I know Johnson loves the club, but as a captain he is a serious liability, the only thing he won on Friday night was the toss. I can count on the fingers of one hand the amount of times he moved the ball forward last year. He's a negative player. He's about as noisy as Humphrey Bear on the field. There doesn't seem to be any passion about the way he plays. I take the 2 flags at Adelaide with a grain of salt, yes he was in the sides and he had to be good to get there, but he was the 4th best midfielder there and even in a side as astonishingly average as Richmond he doesn't look to be our best midfielder. Newman plays with passion, he should be moved into the midfield, he is too loose in defence. Tuck seriously needs help from another mature bodied player in there and Newman could provide, plus he can actually kick the ball, a skill that has evaded Tuck. Don't tell me you weren't inspired when he kicked that goal from 80 metres out against Freo last year. He's also a signal toward the future. Johnson won't be there for much longer.