POLL: Swinging the Axe in 2010. Who should be de-listed from the RFC?

[tigerjoe12]

TW, Brian Royal, Kane Johnson, Nathan Brown & Jake King

Think Hughes is missing from that list

 

[Freezer]

Impossible to pick only 5.

 

[Al Bundy]

quite interesting that Cousins & Richo from the list of the "over 30's" polled very lightly. 1 & 3 votes only.

The club will be stupid imo to get rid of Cousins after 1 year. He is getting better by the game & does influence the team. Very valuable. I hope the club or prospective coach just don't base their decision on stupid media hype.

 

[Streak]

The only over 30s I voted to delist were Sugar and Simmonds. I used my other three options on King, JON and Sarge.

 

[tigertim]

Impossible to pick only 5.

Agreed. ( geez, I sound like MB!)

 

[martyshire]

I cannot believe some people managed to find space in their 5 delistings for Rance, Newman, Lids, Cotchin and Foley.
I think I can work out people's reasoning with some of the other less common nominations, but seriously, some people must be taking the *smile*.

 

[graystar1]

Who goes...who stays??

Here is some food for thought. Who will get the chop and who will stay?

OLD


Joel Bowden 31
Nathan Brown 31
Ben Cousins 31
Kane Johnson 31
Matty Richardson 34
Troy Simmons 31


Possible Delistings

Mark Coghlan 27
Shane Edwards 21
Tom Hislop 21
Cleve Hughes 22
Jake King 25
Jordan McMahon 26
Oakley-Nichols 21
Adam Pattison 23
Kayne Pettifer 27
Graham Polak 25
Jayden Post 20 (Nil games to date)
Dean Putt 20 (Nil games to date)
Andrew Raines 23
Jay *smile* 24
Adam Thomson 23
Matt White 22

Of the above possible delistings I have done so on the basis of some non performers, some ordinary and a couple for one reason or another have not played. Obviously all of the 6 over 30's plus 16 "non performers," cannot just disappear of the list. They could not be replaced. So who, in the opinion of PREnders will stay and who will go??

 

[Pomsta]

Re: Who goes...who stays??

Here is some food for thought. Who will get the chop and who will stay?

OLD


Joel Bowden 31 Stay - one of very few players who is smart enough to find space
Nathan Brown 31 Retire - doesn't seem that interested so probably go
Ben Cousins 31 Stay if he wants to
Kane Johnson 31 Retire now
Matty Richardson 34 Stay if he wants to
Troy Simmons 31 Retire


Possible Delistings

Mark Coghlan 27 Give him another year with a full pre-season
Shane Edwards 21 Trade bait
Tom Hislop 21 Can't get rid everyone
Cleve Hughes 22 Trade or delist. Can't make Coburg 1s
Jake King 25 Delist - what were we thinking????
Jordan McMahon 26 One more year with new coach
Oakley-Nichols 21 Trade or delist
Adam Pattison 23 Trade bait or keep for one more year
Kayne Pettifer 27 Keep
Graham Polak 25 Delist as doing a McCartney will only win us one game and use a space on the list
Jayden Post 20 (Nil games to date) Have to keep
Dean Putt 20 (Nil games to date) Have to keep
Andrew Raines 23 Trade bait or send to Gold Coast
Jay schulz 24 Trade bait or keep
Adam Thomson 23 Don't know
Matt White 22 Keep

Of the above possible delistings I have done so on the basis of some non performers, some ordinary and a couple for one reason or another have not played. Obviously all of the 6 over 30's plus 16 "non performers," cannot just disappear of the list. They could not be replaced. So who, in the opinion of PREnders will stay and who will go??

That's at least 7 players gone with another 4 or 5 as trade bait. If we got a turnover of 9-10 I'd be happy. Who knows though, some of these may step up with a new coach by the end of the year.

 

[Fromthestands]

Re: Who goes...who stays??

OLD


Joel Bowden 31 - gone
Nathan Brown 31 - gone
Ben Cousins 31
Kane Johnson 31 - gone
Matty Richardson 34
Troy Simmons 31 - gone


Possible Delistings

Mark Coghlan 27
Shane Edwards 21
Tom Hislop 21
Cleve Hughes 22 - gone
Jake King 25 - lucky he is still contracted
Jordan McMahon 26 - ditto
Oakley-Nichols 21 - gone
Adam Pattison 23
Kayne Pettifer 27 - trade/gone
Graham Polak 25 - gone ;'(
Jayden Post 20 (Nil games to date)
Dean Putt 20 (Nil games to date)
Andrew Raines 23 - trade
Jay schulz 24 - trade/lucky he is still contracted
Adam Thomson 23
Matt White 22


That's my take. At least seven from that list but will depend on our draft picks.

FTS

 

[YinnarTiger]

Re: Who goes...who stays??

OLD


Joel Bowden 31
Nathan Brown 31
Ben Cousins 31
Kane Johnson 31
Matty Richardson 34
Troy Simmons 31

I think SENIOR is a more appropriate and polite description Gray One.

 

[Liverpool]

I wish the mods could list the names of the posters who have named Lids and Cotch to be delisted... :-\

 

[Sir]

Pettifer - McMahon - Never to be seen again!

Seriously - can anyone see any justification for either of these players ever wearing yellow and black again!!!

 

[Streak]

Re: Pettifer - McMahon - Never to be seen again!

Seriously - can anyone see any justification for either of these players ever wearing yellow and black again!!!

They themselves probably can't either.