Is it too hasty to debut Polo, Hughes and McGuane this week?

[WesternTiger]

I like your team too Claw.

Only issue would be whether Thirsty and Razor are underdone.

However like you Liverpool I think Lids is wasted on the HBF

 

[outcast]

I think Will has played 5 games now so if not this week he should be pretty close...

 

[thomas the tiger]

Claw,

Not a bad team but

You can not leave Bowden out of the team.

How could anyone possibly want Krak to still get a game?????????? Was that Danny Frawley posting that comment to keep him in the pocket?

 

[geoffryprettyboy]

I think Will has played 5 games now so if not this week he should be pretty close...

How close do you think he is? What gives you that impression, do we desparetly need a backman?

 

[the claw]

sheesh when you look at the outs were not losing much.                       

Except our dual JD medalist. Are you crazy!

crazy as a cut snake but i wont go into bowden except to say hes had a free ride for the last 2 yrs. i want to keep my powder dry so to speak.

 

[Tigers of Old]

sheesh when you look at the outs were not losing much.

Except our dual JD medalist. Are you crazy!

crazy as a cut snake but i wont go into bowden except to say hes had a free ride for the last 2 yrs. i want to keep my powder dry so to speak.

He's still a far better option anywhere on the paddock than three quarters of the players you've selected in your side. It's laughable to suggest you'd drop him on the back of one game.

Aside from that I actually really like your team.

 

[The Mighty Wozman]

It has been well documented that Richmond only make surface level changes after horrific losses - let's hope "the Steamer" gets a run this week.

 

[linuscambridge]

Claw,

Not a bad team but

You can not leave Bowden out of the team.

How could anyone possibly want Krak to still get a game??????????  Was that Danny Frawley posting that comment to keep him in the pocket?

On the champion data stats from last week Krak was ranked 7th out of 22, that makes 15 other guys who should be dropped before Krak!!!

 

[Harry]

Polo ?  That's all we need - another slow unskilled plodder.

Harry. What has lead you to make this statement ? I'd be interested in your view on Polo and why.

Because I've seen enough of him to say that he's slow and un-skilled.....actually he's a shocking kick. We've got too many of this type - the plodder, wrestling/scragging/stacks-on types - you know like Coughlan, Tuck, Johnson, Hyde, even Foley and Krakour. Don't need anymore. Time to get players that have toe and can kick. Not at all disappointed that JON was our first pick coz we severly need more players of his type.

 

[Harry]

the side should be
backs   thursfield       gaspar    hartigan
h/b       deledio       hall      newman   
centre   tambling  coughlan   raines
h/f     brown   richardson   meyer
f       hughes   schulz    foley
ruck   knobel   tuck   johnson
int  simmonds   p bowden   jackson  hyde
out  pettifer krakouer  kellaway j bowden pattison  rodan tivendale
ins  thursfield hartigan  hall  meyer hughes knobel jackson.
sheesh when you look at the outs were not losing much.                       

See this is a ballsy selection !!!

Only one thing - change the bowden brothers and you've get it pretty acurate.

 

[Redford]

Polo ?  That's all we need - another slow unskilled plodder.

Harry. What has lead you to make this statement ? I'd be interested in your view on Polo and why.

Because I've seen enough of him to say that he's slow and un-skilled.....actually he's a shocking kick.  We've got too many of this type - the plodder, wrestling/scragging/stacks-on types - you know like Coughlan, Tuck, Johnson, Hyde, even Foley and Krakour.  Don't need anymore.  Time to get players that have toe and can kick.  Not at all disappointed that JON was our first pick coz we severly need more players of his type.

Whilst I totally agree with your objective criticism, be careful Harrison. The "sensitalia" will be all over you soon.....