Tango said:dont judge poor list management issues by a previous coach on what happend to us with wallace......
would mathews, sheedy, malthouse put up with it - dont think so
Malthouse seems to be putting up with an awful lot these days….
Tango said:dont judge poor list management issues by a previous coach on what happend to us with wallace......
would mathews, sheedy, malthouse put up with it - dont think so
mb64 said:Didn't Richo do his hammy on Saturday?
Nah, let him play on if that's what he wantsmopsy fraser said:that`s why part of me wants him to retire this year,just announce it now to the footy world that round 21 or 22(whenever our last game for the year at the G is) will be richo`s farewell game and rest him until then and he can get a huge send off.
Phantom said:Meh!
I suppose it's too hard too de-list 11 players from the list in a single season.
S'pose Richo can be thankful that there was a decent list in front of him.
Forever Hoping said:well you can do it but only if you are prepared to take 11 newies and that is a big call.
Phantom said:That's right, it is a big call.
How many of those new 11 are going to have the talent, first off, without counting the unfolding of that talent.
If you take on a newie, if they make the commitment, you need to put in 2 to 3 years into them.
So where does that place us for the 2010?
Clearly, the 2010 will be very limited due to GC17.
My estimate:
9 to go this year.
6 to go next year.
Richo scrapes in this year because he's only 18 games from 300.
But the onus should be on him to get through those 18 games in 2010.
Phantom said:Richo scrapes in this year because he's only 18 games from 300.
But the onus should be on him to get through those 18 games in 2010.
Chocco said:You just don't get it do you, you went all quiet last year when Richo was 2 votes off winning the brownlow and All Australian. He is still our best player by a mile and no keyboard tapping tough guy can put him down, he is Mr richmond and you should be ashamed of yourself.
Phantom said:That's right, it is a big call.
How many of those new 11 are going to have the talent, first off, without counting the unfolding of that talent.
If you take on a newie, if they make the commitment, you need to put in 2 to 3 years into them.
So where does that place us for the 2010?
Clearly, the 2010 will be very limited due to GC17.
My estimate:
9 to go this year.
6 to go next year.
Richo scrapes in this year because he's only 18 games from 300.
But the onus should be on him to get through those 18 games in 2010.
hmm he played 22 in 07 and we got the spoon.Forever Hoping said:If he did play 18 next year, I think we would have a pretty good year because it would mean the new coach woudl be pretty happy with Richo playing the new team plan
ROLLS ROYCE said:Like everyone here this is a real hard one.....agree with both claw and phanto that Richo probably deserves to survive the cut as we have so many others to execute.
I have only one demand...and that is he plays a floating role and makes an occassional apearance forward allowing our KP kids to develop their own game.
its a no brainer we dont have a true ff. we have just 2 genuine kpfs that look to be up to standard both are more like chfs than ffs.Phantom said:That's the crunch!
He may get another season, but where do you play him?