The following player ratings are out of 10. The "Player Ratings" are provided as an alternative discussion topic to the 3-2-1 format, which does not adequately explain the overall performance of the team.
| Bowden, J | 4 |
| Brown | 4 |
| Edwards | 7 |
| Foley | 6 |
| Howat | 3 |
| Hyde | 3 |
| Jackson | 3 |
| Johnson | 5 |
| King | 5 |
| McGuane | 4 |
| Newman | 5 |
| Pattison | 4 |
| Pettifer | 5 |
| Polak | 3 |
| Raines | 3 |
| Richardson | 8 |
| Riewoldt | 5 |
| Schulz | 3 |
| Simmonds | 5 |
| Thursfield | 5 |
| Tivendale | 5 |
| Tuck | 4 |
