Our Best 22 disreguarding positions?

[Jason King]

Richo has 66 votes out of 69. How could anyone in their right mind not think that Richo is in our best 22 when fully fit??

Maybe they are not in their right mind ? :cutelaugh

 

[tamtiga]

first 12 wereeasy . . . . after that it got a bit slim pickings.

have to consider cougs hasnt played alot in last few seasons etc. . . . ..

 

[Tigermad2005]

Pick two in the draft who ever he is will be in our best 22.

 

[Maxwell]

Here is the list in order:

Bowden 87 (4.5%)
Brown 87 (4.5%)
Deledio 87 (4.5%)
Foley 87 (4.5%)
Polak 87 (4.5%)
Simmonds 87 (4.5%)
Coughlan 86 (4.5%)
Richardson 86 (4.5%)
King 83 (4.3%)
Thursfield 83 (4.3%)
Newman 82 (4.2%)
Tuck 80 (4.1%)
Pettifer 79 (4.1%)
Tambling 77 (4%)
Polo 73 (3.8%)
Pattison 71 (3.7%)
Raines 71 (3.7%)
Johnson 70 (3.6%)
Jackson 65 (3.4%)
McMahon 65 (3.4%)
Edwards 64 (3.3%)
Conners 57 (3%)
-----------------------
Morton 46 (2.4%)
Tivendale 41 (2.1%)
McGuane 40 (2.1%)
Riewoldt 27 (1.4%)
Schulz 15 (0.8%)
Hyde 11 (0.6%)
White 8 (0.4%)
Hughes 7 (0.4%)
Moore 7 (0.4%)
Casserley 4 (0.2%)
Graham 4 (0.2%)
Meyer 4 (0.2%)
Oakley-Nicholls 3 (0.2%)
Collins 1 (0.1%)

 

[Tigers of Old]

Interesting exercise.
Starts to drop away pretty substantially after Connors at 22.
Highlights our lack of genuine quality depth (again) and shows injuries are likely to again be our enemy at some stage next season. Hopefully we stay pretty fit.

 

[Freezer]

Here is the list in order:

Bowden 87 (4.5%)
Brown 87 (4.5%)
Deledio 87 (4.5%)
Foley 87 (4.5%)
Polak 87 (4.5%)
Simmonds 87 (4.5%)
Coughlan 86 (4.5%)
Richardson 86 (4.5%)

88 voters to this point? Who didn't include Bowden 87, Brown 87, Deledio 87, Foley 87, Polak 87, Simmonds 87, Coughlan 86 and Richardson 86 in their votes?

 

[tigertim]

We should do this study again at seasons end. Would be interesting to see who we then consider the best 22.

 

[blx]

of course it will be different at seasons end. Someone will breakthrough. who will it be?

Collins? Moore? JON? Meyer? Cass?

i really hope Meyer can lift.

 

[the claw]

its not about best 22 though is it people. many of our best 22 are not going to take us forward. we should be in the process of turning plenty of players over to take their places. i think it important for the future and team structure that graham mcguane connors casserly riewoldt hughes morton white and others are played in the ones, along with any kid we take this yr who shows enough.

 

[tigertim]

its not about best 22 though is it people. many of our best 22 are not going to take us forward. we should be in the process of turning plenty of players over to take their places. i think it important for the future and team structure that graham mcguane connors casserly riewoldt hughes morton white and others are played in the ones, along with any kid we take this yr who shows enough.

ah, actually it is about the best 22 Claw, hence the title of this thread

but I certainly agree with your sentiments.