journalists

[yandb]

i don't know what some of you fellow posters think of the current level of journalism we have to put up with . i for one think many 15 year olds could do just as well . take that report on richmond in the sun last week , all they seem to do was state the obvious and rehash some statistics . there are posters here that could have done a far better job with far less resources.


how about we have a section where we rate the journalists and their articles. we could put the article up for discussion and vote for a rating .after a few articles it would be obvious if the journalist is worth reading or just someone who dishes out bull manure .

thoughts?????????????????????????????????

 

[TIGEREXTRA]

Not a bad idea yandb.

 

[Anduril]

Considering the journalist here:

http://www.puntroadend.com/yabbse/index.php?topic=17610.from1126169314#new

had Gas and Sugar as playing every game......... speaks volumes.

 

[Skills]

i don't know what some of you fellow posters think of the current level of journalism we have to put up with . i for one think many 15 year olds could do just as well . take that report on richmond in the sun last week , all they seem to do was state the obvious and rehash some statistics . there are posters here that could have done a far better job with far less resources.

I'm betting Caroline Wilson didn't write the article. :

 

[Stuart]

Considering the journalist here:

http://www.puntroadend.com/yabbse/index.php?topic=17610.from1126169314#new

had Gas and Sugar as playing every game......... speaks volumes.

Yeah, I saw that as well. I though to myself, not really much point reading on as they have no clue. When making points about being lucky with injuries, you would think a paid journo would take the time to check the facts. What a joke!

 

[craig]

Cretins

 

[Rosy]

how about we have a section where we rate the journalists and their articles....

thoughts?????????????????????????????????

Could be done on the What the Journos Say board.

As for doing better Tony Greenberg has told me he'd welcome articles from PREnders to publish on the club site, and credit both the author and PRE, if anybody is capable of writing appropriate material at a suitable standard.  

 

[the claw]

how about we have a section where we rate the journalists and their articles....

thoughts?????????????????????????????????

Could be done on the What the Journos Say board.

As for doing better Tony Greenberg has told me he'd welcome articles from PREnders to publish on the club site, and credit both the author and PRE, if anybody is capable of writing appropriate material at a suitable standard.  

in other words brightsiders only.

 

[Stuart]

how about we have a section where we rate the journalists and their articles....

thoughts?????????????????????????????????

Could be done on the What the Journos Say board.

As for doing better Tony Greenberg has told me he'd welcome articles from PREnders to publish on the club site, and credit both the author and PRE, if anybody is capable of writing appropriate material at a suitable standard.  

in other words brightsiders only.

LOL. Claw, couldn't have said it better myself.

 

[Skills]

how about we have a section where we rate the journalists and their articles....

thoughts?????????????????????????????????

Could be done on the What the Journos Say board.

"...and credit both the author and PRE, if anybody is capable of writing appropriate material at a suitable standard." 

Sounds interesting. Could you please ask Tony what he is specifically looking for? (ie. Topics).

 

[craig]

how about we have a section where we rate the journalists and their articles....

thoughts?????????????????????????????????

Could be done on the What the Journos Say board.

As for doing better Tony Greenberg has told me he'd welcome articles from PREnders to publish on the club site, and credit both the author and PRE, if anybody is capable of writing appropriate material at a suitable standard.  

in other words brightsiders only.

EXAKKERRY hahahahahaa. Brightsiders only Tee Hee. I'd be happy to write an article but it would never go to print. :-X ;D

 

[Rosy]

in other words brightsiders only.

I guess that's the nature of the beast santa. I can't imagine a vitriolic post telling everyone all about our duds being published on the official club site.

 

[jonnomc]

Alistair Lynch Rated TW 5 out of 10 i would have put him at 7 out of 10 coz he got our team 1 game out of the finals he did better than Leigh Matthews

 

[RemoteTiger]

As for doing better Tony Greenberg has told me he'd welcome articles from PREnders to publish on the club site, and credit both the author and PRE, if anybody is capable of writing appropriate material at a suitable standard.

in other words brightsiders only.

Probably Claw - because the type of articles that Tony would need are the ones that are supported by facts and not thse that are simply the opinion of a deluded morbid individual...............

 

[Tigerdog]

G'day Mr Shehan. :wave