Interesting question! | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Interesting question!

tigerdave

Ya just gotta stand in line
Feb 1, 2006
7,843
3
A good question was raised on 3aw saturday after our game.Who from Richmond would make the West Coast side.I can only think of 2 from our side-- Lid's & Simmonds. Thoughts please!
 
Bowden, Newman, Deledio, Simmonds, Foley, Richardson, Polak.

It's hard to say. Players like Tivandale and Pettifer might be guns at a team with a stronger midfield. Look at Rodan for example. On the other hand someone like Polak, who has been our best player so far might struggle with more competition like he did at Freo.
 
maybe foley until cousins returns.
and brown when fit.
I'd also take Richo before Lynch or Hansen
and Raines would snag a spot as well
Joel is all Australian so it goes without saying he'd get in every team in the AFL
 
poppa x said:
maybe foley until cousins returns.
and brown when fit.
I'd also take Richo before Lynch or Hansen
and Raines would snag a spot as well
Joel is all Australian so it goes without saying he'd get in every team in the AFL

Yep,fair call poppa about JB!
 
Turbo Tiger said:
Tambling :spin :spin :spin

And just out of (no)interest, how many from your team would make the West Coast side?

Lance Franklin... well at least he is from WA, so it may happen one day, he may even do a Des Headland ;) but who else?
 
tigerdave said:
A good question was raised on 3aw saturday after our game.Who from Richmond would make the West Coast side.I can only think of 2 from our side-- Lid's & Simmonds. Thoughts please!

I think a fair answer to this would be let's wait 4 or 5 years and see how our young guns stack up to theirs. Right now, probably lids, simmonds, polak, tambling, newman would get a gig.
 
Joel Bowden wouldn't get a gig at any other club besides this one, mediocrosy + success just don't go together, wake up people! Bottom eight for a reason!
 
TigersGoddess said:
Talon said:
Joel Bowden wouldn't get a gig at any other club besides this one, mediocrosy + success just don't go together, wake up people! Bottom eight for a reason!

Spose that goes along with All Australian selection too?
Fair Go Tigers Goddess, they hand them out to anyone, I've got 5 of them!