I didn't..and if you want to continue this discussion, your avatar may read checkmate by the end of the night.

Take a look at his clanger count for that game.

 

[geoffryprettyboy]

Have they been handing out free Testosterone tablets out lately?

 

[stripes17]

Does Dale Thomas ever have an opponent?He always seems to be running around by himself. And what happened to the comment that some young players are too skinny and not ready for the rigours of AFL. It doesn't seem to worry him too much.

 

[Tigermad2005]

Been alot better than most people where thinking.
But it is 2-3 years time that we will know.

 

[tigerbro]

Phantom,

do you wish to review your comments RE: collingwoods draft selections?

 

[Bill James]

2005 Draft Picks updated for games and average disposals in 2006.

7 of the top 10 have debuted, both of Hawthorns picks yet to debut.

4 of 11-20 also debuted and an even spread of debuts across the rest of the draft.


1 12 19.25 Carl Marc Murphy
2 11 14.80 Coll Dale Thomas
3 0 0.00 Hawt Xavier Ellis
4 5 5.60 Carl Joshua Kennedy
5 3 12.67 Coll Scott Pendlebury
6 0 0.00 Hawt Beau Dowler
7 7 4.86 Esse Patrick Ryder
8 2 5.00 Rich Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls
9 6 8.17 Bris Mitchell Clark
10 0 0.00 Frem Marcus Drum
11 4 14.80 West Shaun Higgins
12 0 0.00 Melb Nathan Jones
13 4 8.75 West Shannon Hurn
14 6 14.17 Hawt Grant Birchall
15 0 0.00 Geel Travis Varcoe
16 0 0.00 Adel Richard Douglas
17 0 0.00 Adel Darren Pfeiffer
18 0 0.00 Hawt Max Bailey
19 3 6.33 Esse Courtenay Dempsey
20 0 0.00 Carl Paul Bower
21 0 0.00 Coll Danny Stanley
22 0 0.00 Hawt Beau Muston
23 0 0.00 Coll Ryan Cook
24 3 4.00 Rich Cleve Hughes
25 4 12.00 Bris Wayde Mills
26 0 0.00 Frem Garrick Ibbotson
27 0 0.00 West Dylan Addison
28 0 0.00 Kang Matt Riggio
29 0 0.00 West Benjamin McKinley
30 0 0.00 Port Nick Lower
31 0 0.00 Geel Trent West
32 4 7.00 Adel Bernie Vince
33 1 4.00 St K Sam Gilbert
34 0 0.00 West Matthew Spangher
35 0 0.00 Geel Stephen Owen
36 0 0.00 Carl Jake Edwards
37 0 0.00 Coll John Anthony
38 0 0.00 Hawt Travis Tuck
39 0 0.00 Esse Jay Neagle
40 0 0.00 Rich Travis Casserly
41 4 5.00 Bris Rhan Hooper
42 0 0.00 Frem Robert Warnock
43 3 7.67 Kang Andrew Swallow
44 0 0.00 Port Alipate Carlile
45 12 13.00 Kang Kasey Green
46 0 0.00 West Travis Baird
47 0 0.00 Geel Ryan Gamble
48 0 0.00 Adel Alan Obst
49 2 7.00 St K Michael Rix
50 0 0.00 Esse Samuel Lonergan
51 0 0.00 Sydn Matthew Laidlaw
52 Coll PASS
53 0 0.00 Melb Simon Buckley
54 0 0.00 Sydn Kristin Thornton
55 10 13.60 West Brett Montgomery
56 5 8.60 Bris Joel Patfull
57 0 0.00 West Michael West
58 0 0.00 Port Hugh Minson
59 0 0.00 Sydn Ryan Brabazon
60 12 10.58 Melb Clint Bartram
61 4 12.00 Geel Mathew Stokes
62 Adel PASS
63 0 0.00 St K Phillip Raymond
64 Carl PASS
65 Hawt PASS
66 0 0.00 Esse Austin Lucy
67 Rich PASS
68 0 0.00 Melb Heath Neville
69 0 0.00 Kang Timothy Hutchison
70 0 0.00 Port Jonathan Giles
71 0 0.00 St K Justin Sweeney
72 Esse PASS
73 Kang PASS
74 Port PASS
75 St K PASS
76 Esse PASS

 

[Ghost of Punt Road]

some well analysed discussion of what the Tigers should/may draft:

http://www.hawkheadquarters.com/forums/showthread.php?t=22898

 

[RROFO]

some well analysed discussion of what the Tigers should/may draft:

http://www.hawkheadquarters.com/forums/showthread.php?t=22898

Same post is floating around big footy from a new poster who claims to be a Richmond supporter. A bit weird?

I believe

4. Tomas Bellchambers (Tas) good tap Ruckman. Good mark. Clark Keating.
5. Aaron Joseph (Tas) tough in and under player. Tagger/ or h.b.f/ b.p - Steven Baker
6. Craig Bird (N.S.W) leadership qualities. hard at it / good at clearances. Brett Kirk.

are not eligible.

 

[tigerjoe]

If what's been said on the Hawk Headquarters link is true , then someone should send a copy of it to Terry.

Tackling, one percenters and clearances are incredibly important.

If what was said is true then we get flogged when we lose because we do not impart enough pressure on opposition teams.