Interesting Comparison

[Blueyboy74]

How would have last year Grand Finalist teams performed during 2008 with the following changes:

Geelong

In:

Deledio
Foley
Cotchin

Out:

Taylor
Selwood
Stokes


Hawthorn:

In:

Deledio
Foley
Cotchin
Tambling
Riewoldt
Thursfield

Out:
Birchall
Franklin
Roughead
Rioli
Young
Ellis

What do you think my point is?

 

[SkunkDen]

that we couldve chosen there players which intern wouldve meant they wouldve chosen our players???

id suggest geelong wouldve won the game with these changes. franklin & rioli out of hawthorn leaves a big fat X factor out of there side.

 

[ToraToraTora]

This is the comparison you need to make....replace Haw or Geel's bottom 10 or 12 with ours....then how would they have gone?

 

[Tubytiger]

This is the comparison you need to make....replace Haw or Geel's bottom 10 or 12 with ours....then how would they have gone?

Dont think those are our bottom 10 or 12 TTT. Gee wish it was.....

 

[ToraToraTora]

Who are not our bottom 10/12?

 

[Blueyboy74]

The comparison was that only 3 players who represented Geelong in the 08 GF and 6 Hawthorn players were drafted in the post-Frawley era. Make of that what you will.