Next years team | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Next years team

Ghost of Punt Road

Ghost of Punt Road

Tiger Champion
Dec 21, 2004
2,772
353
Under the Punt Road Stand
www.victoria.org.au
We cant carry daft players, players who just don't get involved, and players who spray it.

We are left with heaps of players who are untried kids, but we need to get rid of these 'talented' kids who just don'y touch the ball.

Krakouer, Meyer, Tambling SHOULD be culled. Of course we can't because we give long term contacts to people unsuited to their job.

Tivendale and Hyde are possibly worth another year.

Tuck needs to be played in the forward line only, or no-where.

Howat and Johnson we don't need.

Moore and McGuane are dubious.

Pattison really doesn't have a role in AFL despite showing a bit. Who needs a 198cm wandering midfielder?
 
Moore & Krakouer gone. Tambling just average, still hoping. Agree regarding Howat and yet to be convinced on King. Watching Conners, Reiwoldt and Edwards gives me hope we might be on the right track with Jackson and his recruiting. Gee the 04 (Deledio excepted) & 05 drafees want to get a hurry on....! :'(
 
FB J.King VACANCY* G. Polehack
HB B. DeLedio Import VACANCY
C VACANCY VACANCY VACANCY
HF K.Pettifer VACANCY VACANCY
FF N.G.Brown Richo VACANCY
R T.Simmonds VACANCY N.Foley

Int: Import Ruck Newman J.Bowden S.Edwards
*I don't think Wallet will play J. Bowden in a key defensive slot next year. If he doesn't I don't know where else you play him. Slow sweepers are a waste of park space IMO. And he's not a midfielder. I dunno.

Let's hope the VACANCIES trifecta the B&F next year. The hope of the side.
 
Ghost of Punt Road said:
We cant carry daft players, players who just don't get involved, and players who spray it.

We are left with heaps of players who are untried kids, but we need to get rid of these 'talented' kids who just don'y touch the ball.

Krakouer, Meyer, Tambling SHOULD be culled. Of course we can't because we give long term contacts to people unsuited to their job.

Tivendale and Hyde are possibly worth another year.

Tuck needs to be played in the forward line only, or no-where.

Howat and Johnson we don't need.

Moore and McGuane are dubious.

Pattison really doesn't have a role in AFL despite showing a bit. Who needs a 198cm wandering midfielder?
Click to expand...


i see so many things rong here...that im not even guna bother argueing!
 
tuck- should never be allowed to kick the ball again (unless he's having a shot at goal!)

hughes- terry he's a forward not a backman!!

anybody under the age of 22 your pre season will consist of weights only!(i'm sick of players breaking our tackles!)

raines-play him inthe middle , showed some good signs last night :)

i think we need to persist with meyer, tambling and jon, they will come on with some help from mcrae or dare i say it sheedy in a player develop role?

time to go: tivers
hall
howart
krack
moore
and one or two others
 
futuretigers said:
Ghost of Punt Road said:
We cant carry daft players, players who just don't get involved, and players who spray it.

We are left with heaps of players who are untried kids, but we need to get rid of these 'talented' kids who just don'y touch the ball.

Krakouer, Meyer, Tambling SHOULD be culled. Of course we can't because we give long term contacts to people unsuited to their job.

Tivendale and Hyde are possibly worth another year.

Tuck needs to be played in the forward line only, or no-where.

Howat and Johnson we don't need.

Moore and McGuane are dubious.

Pattison really doesn't have a role in AFL despite showing a bit. Who needs a 198cm wandering midfielder?
Click to expand...


i see so many things rong here...that im not even guna bother argueing!
Click to expand...

Gee most of the players up there should be GONE tmrw!
 
mtench said:
tuck- should never be allowed to kick the ball again (unless he's having a shot at goal!)

hughes- terry he's a forward not a backman!!

anybody under the age of 22 your pre season will consist of weights only!(i'm sick of players breaking our tackles!)

raines-play him inthe middle , showed some good signs last night :)

i think we need to persist with meyer, tambling and jon, they will come on with some help from mcrae or dare i say it sheedy in a player develop role?

time to go: tivers
hall
howart
krack
moore
and one or two others
Click to expand...

Well if Tuck cant kick its hoo roo time. He can go and play Handball in Beijing
 
tigersforever06 said:
mtench said:
tuck- should never be allowed to kick the ball again (unless he's having a shot at goal!)

hughes- terry he's a forward not a backman!!

anybody under the age of 22 your pre season will consist of weights only!(i'm sick of players breaking our tackles!)

raines-play him inthe middle , showed some good signs last night :)

i think we need to persist with meyer, tambling and jon, they will come on with some help from mcrae or dare i say it sheedy in a player develop role?

time to go: tivers
hall
howart
krack
moore
and one or two others
Click to expand...

Well if Tuck cant kick its hoo roo time. He can go and play Handball in Beijing
Click to expand...
well bye bye then!

against port i saw him try to pass the ball back to hyde i think. he was only 5 meters away and couldn't hit him? whats wrong with this picture? there wasn't even any game pressure!!!!
 
Dyer'ere said:
FB J.King VACANCY* G. Polehack
HB B. DeLedio Import VACANCY
C VACANCY VACANCY VACANCY
HF K.Pettifer VACANCY VACANCY
FF N.G.Brown Richo VACANCY
R T.Simmonds VACANCY N.Foley

Int: Import Ruck Newman J.Bowden S.Edwards
*I don't think Wallet will play J. Bowden in a key defensive slot next year. If he doesn't I don't know where else you play him. Slow sweepers are a waste of park space IMO. And he's not a midfielder. I dunno.

Let's hope the VACANCIES trifecta the B&F next year. The hope of the side.
Click to expand...

Your team should include Tambling and Polo for starters. Hughes will make it as will Raines. Jack and Conners are likely to be there also from what we've seen.
 
mtench said:
tigersforever06 said:
mtench said:
tuck- should never be allowed to kick the ball again (unless he's having a shot at goal!)

hughes- terry he's a forward not a backman!!

anybody under the age of 22 your pre season will consist of weights only!(i'm sick of players breaking our tackles!)

raines-play him inthe middle , showed some good signs last night :)

i think we need to persist with meyer, tambling and jon, they will come on with some help from mcrae or dare i say it sheedy in a player develop role?

time to go: tivers
hall
howart
krack
moore
and one or two others
Click to expand...

Well if Tuck cant kick its hoo roo time. He can go and play Handball in Beijing
Click to expand...
well bye bye then!

against port i saw him try to pass the ball back to hyde i think. he was only 5 meters away and couldn't hit him? whats wrong with this picture? there wasn't even any game pressure!!!!
Click to expand...
Hyde didnt play.
 
B........King............Schulz..........Thursfield
HB......Casserly.....Polak...........Connors
C........Deledio.......Bowden.......Edwards
HF......Cotchin.......Riewoldt.......Pettifer
F........Brown.........Richo............Hughes
Foll....Simmo.........Newman......Foley
Int.....Patto..........Polo......Coughlan.......2007 recruit
 
If it was me:


FB:    King      Thursfield  McGuane

HB: Casserly      Polak      Connors

C:  Tambling    Newman    Deledio

HF: Riewoldt    Hughes    Edwards

FF:  Brown        Schulz      Pettifer

R. Simmonds, Foley, Polo

Int/Emerg: Pattison, Richo, Cotchin*, Cogs, Wood, JON, Sugar, Meyer, White, Peterson etc



* Yep Richo on the bench...club needs to start realising he wont be in our next premiership side...should start focusing on a Schulz, Hughes, JR combination.

*Id trade Raines to Brisbane for Cam Wood. Then use whatever pick we get either 1 or 2 on the best midfielder - Cotchin?

* Thursfield, McGuane and Polak the 3 key backs...with possibly another from a trade. All need to sit their bums in the Gym all Summer.

* Newman to play on ball.

* Casserly and Connors on the flanks...have to start playing these guys who can kick. its getting beyond the joke - GET GAMES INTO THEM! Swap with JON.

* Foley, Polo, Newman, Cogs - get the pill and dish to Deledio, Edwards, Bling etc.

* One of (if not both) Tuck and Bowden traded for picks and possibly a youngster ala Prismall.

*De-listed are Knobel, Hall, Moore, Howat, Tivendale, Krakouer (if he cant b traded), Hyde, Hartigan and possibly Jackson.

*Sugar remains but Brown becomes captain for at least 2008.

....have to start making some tough calls on these guys!
 
tha8ball said:
If it was me:


FB: King Thursfield McGuane

HB: Casserly Polak Connors

C: Tambling Newman Deledio

HF: Riewoldt Hughes Edwards

FF: Brown Schulz Pettifer

R. Simmonds, Foley, Polo

Int/Emerg: Pattison, Richo, Cotchin*, Cogs, Wood, JON, Sugar, Meyer, White, Peterson etc



* Yep Richo on the bench...club needs to start realising he wont be in our next premiership side...should start focusing on a Schulz, Hughes, JR combination.

*Id trade Raines to Brisbane for Cam Wood. Then use whatever pick we get either 1 or 2 on the best midfielder - Cotchin?

* Thursfield, McGuane and Polak the 3 key backs...with possibly another from a trade. All need to sit their bums in the Gym all Summer.

* Newman to play on ball.

* Casserly and Connors on the flanks...have to start playing these guys who can kick. its getting beyond the joke - GET GAMES INTO THEM! Swap with JON.

* Foley, Polo, Newman, Cogs - get the pill and dish to Deledio, Edwards, Bling etc.

* One of (if not both) Tuck and Bowden traded for picks and possibly a youngster ala Prismall.

*De-listed are Knobel, Hall, Moore, Howat, Tivendale, Krakouer (if he cant b traded), Hyde, Hartigan and possibly Jackson.

*Sugar remains but Brown becomes captain for at least 2008.

....have to start making some tough calls on these guys!
Click to expand...

The last time we traded to Brisbane for players we ended up with Morrison. If a player can't get a game with Brisbane then we don't want him. Raines is one of our few kids who earn a game in the ones. Maybe Wood is the fourth in line ruck because he is no good.

Thank Brisbane very much but they can keep their drafting errors and we can keep ours.
 
B:King,Rance,Thursfield
HB:Casserly,Polak,Newman
C:Tambling,Deledio,Edwards
HF:Meyer,Hughes,Revolt
F:Brown,Richo,Kruezer
R:Simmonds,Judd,Foley
I/C:Pattison,JON,Conners,Cogs

;D ;D ;D ;D
 
Charman, MacDonald, Wood and Leunberger...perhaps thats why Wood struggles to get a game.... Raines would struggle to get a game at brissy lets be honest.
 
checkside said:
mtench said:
tigersforever06 said:
mtench said:
tuck- should never be allowed to kick the ball again (unless he's having a shot at goal!)

hughes- terry he's a forward not a backman!!

anybody under the age of 22 your pre season will consist of weights only!(i'm sick of players breaking our tackles!)

raines-play him inthe middle , showed some good signs last night :)

i think we need to persist with meyer, tambling and jon, they will come on with some help from mcrae or dare i say it sheedy in a player develop role?

time to go: tivers
hall
howart
krack
moore
and one or two others
Click to expand...

Well if Tuck cant kick its hoo roo time. He can go and play Handball in Beijing
Click to expand...
well bye bye then!

against port i saw him try to pass the ball back to hyde i think. he was only 5 meters away and couldn't hit him? whats wrong with this picture? there wasn't even any game pressure!!!!
Click to expand...
Hyde didnt play.
Click to expand...

Maybe thats why he missed him, he was seeing things!!
 
IN A PERFECT WORLD


B Thursfield RANCE MORTON

HB Zac MILLAR Polak Casserly

C Deledio MASTEN Connors

HF SELWOOD Hughes Edwards

F Brown Jack Richo


Rucks Simmonds - COTCHIN - Foley -


Interchange from - WOOD, KREUZER, PRISMALL, HENDERSON, KANGARS, DE BRUIN, ELLARD , Raines, Polo, Tambling, Newman, Jon, Pattison, McGuane,



;D ;D ;D ;D ;D


Now back to the real world. :'(
 
tha8ball said:
If it was me:


FB: King Thursfield McGuane

HB: Casserly Polak Connors

C: Tambling Newman Deledio

HF: Riewoldt Hughes Edwards

FF: Brown Schulz Pettifer

R. Simmonds, Foley, Polo

Int/Emerg: Pattison, Richo, Cotchin*, Cogs, Wood, JON, Sugar, Meyer, White, Peterson etc



* Yep Richo on the bench...club needs to start realising he wont be in our next premiership side...should start focusing on a Schulz, Hughes, JR combination.

*Id trade Raines to Brisbane for Cam Wood. Then use whatever pick we get either 1 or 2 on the best midfielder - Cotchin?

* Thursfield, McGuane and Polak the 3 key backs...with possibly another from a trade. All need to sit their bums in the Gym all Summer.

* Newman to play on ball.

* Casserly and Connors on the flanks...have to start playing these guys who can kick. its getting beyond the joke - GET GAMES INTO THEM! Swap with JON.

* Foley, Polo, Newman, Cogs - get the pill and dish to Deledio, Edwards, Bling etc.

* One of (if not both) Tuck and Bowden traded for picks and possibly a youngster ala Prismall.

*De-listed are Knobel, Hall, Moore, Howat, Tivendale, Krakouer (if he cant b traded), Hyde, Hartigan and possibly Jackson.

*Sugar remains but Brown becomes captain for at least 2008.

....have to start making some tough calls on these guys!
Click to expand...

As usual 8ty you make a lot of sense.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
< The TW / RFC support thread. | Please Carlton...Win. Damn U! >
Top Bottom