• If you are having trouble logging in to the forum please contact admin@puntroadend.com // When reseting your password or awaiting confirmation please check your junk/spam emails.

Game Day - Round 21 versus Carlton

LeeToRainesToRoach

Get out Gillon
Jun 4, 2006
24,215
1,362
Melbourne
AFLCA season

Player
Rank
Votes
Polled
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
Gms
Career
Age
Prestia, Dion
eq 14th​
60​
10​
2​
1​
2​
1​
1​
1​
1​
1​
20​
150​
26y303d​
Martin, Dustin
17th​
57​
9​
1​
2​
3​
1​
1​
1​
18​
219​
28y 46d​
Edwards, Shane
40th​
37​
6​
3​
2​
1​
19​
250​
30y290d​
Lynch, Tom J.
eq 48th​
34​
5​
1​
1​
2​
1​
20​
151​
26y284d​
Houli, Bachar
eq 57th​
31​
6​
1​
1​
1​
2​
1​
17​
202​
31y 91d​
Lambert, Kane
eq 65th​
29​
4​
1​
1​
1​
1​
16​
90​
27y258d​
Grimes, Dylan
eq 71st​
27​
7​
1​
1​
3​
2​
19​
146​
28y 26d​
Cotchin, Trent​
eq 118th​
15​
2​
1​
1​
10​
230​
29y126d​
Vlastuin, Nick
eq 118th​
3​
1​
1​
1​
19​
136​
25y114d​
Bolton, Shai
eq 132nd​
13​
3​
1​
1​
1​
14​
23​
20y246d​
Ellis, Brandon
eq 132nd​
5​
1​
2​
1​
1​
18​
171​
26y 8d​
Stack, Sydney
eq 144th​
11​
3​
1​
2​
17​
17​
19y105d​
Nankervis, Toby
eq 156th​
9​
3​
1​
1​
1​
9​
68​
24y364d​
Graham, Jack
eq 175th​
8​
1​
1​
12​
35​
21y167d​
Castagna, Jason
eq 188th​
7​
1​
1​
19​
71​
23y 30d​
Astbury, David
eq 217th​
5​
2​
1​
1​
17​
124​
28y166d​
Chol, Mabior
eq 217th​
1​
1​
8​
9​
22y194d​
McIntosh, Kamdyn
eq 217th​
3​
2​
1​
16​
90​
25y130d​
Baker, Liam
eq 299th​
1​
1​
1​
14​
17​
21y196d​
 

Sintiger

Tiger Legend
Aug 11, 2010
11,740
782
Camberwell
We have played the last 5 at the mcg, which is great , but one thing that concerns me is that we have played a lot of wet weather footy and on very soft grounds. I have felt in the last couple of weeks we have looked a little flatter. I hope all these wet weather games haven’t taken too much out of them
 

Smoking Aces

Batten Down The Hatches
Sep 21, 2007
12,232
588
Coaches votes:
9 Dion Prestia (RICH)
8 Jack Graham (RICH)
6 Shane Edwards (RICH)
4 Nick Vlastuin (RICH)
3 Liam Jones (CARL)
We have played the last 5 at the mcg, which is great , but one thing that concerns me is that we have played a lot of wet weather footy and on very soft grounds. I have felt in the last couple of weeks we have looked a little flatter. I hope all these wet weather games haven’t taken too much out of them
Good point Sin. The rest pre finals will be welcomed.
 

tigerlove

Tiger Legend
Aug 9, 2014
12,109
1,356
Clarkson didn't get this memo before Friday night. But then again they only won by 56.
We would have beaten GWS by more. They clearly didn't want to be out there in the cold. Is there a softer front running team than GWS? Essendon maybe but they're not that good anyway.
 

antman

Tiger Legend
Nov 25, 2004
16,814
1,094
Edit: Everyone seems to be talking about Carlton's bright future but their team was older than ours and 3 of their top 5 disposal winners are over 32 years of age and one other is 29yo and their 3 current rucks are 30,30 and 28.
That's OK, let them have some false hope... makes the eventual disappointment even sweeter for us
 

percyms

Tiger Superstar
Feb 24, 2008
2,320
74
I see that Nanks got a $3000 fine and another two players from who cares only got $2000 for infractions. Why to Tigers seem to constantly cop harsher penalties...
 

MD Jazz

Tiger Champion
Feb 3, 2017
3,921
578
Coaches votes:
9 Dion Prestia (RICH)
8 Jack Graham (RICH)
6 Shane Edwards (RICH)
4 Nick Vlastuin (RICH)
3 Liam Jones (CARL)
Not sure if anyone reads sports papers anymore but I still read The Age & have been disappointed in the standard of match reporting this year. Daniel Cherney did our game Sunday and he could not find a spot for Nick Vlastuin in the tigers best. He named 7 players in front of him including Astbury & Ellis. You could not have watched that game and not noted Vlas as the best tigers defender on the day. I can see how you could find Graham/Prestia/Edwards in the best 3 but Vlastuin is easily the next best in that case.

I'm not sure the journo's doing the match reports actually watch the games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users

TigerForce

Richmond has a better list.
Apr 26, 2004
49,303
1,537
Not sure if anyone reads sports papers anymore but I still read The Age & have been disappointed in the standard of match reporting this year. Daniel Cherney did our game Sunday and he could not find a spot for Nick Vlastuin in the tigers best. He named 7 players in front of him including Astbury & Ellis. You could not have watched that game and not noted Vlas as the best tigers defender on the day. I can see how you could find Graham/Prestia/Edwards in the best 3 but Vlastuin is easily the next best in that case.

I'm not sure the journo's doing the match reports actually watch the games.
Agree for both the Hun and The Age. I notice some mis-spelling and bad grammar which makes me wonder if these 'journos' are schoolkids....
 

MD Jazz

Tiger Champion
Feb 3, 2017
3,921
578
Agree for both the Hun and The Age. I notice some mis-spelling and bad grammar which makes me wonder if these 'journos' are schoolkids....
I find I can't read the hun anymore, that goes for all of their sports writing - footy, cricket, golf etc.
 

Smoking Aces

Batten Down The Hatches
Sep 21, 2007
12,232
588
Not sure if anyone reads sports papers anymore but I still read The Age & have been disappointed in the standard of match reporting this year. Daniel Cherney did our game Sunday and he could not find a spot for Nick Vlastuin in the tigers best. He named 7 players in front of him including Astbury & Ellis. You could not have watched that game and not noted Vlas as the best tigers defender on the day. I can see how you could find Graham/Prestia/Edwards in the best 3 but Vlastuin is easily the next best in that case.

I'm not sure the journo's doing the match reports actually watch the games.
Cherney relies on Twitter for his information
 

spook

It is only the intellectually lost who ever argue.
Jun 18, 2007
11,144
1,350
Not sure if anyone reads sports papers anymore but I still read The Age & have been disappointed in the standard of match reporting this year. Daniel Cherney did our game Sunday and he could not find a spot for Nick Vlastuin in the tigers best. He named 7 players in front of him including Astbury & Ellis. You could not have watched that game and not noted Vlas as the best tigers defender on the day. I can see how you could find Graham/Prestia/Edwards in the best 3 but Vlastuin is easily the next best in that case.

I'm not sure the journo's doing the match reports actually watch the games.
I know Daniel, nice lad, St Kilda tragic. Not the best observer, I agree. I chastised him last year for failing to give Chimp a vote when he was clearly BOG against Collingwood. (Zero Brownlow votes for Chimp either: 3 Nank 2 Dusty 1 Treloar because they look at stats - but he got all 10 Coaches votes, which is all you need to know.)

The standard of sports writing in this country is pretty poor overall. Dinny Navaratnam on the AFL site is possibly the worst judge of sport I have ever seen.
 

MD Jazz

Tiger Champion
Feb 3, 2017
3,921
578
Cherney relies on Twitter for his information
Oops, funnily enough whilst bemoaning the accuracy of sports reporting I've named the wrong journo!! It was Ronny Lerner who did the tigers game! I must have pinged Cherney in my mind for another faux pas. I'll see if I can track that one down....
 

MD Jazz

Tiger Champion
Feb 3, 2017
3,921
578
I miss reading the quality of works from guys like Peter McFarlane & Les Carlyon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

spook

It is only the intellectually lost who ever argue.
Jun 18, 2007
11,144
1,350
I miss reading the quality of works from guys like Peter McFarlane & Les Carlyon.
Les was great. McFarline was testy, but you knew where he stood. Jack Fingleton had a way with words. Ron Carter. Martin Flanagan. Brent Croswell was a ripper. Greg Baum doesn't do reporting anymore, just the odd pontification. Richard Hinds' head disappeared up his own arse. Jake Niall is a dope. The Hun pack are morons.

We've never had a Damon Runyon, except in these pages.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

LeeToRainesToRoach

Get out Gillon
Jun 4, 2006
24,215
1,362
Melbourne
I see that Nanks got a $3000 fine and another two players from who cares only got $2000 for infractions. Why to Tigers seem to constantly cop harsher penalties...
Second offence for Nank.

Noticed a couple of journo's pushing for Riewoldt to be sanctioned for an alleged "chicken wing" on Jones. Bad luck chaps.
 

Brodders17

Tiger Legend
Mar 21, 2008
11,192
235
Les was great. McFarline was testy, but you knew where he stood. Jack Fingleton had a way with words. Ron Carter. Martin Flanagan. Brent Croswell was a ripper. Greg Baum doesn't do reporting anymore, just the odd pontification. Richard Hinds' head disappeared up his own arse. Jake Niall is a dope. The Hun pack are morons.

We've never had a Damon Runyon, except in these pages.
Dont forget the esteemed chief of whatever at the Hun. he will surely enter the journo hall of fame one day.
 

lukeanddad

Tiger Champion
Nov 17, 2008
2,955
184
Les was great. McFarline was testy, but you knew where he stood. Jack Fingleton had a way with words. Ron Carter. Martin Flanagan. Brent Croswell was a ripper. Greg Baum doesn't do reporting anymore, just the odd pontification. Richard Hinds' head disappeared up his own arse. Jake Niall is a dope. The Hun pack are morons.

We've never had a Damon Runyon, except in these pages.
My favourite football writers (although they never did match reports) were Brent Crosswell and Martin Flannagan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user