Selwood/ Headland - sam newman you tool! [Merged] | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Selwood/ Headland - sam newman you tool! [Merged]

Re: Adam Selwood/Des Headland

LeeToRainesToRoach said:
I once heard a story that a past Richmond premiership player (one of my favourite players as a lad) would put his fingers somewhere they're not supposed to go, then waft them under his opponent's nose in order to put him off his game. Most people would also consider this to be disgusting and low. Is this any better? Worse? Or just different?

One of my colleagues used to do it. I suppose it's only funny if it happens to someone else. But then it's really funny.
 
Re: Adam Selwood/Des Headland

hellenictiger said:
You dont say that anywhere, if its a spectator yes, you dont expect that comment from anyone. For all thats gone on with priests, stalkers, childporn, this isnt a joking matter, this isnt a light comment.

Its a serious issue, you dont expect anyone to say this. Simple as that, Selwood deserved more than just what he copped.

I do agree that headland had to go, but he knew that and didnt care because you dont joke about peoples children. This was a low act by selwood.
Dunno how you can say that after he's been found not guilty. No-one knows exactly what happened except Selwood.
 
Re: sam newman you tool!

Sam Newman is on the ball! Des Headland was SOFT! I'm sure in Sam's playing time alot worse would have been said!
What happens on the field stays on the field...
Its along the same lines as
Your mum jokes
Your a fag, *smile* blah blah which im sure happen every week out on the ground.
Racism and religous taunts have been taken away, which is fair enough as globally it is a very sensitive

But go to any schoolyard in australia and im sure u'd find just as offensive sledging happening everyday, and not even school kids react like Headland.
People have got to realise in todays society no matter what the provokes the reaction, the reaction is unacceptable as there are proper pathways to deal with these things. Say Headland smacks Selwood and Selwood hit his head on the way down and died, what would every1's reaction be?
 
Re: Adam Selwood/Des Headland

Dyer'ere said:
One of my colleagues used to do it. I suppose it's only funny if it happens to someone else. But then it's really funny.

:rofl

And that's why you love kath and Kim, Russel Coight and The Wedge. But not Yes Minister and Rumpole.

:yellowno
 
Re: sam newman you tool!

King of the Jungle said:
I think Newman was right also I think Headland is full of crap or just misheard Selwood I very much doubt he would of said that & sledging occurs at all level of sport & if you have made it to AFL or the top level & can't take it then I think it's pretty soft!!
Agree
 
Re: sam newman you tool!

mb64 said:
King of the Jungle said:
I think Newman was right also I think Headland is full of crap or just misheard Selwood I very much doubt he would of said that & sledging occurs at all level of sport & if you have made it to AFL or the top level & can't take it then I think it's pretty soft!!
Agree

I believe all people who make jokes or tolerate concepts of 'children' and 'sex' are probably not far from going all the way.
 
"At its worst, sledging is a failure of the imagination. If he must, Selwood could have attacked Headland man-to-man. "You're weak. You won't go and get the ball. You're letting your team down." In that, there would have been a form of honour. Instead, it was "girl like that".

Selwood at the tribunal was steadfast, unshakeable. This was as disturbing as it was impressive, for it meant that in claiming to have done no wrong, he was not simply spinning a line. He believed it. Afterwards, he said: "I never meant to offend Des or his family." (!)

This goes to the heart of football culture. Selwood's mistake was not to offend more grievously than many others, but to be exposed by Headland and made to confront it. West Coast is not the only offender, but it does have the worst name to live down."


http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/no-excuse-for-grubs/2007/04/19/1176697004275.html
 
How does any of this differ from the banter that we as spectators give to all persons on the field, our own, opposition and umpires....the hypocrisy displayed in this thead is appalling. Verbal taunts are just that, a taunt...if you react then the other has achieved the aim...if persons don't have the maturity or sense of self worth not to react....well then who is the person that need be looked at?
 
Re: sam newman you tool!

DirtyDogTiger said:
I believe all people who make jokes or tolerate concepts of 'children' and 'sex' are probably not far from going all the way.

Only the person making such a comment really knows the essence of it, everyone else is interpreting without the complete picture. Best to leave the sledger to resolve the comment with his conscience.
 
Soft as!!! Although it may hit a soft spot it was the whole intention!!
Imagine if you reacted like that to every "your mamma is so fat"" joke?????????????????????
 
Re: sam newman you tool!

Dyer'ere said:
I don't reckon he's watched more than five entire games in the past ten years. Already knows everything.

He's been wasting our time for thirty years.
Let there be no argument.
 
not just headland is soft

AFL is turning soft, and I for one am getting quite sick of it.

I would much rather go and watch a local match where there are contests, players hard at it, and also sledging rather than watch 'professionals' run around getting uncontested possessions and whinging about stupid things!
 
Re: sam newman you tool!

evo said:
Dyer'ere said:
I don't reckon he's watched more than five entire games in the past ten years. Already knows everything.

He's been wasting our time for thirty years.
Let there be no argument.

:hihi
 
I think Gary Lyon was spot on.

People are getting away from the exact quote, you just dont say that or even put those thoughts into your mind.

Selwood knew it was one word against another, I dont think that Headland would joke or try and use this is an escape from suspension.

People doubted if the thing ever happened because they didnt trust Headland, but even Selwood admitted to it, not entirely, because he isnt a man. He doesnt have respect.
 
Re: sam newman you tool!

LeeToRainesToRoach said:
Only the person making such a comment really knows the essence of it, everyone else is interpreting without the complete picture. Best to leave the sledger to resolve the comment with his conscience.

good comment...wise words...still don't like his work though
 
I *smile*ed your daughter, she's a *smile*....Selwood, what does that mean?

You just dont say that stuff, simple as that. Its gutless and he will get dropped again next time Freo play West Coast.



Edit - Don't avoid the swear filter. If you must swear, type the full word and let it get censored.
 
Greek Tiger, you keep assuming Selwood said those comments. Selwood says he didn't, the tribunal dropped the charges, so what proof do you have that Selwood said what Des thinks he did and not what Selwood claimed he said ?

You running around convicting a man with no proof. I for one would tend to believe Selwood's take on what he said and not Des's. But I'm not running around making silly arsed claims based on either of their stories.
 
I hate it when the crowd on the footy show bursts out into applause when Sam for once acts serious & comments on a subject, but he thinks thinks his opinion is the only one! He is a goose & it is others who make the footy show worth watching!