Pick 2 should be off limits | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Pick 2 should be off limits

Carlton may get Judd with picks 3 and 5 if they trade Fevola to Footscray for 5.

Geez who wouldve thought Carltons fantastic tanking effort wouldve paid off this well.

Kreuzer and Judd. >:(

*smile* i hate carlton.
 
craig said:
Carlton may get Judd with picks 3 and 5 if they trade Fevola to Footscray for 5.

Geez who wouldve thought Carltons fantastic tanking effort wouldve paid off this well.

Kreuzer and Judd. >:(

*smile* i hate carlton.

I second that, but who will kick there goals?

Craig didnt Eade say that pic 5 is off limits.
 
Yeah Eade has said as such but i wouldnt right off this scenario - Doggies are desperate for a key forward and the Blues will not cough up #1.

#3 will get the eagles Morton which will please them and with 5 they could nab Rance or Masten or Palmer.

Lets not forget that Judd may very well be damaged stock now, who knows how bad his op is and if and when it will actually come good and if Chris will actually be the same player again.

I think this angle has been forgotten by most in the frenzy of activity.
 
Just heard Judd's manager on 3AW & Dwayne asked him if he would be prepared to go through to the pre season draft if a deal couldn't be done he said yes that might be an option but hoped not!! *smile* head Dwayne said that Judd wanted to go to a club who could win a flag put the Blues in that bracket & not us surely we are just as close as the Blues!! Miller needs to stir the pot make it hard for clubs to deal.
 
Agree RFC need to make this trade as difficult as possible....i think we can do very well out of all this. If we cant land Juddy - Cotchin and a player on the outer in all of this would be more than handy going fwd.
 
TigerArmySoldier01 said:
TOUGH CALL! Its not a quick fix, his still in the prime of his career and should play for another 6 years at the bare minimum!

How can you say NO to having chris judd on ur team? The ability on the park, the experience, the brownlow, the money he would generate for the club.....

JUDDY IN THE YELLOW AND BLACK LIFTING THE PREMIERSHIP CUP

was once just a dream, could it REALLY happen?

PS: Richo would kick 100 next year with that kinda delivery coming his way!

And Schulz 80 goals, and Hughes 65 goals, and if we get Judd we should keep Kingsley as he'd be guaranteed to pick up a lazy 50 too.
 
Disco08 said:
Tigers of Old said:
You're kidding Disco. The kid's a truck and has been feeding off the Hawks excellent midfield.


As he should. He's got plenty of improvement left in him too and if he was playing for Richmond we'd all be excited about him I'm sure.

I dont mind Roughhead either. Reckon he's improving nicely. He's a bit slow but very strong bodied and will only get stronger. Like you many Hawks supporters I know who have watched him week in week out are excited by his prospects for the future..
 
Dream Oh dream on , the only way we want him is a swap for Cogs . And then we both have to have luck to see if they both can play again .