Ridley said:Generally enjoy your posts Carts but you are way off beam here.
The list has too much rubbish; 100% bona fide A grade garbage.
Shankwards, Grigg, Hampson, Vickery, Houli, Chaplin, Morris. There are 7 that are walk up starts every week. Rubbish footballers all of them. Hardwick LOVES them all. That's a third of the team.
Then we have blokes like Jackson & Rance who play key roles. They have good attributes but also make too many basic errors. Foley, Newman and King are years past their best but Hardwick would play Newman and King every week if fit.
Many youngsters are treading water or going backwards. Batchelor, Helbig, O'Hanlon, all have been around long enough to make an impact but it looking highly likely that none of them are good enough. We all know talls take longer but the jury is well and truly out on our young talls. Griffiths is getting a go but geez his intensity is lacking. Elton and McBean are miles off yet and who knows if they will ever make it.
McIntosh is in his second year and hasn't even looked like cracking it for a senior game. Grimes is massively overrated and is playing reserves. Panic merchant with sh!t skills. Dea has been around for 5 years and is not good enough to get a regular go in our sh!t side.
Then you have the recycled players. Petterd poorly skilled, Knights gets injured walking to the shops, Thomas is as bad a kick at AFL level as you'd ever see, Aaron Edwards was never that good to start with, Stephenson nowhere near good enough.
That's 26 players on a list of 40 odd that are either not up to it or have valid question marks against them. Hopefully some of those young players will still be able to step up and make the grade but regardless, the list is anything but in fine shape.
duddelist said:Someone tell me and I am 47 when was the last time we came back from behind after half time let alone 3 qtr time
Thanks I do remember in the wet at the end some 4 years ago what a successful club we followBaloo said:The last won I remember was round 14, 2010 against he Swans at the G.
Nason was everywhere it the wet and Collins survived brain transplant on the sidelines to come back out take the winning mark / goal.
kitrino_tj said:I like what Adelaide did and drop Reilly on 199 games, they bounced back and beat collingwood
We will not do that
zippadeee said:Yes we will, we drop 3 kids and bring in recycled duds
I well remember Collins courage and we swapped that for GriggBaloo said:The last one I remember was round 14, 2010 against he Swans at the G.
Nason was everywhere it the wet and Collins survived brain transplant on the sidelines to come back out take the winning mark / goal.
puntrd64 said:I well remember Collins courage and we swapped that for Grigg
you want to change thisbuenavista said:The equation is fairly simple if the pundits are right and 12 wins could get a final, we have to win (at least) 10 of our last 15 games.
The good news ...
* we play GWS and St Kilda twice
* we have another game against Brisbane
* we have a game against Melbourne
The not so good news ....
* two games against Sydney
* one against Port
* one against Freo
The toss up's that could go either way ....
* two games against Essendon
* one against North
* west coast over there
So I am happy to have a stab at this .......
Rich vs Melb MCG W
GWS vs Rich SPO W
Ess vs Rich MCG L
North vs Rich ES W
Rich vs Freo MCG L
Rich vs Syd MCG L
Saints vs Rich ES W
Rich vs Bris MCG W
Rich vs Port ES L
WCE vs Rich PS W
Rich vs GWS MCG W
Rich vs Ess MCG W
Adel vs Rich AO W
Rich vs Saints MCG W
Syd vs Rich ANZ L
Not much margin for error even if 12 wins makes it :-\
mad_doggy911 said:She's definitely over.
buenavista said:The equation is fairly simple if the pundits are right and 12 wins could get a final, we have to win (at least) 10 of our last 15 games.
The good news ...
* we play GWS and St Kilda twice
* we have another game against Brisbane
* we have a game against Melbourne
The not so good news ....
* two games against Sydney
* one against Port
* one against Freo
The toss up's that could go either way ....
* two games against Essendon
* one against North
* west coast over there
So I am happy to have a stab at this .......
Rich vs Melb MCG W
GWS vs Rich SPO W
Ess vs Rich MCG L
North vs Rich ES W
Rich vs Freo MCG L
Rich vs Syd MCG L
Saints vs Rich ES W
Rich vs Bris MCG W
Rich vs Port ES L
WCE vs Rich PS W
Rich vs GWS MCG W
Rich vs Ess MCG W
Adel vs Rich AO W
Rich vs Saints MCG W
Syd vs Rich ANZ L
Not much margin for error even if 12 wins makes it :-\
buenavista said:The equation is fairly simple if the pundits are right and 12 wins could get a final, we have to win (at least) 10 of our last 15 games.
The good news ...
* we play GWS and St Kilda twice
* we have another game against Brisbane
* we have a game against Melbourne
The not so good news ....
* two games against Sydney
* one against Port
* one against Freo
The toss up's that could go either way ....
* two games against Essendon
* one against North
* west coast over there
So I am happy to have a stab at this .......
Rich vs Melb MCG W
GWS vs Rich SPO W
Ess vs Rich MCG L
North vs Rich ES W
Rich vs Freo MCG L
Rich vs Syd MCG L
Saints vs Rich ES W
Rich vs Bris MCG W
Rich vs Port ES L
WCE vs Rich PS W
Rich vs GWS MCG W
Rich vs Ess MCG W
Adel vs Rich AO W
Rich vs Saints MCG W
Syd vs Rich ANZ L
Not much margin for error even if 12 wins makes it :-\
kitrino_tj said:Only thing to look forward to is getting some high end talent via the draft
They won't take that away from us, surely?