Silent Bob said:Not a bad show from Hislop. Would've been nice to see what Adam Thompson could have added to the team today re toughness.
think thompson is still injured
Silent Bob said:Not a bad show from Hislop. Would've been nice to see what Adam Thompson could have added to the team today re toughness.
tha8ball said:The good news is that Browny, Lids, Richo and The freak all did well for my dream team
tiger1960 said:30 scoring shots to 20. What would the score have been had Geelong kicked straight earlier?
se7en said:Tought to beat the umps let alone Geelong
AstuteTiger said:They didn’t why do people say this, had they kicked straighter, like in the grand final u cant take it back...
I could easily and i mean easily say the umps gave them 4 goals, the double goal and the Jackson tackle to give away 50myts was a terrible umpiring decision that gave the cats a goal, so in that 3rd Qtr there 3 goals pretty much came from the umps with mooney kicking a goal from a Jake king turnover but the umpires giving the cats so many 50's really hurt...And just remembered the same thing happened in the 1st Qtr and cats got a goal...
tigerlee said:Nahas was totally overwhelmed and made silly decisions.
Im a little concerned about McGuane - he seems to have lost some of his
craig said:3 goals given up by 3 of the sides least footy aware players in McGuane, King and Jackson which were very very costly.
Jacksons was a bit stiff but the other 2 were there its in the rules and dumb footy hurt yet again, added to the other free kick goal King gave away early.
AstuteTiger said:They didn’t why do people say this, had they kicked straighter, like in the grand final u cant take it back...
I could easily and i mean easily say the umps gave them 4 goals, the double goal and the Jackson tackle to give away 50myts was a terrible umpiring decision that gave the cats a goal, so in that 3rd Qtr there 3 goals pretty much came from the umps with mooney kicking a goal from a Jake king turnover but the umpires giving the cats so many 50's really hurt...And just remembered the same thing happened in the 1st Qtr and cats got a goal...
But the tackle difference was ok they only had 50 odd as well. Agree on the kicks.Freezer said:Good to see the kick to handball ratio back up. Still only 51 tackles - 3 less than last week.
Looking forward to watching the game.
AstuteTiger said:yeah craig mcguane and king gave up goals but id let jacko off and replace his give away goal to the ump...terrible decision..
Tubytiger said:Ok, I'll ask you the same question as i did with Craig but didnt receive a response - which goal are you saying king gave up?
WesternTiger said:I suspect it was the one he kick directly to Mooney under no pressure in the third.
Tubytiger said:That was a shocker and i agree. The other two goals he got against him in chapman and johnson was disgraceful decisions against him which both resulted in goals. Cheers WT- thanks for taking the time out to respond mate.
Tubytiger said:Ok, I'll ask you the same question as i did with Craig but didnt receive a response - which goal are you saying king gave up?
WesternTiger said:That’s the disappointment with King TT; he generally turns it over when he is under little pressure.
I have no idea about the Johnson free. If it was paid for high contact from the bump why wasn't King reported and/or a 50m paid?