Half way report | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Half way report

Rosy

Tiger Legend
Mar 27, 2003
54,348
32
We're half way through the season so I thought it would be good to discuss our performance so far.

1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?

6-How happy have you been with the backline?

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?

9-Biggest thrill this year?

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
 
rosy23 said:
We're half way through the season so I thought it would be good to discuss our performance so far.

1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
On track.Cant beat the better sides.Capable against those around us.10-13th at the start of the season.Hasnt changed

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
Great move with Richo on to the wing got us the Win against Freo.Apart from that he,s been a tad dissapointing.

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
Very good under the circumstances

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
The bonus was Freo.Dissapointed in the Pies game.A draw ahead of expectations at this stage ;D


5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
8 wins

6-How happy have you been with the backline?
Been good.Would still move King out of there

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
Need someone to step up and takeover from the big lug.

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
To much of a workload on one person[Foley].Lids has stepped up however Foley needs more support

9-Biggest thrill this year?
A certain #2 pick

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
As Above
 
1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
Better
2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
Worse
3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
They're doing well at Coburg.
4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
1
5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
7
6-How happy have you been with the backline?
:help
7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
:help
8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
:help
9-Biggest thrill this year?
This is a family site.
10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
TC
 

1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?


I feel a bit disappointed. This is the 4th year Terry has had to develop the team and with "no excuses" and a blessed run injury wise for a change I would have expected to have more than 3 wins on the board.


2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?

50/50. Some strange moves ie Hyde on Goodes and finally some sense, albeit a bit late, using Richo differently. We've been very competitive in some games but we've also thrown a couple away.


3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?

I haven't seen Coburg but by all accounts there are a few kids ready to come in. Great news. I think Lids is a far more mature player this year, Whitey has improved, Cotch is a breath of fresh air and gives hope for the future.

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?

I expect to win every game. Not realistic I know but 3 from 11 is way below what I would have expected. I ws disappointed to hear ladder position of the teams we've played used as an excuse. The players need to beleive they can beat every team.

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?

I hope we run out trying to win the next 11 and don't give one seconds thought to where teams are on the ladder. It's a fairly even season and all teams are ripe for the picking.

6-How happy have you been with the backline?

I'm not sure yet that we have players as good as Gas and Andy Kellaway in their prime but I like our backline and the way the kids go about their business.

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?

I think it needs a bit of work still. Doesn't function efficiently.

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?

I hope we've got a lot of improvement in that area. I bet the backmen hope so too.

9-Biggest thrill this year?

Cotch giving us hope for the future. I know his early draft seelction indicated he'd be a ripper player but we all know too well that often accounts for nothing. Good to see a Rolls Royce in the garage.

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?

All the Cs. Cotch next week. Collins, Connors and Collard. I'm really looking forward to seeing Rance debut too and think he could be noticed by the judges.
 
1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
About what I expected at the beginning of the year.

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
Up and down, occasionally good (Richo move), but very prone to outsmarting himself and trying moves and matchups that are ludicrous. Too much weight given to older players that should be axed. Needs to learn that more marking players are required in the fwd line.

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
Up and down. Cotch obviously is if anything better than I expected. Disappointing that players like Connors and Polo have been struck with injury.

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
4

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
8

6-How happy have you been with the backline?
Very happy since Bowden has moved out.

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
Unhappy because Wallace is prone to playing too few marking players.

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
OK, although Lids needs to be told to kick it more and Foley needs to be given more protection and learn to break tags better.

9-Biggest thrill this year?
Fremantle win

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
Cotch
 
1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
Slightly better than expected. I thought games against Bulldogs, Saints and Hawks were OK. Disappointed in the last 2, but 3 and half wins at this point, is what I expected at seasons end.
2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
Slightly above average. I would have had it higher, but the last 2 games have knocked my confidence a bit. Gone too much with the tried and failed on matchday, and some poor matchups. Has responded too slow at times when a player looks like he's about to break a game up (Eg Corey Jones against North Melb).
3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
Tambling hasn't done as much as he promised.
Lids stepping up well.
Patto a non-factor in the ruck, but otherwise OK. Skills look to be improving by foot.
Would like to see Edwards getting a limited run in the midfield at times.
Cotchin is outstanding after 4 games, hope he can keep it up.
Morton classy, and a far better option than Pettifer. Happy with his trade.
Thursty going great guns. McGuane isn't a long term answer, but does OK for now.
Raines a worry.
Moore a suprise. Can't have McGuane, Moore and Thursty playing all together though.

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
11. Realistically though, I expected 2.
5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
6-7
6-How happy have you been with the backline?
Not all that happy with the smalls. Raines needs to go back and either make that position his with the same desire he did 2 seasons ago, or we need to give it to someone else. Moore has been handy, Thursfield is fine. Happy with Schulz down back for now. Polak and McGuane are basically backfill for those three in my opinion.
7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
Happier with Morton in. He seems to do good things everytime he touches the ball. We still lack pressure in our forward line, trying to keep the ball in. Pettifer, Bowden, Brown and Richo don't all work together, not enough defensive pressure from them. Would like to see us transition Richo out of the forwardline permanently now, and start getting Riewoldt and Hughes or Polak in as our key targets. We need to look to the generation beyond Richo.
8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
It's So-So.
Lids, Cotch, foley = Good. Tambling OK, but needs to do more.
Tuck, hyde, Tivendale, Johnson need to be replaced
.
9-Biggest thrill this year?
Watching the young guys turn our skill standard and intensity around.
10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
Trent Cotchin
Travis Cassarly (if he gets fit)
Maybe JON,if he aint too old.
 
1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
I was hoping for 4 wins so 3 wins is about around the mark. Been competive in some games against the top sides which is good.

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
Mystifying. Some of the match ups have been terrible - even i knew they wouldn't work

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
Okay ATM. Disappointed with Cleve, McGuane, edwards, jackson, pattison and polak,

Good: White, Lids, moore, riewoldt, thursfield and so far cotchin


4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
4

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
7

6-How happy have you been with the backline?
too many turn overs - McMahon needs to be moved on.

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
Without Richo we have no focual point. Also no CHF

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
okay

9-Biggest thrill this year?
Freo win

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
cotch
 
rosy23 said:
We're half way through the season so I thought it would be good to discuss our performance so far.

1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
One more win than I thought we would have. The general performance has been in line (didn't think we would improve much)

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
OK.

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
Mixed. Lids and Cotch have been good. I am disappointed in Bling- does nowhere enough IMO. Patto not up to it. Edwards has struggled a bit- but I think he will be a player. Foley keeps on keeping on. Riewoldt has shown glimpses. Thursty been solid. Morton been stiff. Most others have hardly been sighted for one reason or another.

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
2 to 3

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
6 or 7

6-How happy have you been with the backline?
Not very. Get heavily scored against too often. Skill level of the back six not up to scratch IMO.

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
Been OK. Have kicked some decent scores. Need to unearth a crumber. Still concerned that Richo, despite playing much of the gmes on the wing, continues to be the primary forward target
8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
So so. In the main, the ball use and decisioon making is sub standard IMO, with some exceptions.
9-Biggest thrill this year?
The start to Cotchin's career- could finally have a gun on our hands.
10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
Cotchin. Full stop.
 
1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
As much as I love to win, we are actually about where I thought we would be with one exception, I would have thought (on form) we should have beaten the Saints (even though I tipped the Saints to win.)

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
Not sure, I am not privy to everything but suggest about a 5 out of 10 from a lay persons perspective

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
If they got more of a go I might be able to tell ;D
Um, more time needed with this one I will come back to it.

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
4

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
Optimistically we could win 4 more
Pessimistically we could draw 1 more

6-How happy have you been with the backline?
It has been on and off, really have to be a good backline if the midfielders don't do there job, backline has been under pressure a fair bit so probably better than I think.

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
Not bad considering the midfield, although putting pressure on when the ball is there is still a bit inconsistent.

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
Working its guts out but for little reward, not "gelling" as well as it could, first options possibly the best, are they being instructed to do too much or panicking, getting tired as the season progresses, will be good when we really have a core group to work with.

9-Biggest thrill this year?
Beating Carlton. Winning in the West. Watching Cotchin's first game at the G.

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
Trent Cotchin.
 
We're half way through the season so I thought it would be good to discuss our performance so far.

1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
Same

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
Ok, could be a bit better

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
Starting to come good, need to be played more now that the season looks to be over

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
more than zero

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
6 and a half

6-How happy have you been with the backline?
ok, need a FB so Thursty can be played as a third tall

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
not to good, need a small crumber (hopefully Collard) and a CHF/FF

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
good, Lids is finally being played there, Cotch will be fantastic, Tuck/Johnson slowly moving out

9-Biggest thrill this year?
On the road to Freo, finally smashed a side
Also first up win against Carlton, shoved it in their smug faces
Cotchin


10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
Cotchin
 
1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?

4/10. We are performing worse. About the right amount of wins, but I didn't expect the floggings and insipid performances.

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?

5/10. Only average. His pre-game analysis of the opposition is great, but on game day he appears reluctant to make changes.


3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?

5/10. About where is should. Except Polak - who has gone downhill since last season.


4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?

3-4.

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?

We play some of the competition's lesser lights, so 4-5 more.

6-How happy have you been with the backline?

4/10. Not very. Great endeavour, but fairly unskilled players making too many mistakes, and fairly skilled players (McMahon) making too many mistakes!

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?

6/10. Removing Richo has at least given it a chance to develop.

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?

6/10. Foley and Lids progressing nicely. Johnson having a good season.

9-Biggest thrill this year?

Beating Carlton

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?

Cotchin. Is there anyone else?
 
1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?

Disappointed. I expected more from thiss team under Wallace in his 4th season. Given our dream run with injury. It's very hard to tell whether we have improved at all.

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?

Ordinary to poor. Hyde on Goodes a lowlight.

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?


Good: Cotchin, Deledio, Moore
OK: Foley, Tambling, Schulz
Poor: Hughes, Polak, Pattison


4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
Hoped for at least 5 but pessimistically expected less.

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
7.5

6-How happy have you been with the backline?
Been our brightest aspect.

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
Disappointing overall. Polak, Hughes, Pettifer & Riewoldt have offered little.
Edwards & Morton some cameos.
Again most of our goals have come from Richardson(wing) and Browny.


8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
Ok

Lids a standout.
Sugar good.
Foley well tagged on occasions but solid.
Simmonds good early before the state game.
Tambling Ok.
Tuck mixed.


9-Biggest thrill this year?
Beating the Blues in round 1.

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
Trent Cotchin
 
1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?

Disappointing, would be happier if we beat Dogs and Saints

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?

Patchy. However, really dropped the ball at the selection table the last two weeks

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?

Not bad, but not convinced yet.

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?

5 or 6

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?

8 or 9

6-How happy have you been with the backline?

So-so: seems to be a player each week that kicks a relatively easy bag against us

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?

Better, but worried about going into bad habits and leaving it all to Richo

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?

Huge improvement from midfield on last few years - good to see our midfielders getting amongst the goals too, though we have one or two in dreadful form.

9-Biggest thrill this year?

Spoiling Carlton's party first time around - thrashing Freo

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?

If Cotchin doesn't it is a crime. Hopeful Riewoldt will get one too.
 
rosy23 said:
We're half way through the season so I thought it would be good to discuss our performance so far.

1-How does the season weigh up with your pre-season expectations?
Another failure in progression.

2-How do you rate Terry's game day coaching?
Lame and pathetic

3-How do you rate the performance of the 'next generation'?
Promising signs but still underdeveloped.

4-How many wins would you have been satisfied with at this stage?
Five.

5-How many wins do you think we'll finish the season with?
Six.

6-How happy have you been with the backline?
OK. Moore and Thursfield are the only long-term hopes. King should be in the midfield.

7-How happy have you been with the forward line?
Terrible. Richo's finally been given a free run outside the forward line, but Wallace still can't develop or structure set forwards.

8-How happy have you been with the midfield?
OK. Foley still busting his gut, but Lids should be there more often.

9-Biggest thrill this year?
Cotchin.

10-Who will get Rising Star nominations before the season is over?
Cotchin.