If you could have your pick of 4 players from other clubs who would it be? | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

If you could have your pick of 4 players from other clubs who would it be?

hopper said:
Judd
Riewoldt
Pavlich
Rutten

Got it one, though maybe Murphy (Carl) at the expense of Pavlich to ensure we can keep delivery up to our fwds beyond 5 years.............  PS I'd also predict everyone will be wishing they got Hamish McIntosh (NM) in the years to come - there is an absolute void of decent up and coming ruckman.........
 
When you look at the youngsters we already have plus the ones we'll get in this years Gun ND Draft.............
The following would be the icing on the cake

B: Harris & Scarlett
CHB: C. Cornes
CHF: Jonathon Brown
 
Kirk
Judd
Cox
Dal Santo

Midfields are where games are won. Could win a flag with Petrie, Playfair, Bradley and Livingstone as your KP defenders and forwards if our current midfielders were combined with the above. ;D
 
Dal Santo (STK) - Awesome player

Aka (BRIS) - blend experience for a few years to help educate youth at the club. Great assets & draw card. $$ for the club

Marc Murphy (carl) - great long term talent

Judd (WCE) - self explanatory
 
Al Bundy said:
Dal Santo (STK) - Awesome player

Aka (BRIS) - blend experience for a few years to help educate youth at the club. Great assets & draw card. $$ for the club

Marc Murphy (carl) - great long term talent

Judd (WCE) - self explanatory

No kpps?
 
Putting to one side Judd, Ball, Hodge, Pav etc and focusing instead on young as yet un proven players who are likely to emerge in the next three years, I like Dowler, Muston and Tuck from Hawthorn, Drum from Freo, McIntosh from North, Minson from the Dogs and Salopek from Port.
 
1. C. Judd- obvious

2. N. Reiwoldt -

3. B. Mclean - need an inspirational work horse IMO.

4. D. Mundy - may cause a few eyebrows to raise, however this bloke will be just about the best Back in 3-4 years IMO. He is calm and cool under pressure and is rarely beaten.
 
I'll have:

C.Judd
L.Hayes
C.Cornes
N.Riewoldt (prefer B.Hall but you gotta take the younger)

Apologies to B.Kirk, B.McLean and C.Bruce. B.Hall and B.Rutten.

If you could have them at 20yo M.Voss and J.Hird are standouts.

It's a great exercise because you begin to see that even very average sides are only four or five stars off a premiership tilt. That's why IMO, at draft time, you should usually take a gamble for a champ over a safe bet on a flanker. Particularly when you're rebuilding.
 
Headland, N Davis, plastic tuff, and campereale, we need some steely enforcers in the side and these bloke fit the bill to a T.