Round 7 - Other Games

[caesar]

Their percentage is going to take a hammering.

Doesn't matter because of that St Kilda draw. Would have been beautiful had Saints got up.

 

[brigadiertiger]

Tomahawk touched the little pinky finger of that ever so special, precious dumpire. Let's see if he gets a $1000 fine like Dusty.

Hawkins intentionally made contact l wouldn’t be surprised if he gets a week but also wouldn’t be surprised if it’s nothing just to maintain their inconsistency.

 

[Dyer'ere]

The worst news for Leon Cameron fans is that he's doing his best.

 

[seven]

The worst news for Leon Cameron fans is that he's doing his best.

Hope they keep him on.
He's the kind of coach that can keep GWS winless in the premiership stakes.

 

[Dyer'ere]

Hope they keep him on.
He's the kind of coach that can keep GWS winless in the premiership stakes.

Leon Cameron is only mildly influential in his world of failure, 7.

Stephen Silvagni is dominant.

Genki!

 

[easy_tiger]

Hawkins intentionally made contact l wouldn’t be surprised if he gets a week but also wouldn’t be surprised if it’s nothing just to maintain their inconsistency.

has to go. it was only a little touch, but it was menacing.

he thought about jumper punching the *smile* out of him for a second

 

[Batchelor Party]

Turned off right after Eddie McGuire started pushing for the incident where Tom Hawkins made contact with another player in the back (free kick and 50 paid). Eddie repeatedly was calling it a "rabbit punch". How ridiculous is it that a club official is trying to highlight an incident that could get a player from another club suspended during a TV commentary?
Is it just coincidence Collingwood plays Geelong next week? Ridiculous conflict of interest.

 

[graystar1]

Dreadful game from what I saw until 1/4 time. Switched off, read a book instead.

 

[scottyturnerscurse]

Hawkins intentionally made contact l wouldn’t be surprised if he gets a week but also wouldn’t be surprised if it’s nothing just to maintain their inconsistency.

Gotta get a week, at least. Such a bad look. In legal terms, general deterrence demands a suspension.

 

[Rfc4Ever]

Dreadful game from what I saw until 1/4 time. Switched off, read a book instead.

It was a boring Friday night game that's for sure.

 

[Tigerfan]

Don’t know about Giants. Pretty-boy superstar metro hipsters with man-buns.

 

[seven]

Leon Cameron is only mildly influential in his world of failure, 7.

Stephen Silvagni is dominant.

Genki!

You don't think Carlton will steal Cameron from GWS?

 

[Brodders17]

GWS need more first round draft picks. ;D

At least they wouldnt have Silvagni to f them up this time.
He gets high praise for the list he built. he should be condemned for the list he should have built.

 

[tigertim]

Dreadful game from what I saw until 1/4 time. Switched off, read a book instead.

Yeah, it was very dull.

 

[TigerTribe5]

It was a boring Friday night game that's for sure.

Yep somehow I lasted till halfway through the 3rd without falling asleep.
Couldn't stand the boring game and crap Geelong-centric umpiring so went on to Netflix to see how Will Robinson was doing.

 

[Tails]

I noticed there has been a reorganisation of seating in the Giants coaching box, has anyone else noticed this? Looks like there is pressure on a few and some cracks are starting to show.

 

[TigerTribe5]

Hawkins intentionally made contact l wouldn’t be surprised if he gets a week but also wouldn’t be surprised if it’s nothing just to maintain their inconsistency.

Hawkins under scrutiny for a couple of other incident in the game also.
On Fox they were talking about the knees to the back and a rabbit punch (whatever that is?).

I won't forget how he cleaned up Vlossy with his knee 3 of 4 times in the final last year.

Hawkins seems to have moved on from the jumper punch to the "p!ss weak knee in the back pretending it's in the marking contest" style actions.

Hope he gets a few weeks on the sidelines and fines.

 

[Tigers of Old]

You don't think Carlton will steal Cameron from GWS?

:hihi

 

[Tigaman]

Hawkins under scrutiny for a couple of other incident in the game also.
On Fox they were talking about the knees to the back and a rabbit punch (whatever that is?).

I won't forget how he cleaned up Vlossy with his knee 3 of 4 times in the final last year.

Hawkins seems to have moved on from the jumper punch to the "p!ss weak knee in the back pretending it's in the marking contest" style actions.

Hope he gets a few weeks on the sidelines and fines.

You must have led a cloistered life as a rabbit punch is the good old punch with a fist or a chop with an open hand to the back of the neck. Conca sought of gave Devon Smith one a few years back.

 

[Tigaman]

Who was out for the Giants?

Deledio. Ok. He's their bet player but he's pretty much never played for them.

Kelly can get it and use it. Big out.

Scully? All Aus wing class player.

Cameron? Good player. Coleman. AA.


Good call.
Toby Greene. All Aus HFF.

Zac Williams. Outstanding HBF with high BWA. Not far below the others for getting it. And his best use is incisive.

That is six big outs. It doesn't explain why GWS fielded ten VFA footballers tonight. No irony. But the injured sextet would make top six in most sides.

Rory Lobb was out tonight. But he's not as bad as the other outs are good. He's worth +five goals out.

The GWS backline was reasonably intact. But, to be fair, got no cover from the midfield. Phil Davis was terrified and uncoordinated. His mates were ok. Phil Davis is no good. He relies on three teammates screening him while he marks an errant ball that was heated by his usually diligient mids.

Phil Davis turned it up four times in the first quarter and then focussed on getting worse. He was successful.

Jonathan Patton was outmanned by Rhys Stanley. Are we done with this rumour?

Whitfield was useless. Coniglio reinvented meaninglessness of disposal.

The Giants had a road game. But the problems are in the bottom six to ten. Too many VFA players.

It was a road game with six very big outs. Geelong had outs? Meh. The lingering doubt about GWS is the talent of players like Patton, Whitfield, Lobb. And the abundant VFA class players. (Really VFA.) Reid, Lloyd, Corr, Shipley, Langdon, Buckley. Have I got ten yet? De Boer. Keeffe. Whitfield. Patton. Davis.

I've come around a bit on Cameron. I think he can think. In which case he can rethink this structure and player rating.