Richmond vs Coburg Intra Club Praccy game this Friday | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Richmond vs Coburg Intra Club Praccy game this Friday

flogger said:
Sorry but not truye. you actual wordds were that my psots awere "all about Jakey", when in actual fact some of them were about other topics as well, so that makes what you said untrue.

you didn't actually say that everyone of my posts mentions Jake "in some way"( as you suggest above!) but rather that all my posts were "all about Jakey.

You have since added the clarificationthat I mentioned Jake in "some way". Sorry, that is different to saying they are all about Jakey
Shouldn't post when on the grog or typing in blind fury. It doesn't make sense
 
French Tiger said:
Does anyone know how Thompson & Farmer played ?
Thomson stood out and played 3 qtrs, kicked two goals fom difficult angles in the first. Looks super fit and hungry, should start in the best 22.
Farmer played after 3qtr time and did what he had to against inferior opposition. Swept the ball well out of defence and dd what he needed to do.
Farmer may allow Newman to play up the ground a little later in the year.
Thomson is very well built and kicking looked fine without being elite.
 
pmac21 said:
Thomson stood out and played 3 qtrs, kicked two goals fom difficult angles in the first. Looks super fit and hungry, should start in the best 22.
Farmer played after 3qtr time and did what he had to against inferior opposition. Swept the ball well out of defence and dd what he needed to do.
Farmer may allow Newman to play up the ground a little later in the year.
Thomson is very well built and kicking looked fine without being elite.

Cheers! Thomson is the forgotten man,i thought in the last game against the Eagles he showed a bit
 
for the 1st time on a long time the midfield is ok, but the defence looks really weak and we havent got a quality forward.
conners, hislop, thursfield and vickey really need to take the next step....
 
French Tiger said:
Does anyone know how Thompson & Farmer played ?

I endorse what pmac said. Thommo looked very fit and injury free and it showed - played well.

Took us while to figure out who no 15 was - dont know why - its Farmer's number. He played pretty well for the quarter I saw him.

Both aer serious considerations for a start which is good for our depth.
 
smokin joe said:
Sorry if i missed this somewhere but did Griffiths play in the game?
Didnt play

On Thomson thought he was very good and combined well with the other mids as f they had played a lot of footy together
 
lamb22 said:
I endorse what pmac said. Thommo looked very fit and injury free and it showed - played well.

Took us while to figure out who no 15 was - dont know why - its Farmer's number. He played pretty well for the quarter I saw him.

Both aer serious considerations for a start which is good for our depth.

great - I'd love to see these two have a great 2010 for us :clap
 
French Tiger said:
Cheers! Thomson is the forgotten man,i thought in the last game against the Eagles he showed a bit

Not forgotten here!

He was a top 10 pick back in 2004, was not popular with Williams and struggled with injuries as well - when he is fit (hopefully he is now) he will play and play well. He did have some good games with Port and was uncerimoniously dropped after stringing a few games together - paid the price for an insipid team effort - took it tough and that was his end at Port - played out the rest of his time at Sturt I think (don't quote me on Sturt though).

Dyer Disciple spoke to him through 2009 and was stuggling with a sturnum problem (Thommo not DD ;D ). He was never really untroubled in 2009 apparently.
 
lamb22 said:
I endorse what pmac said. Thommo looked very fit and injury free and it showed - played well.

Took us while to figure out who no 15 was - dont know why - its Farmer's number. He played pretty well for the quarter I saw him.

Both aer serious considerations for a start which is good for our depth.

What do you base that on in regards to Farmer being a strong consideration? The reason I ask is, the guy couldn't get a kick nor did he play his role right in the last 2 scratch matches prior to the Intra club match, nor has he be setting the training track alight. Plus I would hae thought if he was a consideration , he would at least had played in the first half
 
smokin joe said:
Sorry if i missed this somewhere but did Griffiths play in the game?

Griffiths had a shoulder reco in november and probably won't be ready till May.
 
White Lightning said:
What do you base that on in regards to Farmer being a strong consideration? The reason I ask is, the guy couldn't get a kick nor did he play his role right in the last 2 scratch matches prior to the Intra club match, nor has he be setting the training track alight. Plus I would hae thought if he was a consideration , he would at least had played in the first half

i saw the game on friday nd farmer was terrific when he came on, hard at it, aggressive, ran the ball out well and used it well also...

In regards to ur point if he was a consideration , he would at least had played in the first half Collins came on in the 2nd half...i wouldnt be reading to much into that WL
 
AstuteTiger said:
i saw the game on friday nd farmer was terrific when he came on, hard at it, aggressive, ran the ball out well and used it well also...

In regards to ur point if he was a consideration , he would at least had played in the first half Collins came on in the 2nd half...i wouldnt be reading to much into that WL

Collins is easing his way back, hence the reason why he came on in the second half. This is not the case with Farmer. Sure he looked alright on Friday, but don't read too much into it. If you had seen him in those scratch matches I mentioned, you'd be saying the same thing.
 
White Lightning said:
What do you base that on in regards to Farmer being a strong consideration? The reason I ask is, the guy couldn't get a kick nor did he play his role right in the last 2 scratch matches prior to the Intra club match, nor has he be setting the training track alight. Plus I would hae thought if he was a consideration , he would at least had played in the first half

IMO his form in the trial makes him a serious consideration for a starting berth. Not saying Hardwick has him pencilled in.

I'd say Edwards, Tambling, Newman and Connors are in front of him in the coach's eyes. Dont know how he has trained previously but played well Friday! As I said above good for depth - nice problem to have lots of players in decent nick!
 
lamb22 said:
IMO his form in the trial makes him a serious consideration for a starting berth. Not saying Hardwick has him pencilled in.

I'd say Edwards, Tambling, Newman and Connors are in front of him in the coach's eyes. Dont know how he has trained previously but played well Friday! As I said above good for depth - nice problem to have lots of players in decent nick!

IMO i don't consider Farmer as depth player. He doesn't hae the composure to play that role in our backline.This is a major focus in DH's game plan for the backline.
 
White Lightning said:
IMO i don't consider Farmer as depth player. He doesn't hae the composure to play that role in our backline.This is a major focus in DH's game plan for the backline.

Fair enough.
 
White Lightning said:
IMO i don't consider Farmer as depth player. He doesn't hae the composure to play that role in our backline.This is a major focus in DH's game plan for the backline.

Odd really. Everything I've read indicates that's where he is likely to play - time will tell....
 
White Lightning said:
IMO i don't consider Farmer as depth player. He doesn't hae the composure to play that role in our backline.This is a major focus in DH's game plan for the backline.
So DM trades for him and he is not going to play him :help :help