-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
Just thought I'd have a crack at seeing who's been good an who's been not so good
Newman-Probally cant have asked for more after coming back from a broken leg,Im still one who thinks he plays a little to loose on the oppositions dangerous forwards 6
Gaspar-Though its made us short down back,I think it was the correct desicion 2
Deledio-Played some outstanding football as well as 3 quiet games as he battles the heavy tag,we are just so reliant on such a young man 7
Raines-started slowly then started to win good amounts of the footy but his foot skills have gone backwards 5
Simmonds-No impact at all 2
Polak-Been very good an his marking has been oustanding,would love to see him get a few genuine KD jobs 8
Brown-Shown glimpse's of his brilliant best but just not on the park anywhere near enough 5
Reiwoldt-So very exciting at the Burgers an showed enough at AFL to say he will be around a while 7 mainly on Coburg form
Edwards-Just like Jack but more AFL games an looks a beauty 8
Bowden- How good would he be with good Key Backs around him ,cant have asked for more 8
Richo- Cant have asked for more from the big fella ,not as many matchwinning games now but pretty reliable 7
Knobel-MIA
Polo-8 games at 15 touches an some very good jobs done,was heading along OK 6
Pettifer-Was appauling early but has battled back pretty well to be one of our better players 6
P Bowdn-MIA
Johnson-No where near the tagger he was an foot skills have dropped off 4
KK-Hello good bye
Hall-MIA
Tuck-geez its been a mixed bag IMO some good games ,some poor,worked hard but consitently turned it over 6
Meyer-Hope the wheel's turning cause he has been just about the biggest dissapointment 1
Jackson-Improved every area of his game as well as some very good jobs ,from close to worst on list to now having a lot more below him 5
Coughlan-MIA
Shultz-Started ok then TW shafted him,but now his back working hard so fingers crossed 3
Pattison-Herculian effort fighting way out of his division,has improved so much as an all round player an some very good 20 plus games,just has to keep improving the kicking 6
Krakouer-Very poor year for whatever reason an surley wont be in Yellow an Black next year 1
Peterson-After no pre season has strung 6 games together an must be averaging 20 touches a game.
JON-Extemley dissapointing IMO has improved areas of his game but his kicking is clearley the worst at the club,hopefully be proven wrong but the worst draft selection mistake in years.....Tambling wasnt speculative. 3
Tambling-untill this week I thought at least he dosent have the 10 or less touches a game type games an even though he hasnt won a game of his own boot he has shown improvment 5
Hyde-gives his all an done some great passages ,but to me this year has proven his just a handy player in a weak side 4
Tivendale-Been ultra consistent an cant question his work rate now but just has to many negative influences on games for a senior player but there's been a lot worse 5.5
Hartigan-Battled injury again an it may just be all over 2
Hughes-6 goals in 2 weeks an gets the ass :
Like the Sarge,Bling,Meyer has talent but he has to work harder in saying that has shown enough an hopefully will finish the year with an impact at AFL then a flag with the BUrgers 4
White-Poor mans Hyde IMO simply not up to it 3
Thursfield-Struggled on the gorillas but other then that very good ,will be better for the run next year 5
Casserly-3 games in 3 games out if he ever gets right he will only help the cause 5
Mcguane-Really thougt he deserved to keep his spot an has dominated at VFL at only 20 Im not writing him off 6
Connors-On his VFL form has been 1 of the very few possitives this year 8
Moore-Feel he had his chance an didnt take it 3
Foley-Outstanding to be leading clearance player in the league is amazing ...wil win the JD medal 8
Collins-Bit like all the other Coburg boys ,what we have seen is very encouraging but the kid just cant get on the park 4
Howat-Runs his guts out an continues to improve as a player 5
Graham- definate improvment but is he up to it? 3
Clingan-Very good at the ressies ressies 5
King-Big surprise an his endevour could be a lesson for most 7
TW-Hard to judge on how his bringing the kids along i.e plan but he has got some spanking's in the box may just now realise he too has to do the hard yards an may not just be as good as he believe's.May be harsh but I said it along time a go but I want Royal gone dont want Tezza's mate kissin his ass all the time an too me he's not a born winner(yes I know he coached a bush flag)but sucess seems to follow some an some it dosent
Newman-Probally cant have asked for more after coming back from a broken leg,Im still one who thinks he plays a little to loose on the oppositions dangerous forwards 6
Gaspar-Though its made us short down back,I think it was the correct desicion 2
Deledio-Played some outstanding football as well as 3 quiet games as he battles the heavy tag,we are just so reliant on such a young man 7
Raines-started slowly then started to win good amounts of the footy but his foot skills have gone backwards 5
Simmonds-No impact at all 2
Polak-Been very good an his marking has been oustanding,would love to see him get a few genuine KD jobs 8
Brown-Shown glimpse's of his brilliant best but just not on the park anywhere near enough 5
Reiwoldt-So very exciting at the Burgers an showed enough at AFL to say he will be around a while 7 mainly on Coburg form
Edwards-Just like Jack but more AFL games an looks a beauty 8
Bowden- How good would he be with good Key Backs around him ,cant have asked for more 8
Richo- Cant have asked for more from the big fella ,not as many matchwinning games now but pretty reliable 7
Knobel-MIA
Polo-8 games at 15 touches an some very good jobs done,was heading along OK 6
Pettifer-Was appauling early but has battled back pretty well to be one of our better players 6
P Bowdn-MIA
Johnson-No where near the tagger he was an foot skills have dropped off 4
KK-Hello good bye
Hall-MIA
Tuck-geez its been a mixed bag IMO some good games ,some poor,worked hard but consitently turned it over 6
Meyer-Hope the wheel's turning cause he has been just about the biggest dissapointment 1
Jackson-Improved every area of his game as well as some very good jobs ,from close to worst on list to now having a lot more below him 5
Coughlan-MIA
Shultz-Started ok then TW shafted him,but now his back working hard so fingers crossed 3
Pattison-Herculian effort fighting way out of his division,has improved so much as an all round player an some very good 20 plus games,just has to keep improving the kicking 6
Krakouer-Very poor year for whatever reason an surley wont be in Yellow an Black next year 1
Peterson-After no pre season has strung 6 games together an must be averaging 20 touches a game.
JON-Extemley dissapointing IMO has improved areas of his game but his kicking is clearley the worst at the club,hopefully be proven wrong but the worst draft selection mistake in years.....Tambling wasnt speculative. 3
Tambling-untill this week I thought at least he dosent have the 10 or less touches a game type games an even though he hasnt won a game of his own boot he has shown improvment 5
Hyde-gives his all an done some great passages ,but to me this year has proven his just a handy player in a weak side 4
Tivendale-Been ultra consistent an cant question his work rate now but just has to many negative influences on games for a senior player but there's been a lot worse 5.5
Hartigan-Battled injury again an it may just be all over 2
Hughes-6 goals in 2 weeks an gets the ass :
Like the Sarge,Bling,Meyer has talent but he has to work harder in saying that has shown enough an hopefully will finish the year with an impact at AFL then a flag with the BUrgers 4White-Poor mans Hyde IMO simply not up to it 3
Thursfield-Struggled on the gorillas but other then that very good ,will be better for the run next year 5
Casserly-3 games in 3 games out if he ever gets right he will only help the cause 5
Mcguane-Really thougt he deserved to keep his spot an has dominated at VFL at only 20 Im not writing him off 6
Connors-On his VFL form has been 1 of the very few possitives this year 8
Moore-Feel he had his chance an didnt take it 3
Foley-Outstanding to be leading clearance player in the league is amazing ...wil win the JD medal 8
Collins-Bit like all the other Coburg boys ,what we have seen is very encouraging but the kid just cant get on the park 4
Howat-Runs his guts out an continues to improve as a player 5
Graham- definate improvment but is he up to it? 3
Clingan-Very good at the ressies ressies 5
King-Big surprise an his endevour could be a lesson for most 7
TW-Hard to judge on how his bringing the kids along i.e plan but he has got some spanking's in the box may just now realise he too has to do the hard yards an may not just be as good as he believe's.May be harsh but I said it along time a go but I want Royal gone dont want Tezza's mate kissin his ass all the time an too me he's not a born winner(yes I know he coached a bush flag)but sucess seems to follow some an some it dosent