-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Hall, Limbach and others
- Thread starter rensman
- Start date
Thanx Craig. On me way to work(Bar manager) not gunna be fun on new years eve.Ah well will have to have a few afterwrds!craig said:
Tigers of Old said:
:rofl Claw, you're a dead set laugh a minute.the claw said:why is it so hard for ferals to understand basic posts.no ones saying one player is responsible for us finishing 12.the fact that such an ordinary weak slow spineless excuse of a footballer like pettrified is in the top 22 shows the overall problems with the list we have.if he remains in our best 22 for the next 3 or 5 yrs god help us. and just because hes finally managed to produce an average season ferals everywhere are proclaiming him an elite footballer ffs its typical of our supporters as soon as someone shows a little bit they are automatically champs never mind the 5 previous pathetic yrs or the deficiencies in their games that have not been improved on that tell you as plain as day we have seen the best of the pettifers of this world and their best is not good enough.pharace said:the claw said:
Think ToO gets closer to the truth than your opinion couched in "fact" oh Clawed One. Never known one player to be solely responsible for a club finishing 12th. If you ever get the chance - put that to TW and get his opinion.
Putting your "fact" another way though, that RFC was in the Top 8 until Browny did his leg (and still there a little after I seem to recall), perhaps was also due to Pettifer being in the best 22? Both are pointless opinions and only 2006 and beyond can confirm whether one is a more accurate "snapshot in time" than the other
For mine, just happy he is improving and playing a better brand of game over time.
Who here in these referred posts is calling him a "champ"? Who here in these referred posts is callling him "elite"? Why is it so hard for you to understand basic posts?
Oh that's right it's hard to read in the dark 8).
Balanced posting just isn't part of your mindset is it? How's this.... "ordinary weak slow spineless excuse of a footballer"? That's about as ridiculous as calling him a "champ".
who will argue overhis career he hasnt been very ordinary who will argue hes not weak i reckon my granny could break one of his pathetic efforts to tackle and would definately put up a better show when challenged. who will argue hes not spineless the amount of times hes pulled out of contests is sickening and a disgrace.who will argue hes not slow the amount of times his direct opponent runs of him and delivers the ball cleanly is another disgrace.his histrionics when he does something wrong are down right embarrasing.hes a 184cm 84kg hff with no other strings to his bow who is slow lacks strenght and a physical presence who wont put his head over the ball. in fact i would say kane is the most scared footballer in the aflTigers of Old said:Tigers of Old said::rofl Claw, you're a dead set laugh a minute.the claw said:why is it so hard for ferals to understand basic posts.no ones saying one player is responsible for us finishing 12.the fact that such an ordinary weak slow spineless excuse of a footballer like pettrified is in the top 22 shows the overall problems with the list we have.if he remains in our best 22 for the next 3 or 5 yrs god help us. and just because hes finally managed to produce an average season ferals everywhere are proclaiming him an elite footballer ffs its typical of our supporters as soon as someone shows a little bit they are automatically champs never mind the 5 previous pathetic yrs or the deficiencies in their games that have not been improved on that tell you as plain as day we have seen the best of the pettifers of this world and their best is not good enough.pharace said:the claw said:
Think ToO gets closer to the truth than your opinion couched in "fact" oh Clawed One. Never known one player to be solely responsible for a club finishing 12th. If you ever get the chance - put that to TW and get his opinion.
Putting your "fact" another way though, that RFC was in the Top 8 until Browny did his leg (and still there a little after I seem to recall), perhaps was also due to Pettifer being in the best 22? Both are pointless opinions and only 2006 and beyond can confirm whether one is a more accurate "snapshot in time" than the other
For mine, just happy he is improving and playing a better brand of game over time.
Who here in these referred posts is calling him a "champ"? Who here in these referred posts is callling him "elite"? Why is it so hard for you to understand basic posts?
Oh that's right it's hard to read in the dark 8).
Balanced posting just isn't part of your mindset is it? How's this.... "ordinary weak slow spineless excuse of a footballer"? That's about as ridiculous as calling him a "champ".
as i have said before he should be gone as soon as one of the kids are ready to do his job and if it takes 3 or 4 yrs for a kid to replace him we are in big trouble.in fact kane should of beeen shopped around for a draft pick this past draft while we can get something for him.
You know the saying claw, if you keep saying it long enough sooner or later someone will believe you. ;Dthe claw said:why thank you gus im glad you have the good sense to see that fact.gustiger12 said:
Me I just believe everything that is written in the Gospel that is PRE. :rotfl
the claw said:pharace said:the claw said:
Think ToO gets closer to the truth than your opinion couched in "fact" oh Clawed One. Never known one player to be solely responsible for a club finishing 12th. If you ever get the chance - put that to TW and get his opinion.
Putting your "fact" another way though, that RFC was in the Top 8 until Browny did his leg (and still there a little after I seem to recall), perhaps was also due to Pettifer being in the best 22? Both are pointless opinions and only 2006 and beyond can confirm whether one is a more accurate "snapshot in time" than the other
For mine, just happy he is improving and playing a better brand of game over time.
why is it so hard for ferals to understand basic posts.
Because sometimes the posts a too basically put. I think that may come from being too negative or too positive, ie. a lack of balance.
Try adding the word "symptomatic" somewhere in you original basic post and you may solve the problem At least you mean what you say, rather then the alternative.
Still think it is too simplistic to just bag Pettifer at then end of a much improved season. There are many clubs with a Pettifer, or worse, a Medhurst :rotfl
i wouldnt hesitate to pick medhurst over pettrified even with all his shortcomings.pharace said:the claw said:pharace said:the claw said:
Think ToO gets closer to the truth than your opinion couched in "fact" oh Clawed One. Never known one player to be solely responsible for a club finishing 12th. If you ever get the chance - put that to TW and get his opinion.
Putting your "fact" another way though, that RFC was in the Top 8 until Browny did his leg (and still there a little after I seem to recall), perhaps was also due to Pettifer being in the best 22? Both are pointless opinions and only 2006 and beyond can confirm whether one is a more accurate "snapshot in time" than the other
For mine, just happy he is improving and playing a better brand of game over time.
why is it so hard for ferals to understand basic posts.
Because sometimes the posts a too basically put. I think that may come from being too negative or too positive, ie. a lack of balance.
At least you mean what you say, rather then the alternative.
Still think it is too simplistic to just bag Pettifer at then end of a much improved season. There are many clubs with a Pettifer, or worse, a Medhurst :rotfl
Getting back to the point (geez, that’s unusual for me), this will be a defining year for all 3 players mentioned.
Hall should be at his peak this year (even if that peak is no higher than the top end of Bourke street). For mine, last year was one of his better years but he is still not good enough to be part of a premiership team. Right now he’s only there because we couldn’t trade him and also because of the fact that we are bereft of height in the backline. He’s gotta have his best year ever if he’s gonna remain at Richmond. By all reports, the way he is training it sounds like he understands that.
Schulz. Time for him to step up to the plate. The potential tag has worn thin. He’ll be thrust into a key role or two throughout the season. This is the year we find out if he’s good enough. Doesn’t have to star…but has to make a solid contribution.
Limbach. If it wasn’t for the mandatory minimum 2 year contract he got after being drafted last year, the club probably would have de-listed him. Lazy, un-disciplined and un-professional. Was subsequently read the riot act by Wallace and the club, and sounds like he has started to pull his finger out if going by his pre-season training form is any indication. Has a real smart ar$e attitude about him, but I don’t mind that in a forward. We need a bit more character around the club. Can take a half decent mark, kicks ok (if not a bit unorthodox with his technique) and is starting to build a frame on his body. He’d wanna get a game or two in the seniors this year, or at least put in a good year at Coburg, to retain his spot on the list. Under the Wallace game plan (which should filter down to Coburg much better this year), Limbach could surprise if he stays injury free.
Hall should be at his peak this year (even if that peak is no higher than the top end of Bourke street). For mine, last year was one of his better years but he is still not good enough to be part of a premiership team. Right now he’s only there because we couldn’t trade him and also because of the fact that we are bereft of height in the backline. He’s gotta have his best year ever if he’s gonna remain at Richmond. By all reports, the way he is training it sounds like he understands that.
Schulz. Time for him to step up to the plate. The potential tag has worn thin. He’ll be thrust into a key role or two throughout the season. This is the year we find out if he’s good enough. Doesn’t have to star…but has to make a solid contribution.
Limbach. If it wasn’t for the mandatory minimum 2 year contract he got after being drafted last year, the club probably would have de-listed him. Lazy, un-disciplined and un-professional. Was subsequently read the riot act by Wallace and the club, and sounds like he has started to pull his finger out if going by his pre-season training form is any indication. Has a real smart ar$e attitude about him, but I don’t mind that in a forward. We need a bit more character around the club. Can take a half decent mark, kicks ok (if not a bit unorthodox with his technique) and is starting to build a frame on his body. He’d wanna get a game or two in the seniors this year, or at least put in a good year at Coburg, to retain his spot on the list. Under the Wallace game plan (which should filter down to Coburg much better this year), Limbach could surprise if he stays injury free.