Jack Dyer Medal - Post Your Top 10 | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Jack Dyer Medal - Post Your Top 10

Love to see Richo win it but here goes:

1. Tuck
2. Richo
3. Bowden
4. Cogs
5. Newman
6. Johnson
7. Brown
8. Campbell
9. Gaspar
10. Petiffer
 
1.Richo
2.Tuck/Bowden Tie
4.Newman
5.Cogs
6.johnson/Cambo tie
8.Pettifer
9.Simmonds
10.Delidio

39.Krakouar
 
1 tuck
2 richo
3 gas
4 bowden
5 cambo
6 brown
7 lids
8 cogs
9 brown
10 johnno
 
1.Shane Tuck
2.Kane Johnson/Richo (Tie)
3.Joel Bowden
4.Newman
5.Cogs/Brown (Tie)
6.Campbell
7.*smile*
8.Simmons
9.Deledio
10.Pettifer/Hall (Tie)
 
1 Richardson
2 Bowden
3 Tuck
4 Johnson
5 Brown
6 Gaspar
7 Cogs
8 Newman
9 Simmonds
10 Lids
11 Campbell
 
1 Tuck - should win it by miles
2 Richo - gotta love the big guy and has put in a big year.
3 Bowdo- consistent year this year
4 Lids - had a fantastic year and would not surprise me if he finished higher
5 Gas - since coming back from a serious knee has done a mighty job
6 Sugar - despite what some think, a great captain for this club and a good year.
7 Cogs - the left over OP really still limited him this year
8 Newman - like the guy, has a real go and has had a solid year.
9 Hall - not in the limelight but has done some bloody great jobs this year.
10 Pettifer - all in all a solid year and has stepped up a cog this year but needed to.
 
Leysy likes -

1.Tuck
2.Richo
3.Bowden
4.Coughlan
5.Gaspar
6.Brown
7.Pettifer
8.Deledio
9.Johnson
10.Newman

Leysy not sure how everyone has Johnno up so high, been pretty average, beaten most weeks IMO, anyways it is bloody hard outside the top 3 or 4 innit
 
1. Bowden
2. Tuck
3. Richardson
4. Newman
5. Brown
6. Coughlan
7. Pettifer
8. Gaspar
9. Simmonds
10. Kellaway
 
Bowden
Tuck
Coughlan
Richo
Campbell
Johnson
Newman
Brown
Deledio
Kellaway


Apologies to Chaffey.

Not cos he didnt make my top ten, just cos I'm feeling a bit guilty for bagging him all year
 
1. Richo
2. Tuck
3. Bowden
4. Coughlan
5. Campbell
6. Brown
7. Kellaway
8. *smile*
9. Simmonds
10. Pettifer

Unlucky: Hyde, Deledio, Newman, Johnson
 
1 Tuck
2 Richardson
3 Bowden
4 Brown
5 Deledio
6 Campbell
7 Coughlan
8 Johnson
9 Hyde
10 Kellaway
 
I don't know what the voting structure is this year - if every player gets some sort of vote then one of those who has played every game will win it (in the past you seemed to be awarded 5/10 just for sitting on the bench all day....), but if it just the top 10 players receiving votes each game then players who missed games like Richo have a better chance, anyway here goes:

1/ Tuck
2/ Bowden
3/ Richo
4/ Newman
5/ Coughlan
6/ Johnson
7/ Brown
8/ Campbell
9/ Deledio
10/ Hall

Knobel would have been up there had he played the full season, Gaspar may be up there as some reckon a few good games make a good season.
 
TIGEREXTRA said:
1.Shane Tuck
2.Kane Johnson/Richo (Tie)
3.Joel Bowden
4.Newman
5.Cogs/Brown (Tie)
6.Campbell
7.*smile*
8.Simmons
9.Deledio
10.Pettifer/Hall (Tie)
Click to expand...

Official Results:

1st: Joel Bowden 221
2nd: Matthew Richardson 220
3rd: Shane Tuck 197
4th: Darren Gaspar 184
5th: Mark Coughlan 172
6th: Chris Newman 171
7th: Kane Johnson 147
8th: Wayne Campbell 141
9th: Troy Simmonds 140
10th: Nathan Brown 129


Thought some PREnders would like to see how they went in predicting the top 10.

Oh well, I got Richo right! :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
< MVP | New website launch / Volunteer writers required [Merged] >
Top Bottom