Journalistic Crap | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Journalistic Crap

gustiger12

Its Tiger Time
Jan 22, 2003
9,933
3
www.thaigerpics.com
Anyone read the article "Tigers thump bumbling Bombers" in the Sunday Herald Sun by Mark HARDING.

Two quotes really irked me.

"But here's a warning for Tiger fans who will now be talking top four: the reality check they usually get when they play the Dons might come a week or two later when they realise that their oposition yesterday was substandard"

AND

"Make no mistake this was a game of appalling quality. The Tigers made enough skill errors in the first quarter for the old Essendon to have capitalised and broken the game apart"

Does this sound like sour grapes from a typical Bummer supporter. Sure they were undermanned, but am I missing something here. CAMPBELL, RICHO, OTTENS, HOLLAND, BLUMMFIELD just to name a few.

Is he talking about how we made so many mistakes that the Bombers only were kept goal less for over a quarter and a half. I thought LOYD, LUCAS and HIRD all took the field at the start of play, and then this;

"While injuries have hurt the club, especially the kick to the calf that took James HIRD out of he match at the 10-minute mark, there were no excuses for the slipping, fumbling, inept tackling and shoddy field kicking from those fit to take their place"

Well I thought it was Chaffs knee doing the damage to HIRDS calf when he accidentally fell on him during a contest. Or is the writer trying to suggest something more sinister. Maybe back to a Video review to see if Chaffs was negligent or reckless for contesting the ball.

I wonder if the pressure at the contest may have had something to do with the clangers.

Even Mike SHEEHAN wrote us up today and admitted that many may have underestimated the Tigers.

Whilst I don't want to get to carried away at this stage, but surely credit where credit is due.

If you read that article you could almost think that Essendon were just so unlucky to have lost it was a travesty of justice.

We killed them out of the middle, smashed them at the stoppages, yet at the end of the day we only went into our forward 50 two more times than them yet had 29 scoring shots to 17 and should have beaten them by 60 points plus if we had kicked a little more accurately in the second quarter.

I hope this Journo, and I use that term loosely, has looked at the ladder this morning.

Now I hope that Melbournes form yesterday was a one of as a result of the press they copped during the week and they revert to their old ways by next Saturday night.
 
I wouldn't be too worried about what some journo has to say Gus.

I know when we have a reason to feel good about a win. Never mind the way the game looked or the way the game was played.

Look at how we won and why we won. That's all that matters to me. No journo is going to sour the victory for me.

If we can approach every game the way we did on Saturday, then when we get some players back we can start to have a real impact on the competition.

In 2001, I thought where we fell down was that we took the foot off after a win. It seemed to me like we were a bit comfortable with ourselves and perhaps weren't as mentally switched on going into some games as we could have been. So if we can have that approach going into each game, we can cause a few headaches to the opposition before the season is out.

If people are still cynical about the Tigers, let them be. We can only get better.
 
I hate it when the Tiges are flavour of the month in the papers, though I expect the current team might be different previous years when they seemed to get too carried away with what the press had to say about them.
I think this will be the first game all season where we've started favourites.
That's pretty amazing imo, but somehow it makes me nervous.
I'm glad Melbourne had a win. Stick with them Mike Sheehan and all you other journos, we don't need you anyway.
I'd prefer the team to do the talking.
Go Tiges, Stick it up them all.
 
You make a very good point MC24 - in previous years we did tend to take the foot off the pedal after wins and expected wins to come our way. This year appears different in that our intensity hasn't fallen even after a win. MC24 I believe the difference is the guy in your avatar. Cogs sets them all alight and sets the tone every week. Does anyone know who is leading the comp in clearences and hardball gets? Also tackles? It'll be interesting to see where Cogs is sitting with these stats. He is definately our next captain.
 
Thats a pretty big prediction Harry and I hope you're right. All we need to do is hang on to him. Maybe the lure of future captaincy will keep him loyal to the Tiges!
Can you imagine the frenzy of interest if Cogs came off contract!
Does anyone know what sort of contract he's on??
What ever it is the Tiges should stitch him up until he's elligible for a pensioners discount card! ;D
Even then I'd still put an option clause on him. He could use his zimmer frame to great effect in close contests! ;D
 
Harry said:
Does anyone know who is leading the comp in clearences and hardball gets? Also tackles? It'll be interesting to see where Cogs is sitting with these stats. He is definately our next captain.

Canno t help you with all of them Harry but before round seven Cogs was second in the league for tackles. He had 34 while Troy Cook from the Dockers had 39 and was first.