Nick Daffy - unfairly dismissed on PRE??? | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Nick Daffy - unfairly dismissed on PRE???

Hungry said:
Spot on Jack, the Knights injury came at a terrible time. Don't forget Freezer was also unable to get back on the park. Was Turner starting to struggle with injury too?

But the other thing that hurt us was losing Stewart Maxfield - he had a breakout year at the Swans in 96. And Justin Murphy had a good year at Carlton. Both of those would have given us some more run during a couple of close losses, which cost us finals yet again, and possibly turned these losses into close wins.

We should have done better that year no doubt. However, our recruiting around that period - 95/96 - was abysmal and would have caught up wtih us sooner or later regardless!

On a side issue we should never have sacked Walls during the following year - it was a total over-reaction borne from over-rating our list. Say what you like but Walls is streets ahead of Geisch and Frawley as a coach!

Touching on from what Ridley said earlier and this post, Daffy and a few of his clique did indeed start getting ahead of thjemselves.

Walls came to the club and challenged those in "the clique" and told them a few home truths about their attitudes; deficiencies; and overall dedication.

They did not like this. In fact, they refused to take any of Walls' constructive criticism on board. Basically, a soft mutiny took place i.e. "the clique" did not play for him and it was the demise of Walls on that dark Adelaide night.
 
The Mighty Wozman said:
Touching on from what Ridley said earlier and this post, Daffy and a few of his clique did indeed start getting ahead of thjemselves.

Walls came to the club and challenged those in "the clique" and told them a few home truths about their attitudes; deficiencies; and overall dedication.

They did not like this. In fact, they refused to take any of Walls' constructive criticism on board. Basically, a soft mutiny took place i.e. "the clique" did not play for him and it was the demise of Walls on that dark Adelaide night.
The tail wagged the dog, as it appeared to when Walls' replacement Gieschen was pushed out a couple of years later.

I was quite excited getting Walls....I thought his tactical nouse would help lift us to another level, and was way ahead of Northey, who relied on passion and commitment. Unfortunately, while we may have got one, we lost the other.
 
Leysy is good mates with an ex-tiger from the late 90's.

He rarely has a bad word to say about anyone & is good mates with a lot of the senior clan at that time. However along with others couldn't stand Daffy & his selfish, self-centred appoach both on & off the field.

Ironically, Leysy understands a similar thing is thought about a current player who plays a somewhat comparible role :-X
 
Leysy Days said:
Leysy is good mates with an ex-tiger from the late 90's.

He rarely has a bad word to say about anyone & is good mates with a lot of the senior clan at that time. However along with others couldn't stand Daffy & his selfish, self-centred appoach both on & off the field.

Ironically, Leysy understands a similar thing is thought about a current player who plays a somewhat comparible role :-X

hmmmm - Petifer is a HFF only and does not play in the midfiled so I guess that counts him out. Surely he was not referring to Lids....
 
Punxsutawney Phil said:
The tail wagged the dog, as it appeared to when Walls' replacement Gieschen was pushed out a couple of years later.

I was quite excited getting Walls....I thought his tactical nouse would help lift us to another level, and was way ahead of Northey, who relied on passion and commitment. Unfortunately, while we may have got one, we lost the other.

Yeah, same happened to the Giesh. Although, by this stage, Gaspar had now become a player in the leading "clique." This is not a joke, these players had more leverage over our club between the period of 1996-2004 than any coach, president or board.
 
Hungry said:
On a side issue we should never have sacked Walls during the following year - it was a total over-reaction borne from over-rating our list. Say what you like but Walls is streets ahead of Geisch and Frawley as a coach!

After the game that prompted Walls' sacking - a 130+ point loss in Adelaide - quite a few players hit the grog and ran amok at the hotel.
 
LeeToRainesToRoach said:
After the game that prompted Walls' sacking - a 130+ point loss in Adelaide - quite a few players hit the grog and ran amok at the hotel.
Should have sacked them all. Different times now...
 
I've always hated him, was absolutely rapt when we tarded him, I would taken Shaun McManus or Richard Champion for him. Fair Dinkum, anything to get him out the door.

When Dapne had a big press conference announcing he'd signed 'the big 4' of Richo, WC, MK and Daffy, Me and my entire family collectively thought, 'god help us'. The fact we rated him as part of a big 4 speaks volumes about out administrative ineptitude. We had a big 3 full stop. I honestly reckon it was fatal, think about it, placing an OK player at best as a marque player, imagine what that does to team morale, recruiting and salary cap, not giving kids games, etc etc, its massive. A good coach would have traded him when his stocks were at their highest for a good player and a high pick and snagged a flag. Not us, Nooooo. We give him 4 years and the grandstand.

Reading the above posts confirms my suspicions that he must have been a master at club politics to meneouvre himself into 'big 4' status in the eyes of the heirarchy. While as I said above, acknowledge that he had his rare moments and a couple of decent seasons, (as did Jamie Tape) I always said once he went into the midfield he was a liability, said it then and still say it.

in conlcusion, I suggest that Daffy was fairly dismiised on PRE, and anywhere else he's been dismissed. A millstone that set us back 5 years. But then again we're always getting set back 5 years so he's really a symptom rather than a cause.
 
Hmm. Read through all your negative posts and drew one conclusion. Who cares about his playing ability. He was sooooooooooooo gorgeous :hearton
 
Welcome back Mrs D,

Someone must have taken over Nick's mantle by now? What about the ginger - Kelvin Moore? He's a bit of alright aint he...
 
Leysy Days said:
Welcome back Mrs D,

Someone must have taken over Nick's mantle by now? What about the ginger - Kelvin Moore? He's a bit of alright aint he...

Moore is useless. There may be a poster on this site who runs a very close second to Nick. Hasn't quite taken over the mantle yet though.