GoodOne said:Ridiculous comment. Do you think WA and Carlton would have been interested in Coughlan if they could see the future? You'll have to come up with a better argument than that.
I had the argument about trading him at the time too with people I know.
Carlton at the least were interested when his groin was shot and he could barely walk let alone run.
Richmond made a mistake on Cogs. Regardless of whether he comes back to senior standard or not. 4 years down the tubes for zero return.