Next Year - Would we be any worse if: | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Next Year - Would we be any worse if:

Tango said:
Ok lets look forward, would we be better off in the long run if the following happened:

1. Lids made captain

2. Johnno, Richo, Gaspar, Kellaway, Chaffey, Tivendale, Stafford all retired

3. Bowden brothers, Krakour & Cogs - all traded

Why not keep it simpler and only have pleyers 19 years old or less in the senior side???

Silly silly thread.
 
What i truly think i will hold back till years end or if we have another couple performances like we had last Friday against the Saints, Coasters and the Lions and if we lose to the Blues and are 0-5
 
iitb said:
Tango said:
Ok lets look forward, would we be better off in the long run if the following happened:

1. Lids made captain

2. Johnno, Richo, Gaspar, Kellaway, Chaffey, Tivendale, Stafford all retired

3. Bowden brothers, Krakour & Cogs - all traded

Why not keep it simpler and only have pleyers 19 years old or less in the senior side???

Silly silly thread.
rather have a team of committed and united 19 yo who play for pride, team and jumper than overpaid players who play for personal stats and avoid contact to protect themselves

by the way, it still leaves Knoble, Tuck, Pettifer, Hall, Newman, *smile*, Brown all over 20 still in the side
 
Agree in parts. Lids will be a future captain if we can hold on to him. Kellaway(?) & Stafford to retire at years end. Chaffey & Tivendale to be delisted/traded depending on contracts. Gas- not sure. P. Bowden was a wasted pick. Groom a youngster. Would not lose any sleep if J.Bowden was put up for trade. Krakouer on very thin ice. Cogs to be given the benefit of the doubt at the minute. Assess at end of year.
 
Tango said:
Ok lets look forward, would we be better off in the long run if the following happened:

1. Lids made captain

2. Johnno, Richo, Gaspar, Kellaway, Chaffey, Tivendale, Stafford all retired

3. Bowden brothers, Krakour & Cogs - all traded

Lisa not captain yet
No to Johnno or Richo
Gas is at cross-roads
Chaff, Tiv, Staff - May be final yr at tigers unless they do something real special this season
Bowden brother done nothing wrong
Need to look at a trade for Krak, hes had enough time now
Cogs wont be traded, but boy I hope he finds some of that old form
 
Why would we encourage Johnno to go? We gave away two early draft picks to get a midfielder who was both consistent and who knew what champagne poured from the AFL premiership cup tastes like. Whether we should or shouldn't of is history, not much point short changing us now though.