That might be the case in the Hunter Valley area, have you been to the LaTrobe Valley? not may wineries or horse racing studs around there. im guessing Matt Canavan country isnt full of wineries either.The first sentence is the main one and agree. As for the rest, I take your point, but I think there is a fair bit of hype as a result of the Union PR campaign and firm murdoch and coalition support. The latter 2 have been all over it because its been a rich political vein to wedge the ALP, but when you peel back the layers, its not that clear. Some communities sure, Moranbah and Blackwater for example which have always been boom and bust, but the biggest coalmining region is the Hunter valley/ Newcastle area. Shitloads of alternative industries and economies, and there is quite a bit of local support to end coal from the wineries and racehorse studs and farms. Its an amazing area, dunno if you've been there, superb postcard country, with bloody great open cut mines in the middle of it!
I find the logic and tone of the coalminers a bit hard to take. I don't begrudge them earning good dough and setting themselves up while it continues, not at all, but they are not owed a living when its over. Its just like a Blockbuster video store attendant thinking their job should continue when DVDs were over, and thats putting aside the issue of environmental harm.
i agree with the you that coal miners are protected species, but comparing the impact on local communities of a coal mine shutting to a video store is showing ignorance for a serious issue for those communities.