Tivendale / Mcmahon | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Tivendale / Mcmahon

iIf you could replace Mcmahon with Tivendale, would you do it?

  • Yes

    Votes: 57 82.6%

  • No

    Votes: 12 17.4%
  • Total voters
    69
Tiv at least went in for the ball ...occasionally! They both looked like they were the beautiful left foot kick but as previously mentioned Tiv always wanted to kick bullet pass worm burners that always fell short of it's intended target and McMahon, well his kicks often seem to just miss the target completely. How was the AFL footy world fooled into thinking he had these magnificent foot skills?
 
tigertim said:
Tiv at least went in for the ball ...occasionally! They both looked like they were the beautiful left foot kick but as previously mentioned Tiv always wanted to kick bullet pass worm burners that always fell short of it's intended target and McMahon, well his kicks often seem to just miss the target completely. How was the AFL footy world fooled into thinking he had these magnificent foot skills?
Click to expand...

It might have been wallaces "suck-up" apology to the doggies
 
Just did a comparo of them in '06 & '07. They about break-even across the board in '06 though Jordie plays two more games, '07 Tivva owns him in about half his stats and doubles his tackle count and kicks 15 goals to one. As I said this is a rhetorical exercise but *smile*nuts Wallace can try all he likes to walk away from his RESPONSIBILITY but JM is on the list only because Wallace put him there! Just shows that as maligned as Tivva was he was giving us much more than Jordie.
 
geoffryprettyboy said:
We've seen what Tivendale is made of, haven't we learnt from our mistakes or do people want to go around in circles.
Click to expand...

Yeah but at least he had more heart than McMuffin....

We'da been better off getting rid of Tivva and leaving McMuffin to head to Port.
 
I find it's insulting to Tivendale to compare him to McMahon. Didn't Sir Alex Ferguson say he wouldn't even sell McMahon to Real Madrid.
 
Tigers of Old said:
lol :help
Click to expand...
agree the thought processes of ferals is at times very amusing.

we got rid of one dud in tivendale all be it many many yrs to late, we now have another to get rid of as soon as his contract expires.

that hbf people are so keen to see the tivandales and mcmahons of this world play from is and should be reserved for young versions of tambling and deledio.

i think by now everyone knows claw still thinks tambling should play back there permanently. claw has said for a long time now kel moore should be played as the medium sized running player. alex rance should be now playing at chb with a job to do on a direct opponent im hoping he can put on 5 or 6 kg in the off season.
claw has also regularly stated we need to find a big bodied fb who has pace agility and footy smarts.
in claws opinion there should be no room in the one backline for both mcguane and thursfield my preference of the two is thursfield.i would be reluctant to get rid of either until we actually have that big fb in our system.

mcguane being a queenslander to the gc for as early a draft pick we can wring out of them.but we need to get that fb first.
 
I thought McGuane was amongst our best. Fevola just had a day out, when he's in that mood no-one can stop him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
< Richmond Players: KICK THE BLOODY THING! | Peter Sumich has applied to coach the Tiges in 2010 >
Top Bottom