Tommy Roach | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Tommy Roach

angel

Tiger Cub
Jan 5, 2005
12
0
Hi all, just wondered down from saintsational to ask about Tommy Roach... he's training with us. I'm sure yuo guys delisted him for a good reason but I'd just like to know your opinions of him... strengths, weaknesses, worth a late pick, that sort of thing
 
angel said:
Hi all, just wondered down from saintsational to ask about Tommy Roach... he's training with us. I'm sure yuo guys delisted him for a good reason but I'd just like to know your opinions of him... strengths, weaknesses, worth a late pick, that sort of thing

Nothing outstanding in any area IMHO, a good honest kid who had the misfortune of starting his career in an era where a fairly clueless coach wasn't able to get the best out of quite a few young players with some potential.

Unfortunately there are numerous players of his build, pace, skills etc. around and the competition for a spot on an AFL list is pretty fierce if you don't have something that stands out, and I cannot think of anything young Roachy has like that.
 
He needs to get his confidence back, as I think he lost it after his broken jaw.
 
The_General said:
He needs to get his confidence back, as I think he lost it after his broken jaw.

I reckon you are spot on General. He needs to believe in himself again.

He is fast, has good skills and works hard. If there is one area that the Saints needs depth in it is with ball carrying midfielders.

I hope Tommy gets picked up and works out at the Saints a la Shane Tuck with us. He's a good player and a ripping fella by all reports.
 
I wish him the best.

I think he received some shabby treatment from the Richmond selectors and felt sick for him as he tried to salvage his career in that last match againt West Coast. His first kick caused a turnover and that was that!

AFL football can be very cruel...................don't get me started on Andy Kellaway!
 
I honestly believe that Roach can have a breakout year in 07 ala Raines and Tuck. He is quick and has a good work ethic. Richmond werent able to get the best out of him but I believe with an injury free season he could turn everything around. If I were a saints supporter (I almost am 2nd fav team) then I would be hoping to Roachy to be picked up late.
 
I would have loved for Tommy to make it, but he was never really offering anything outstanding. As for training with St Kilda, well......... read Aaron Fiora. 8)
 
angel said:
Hi all, just wondered down from saintsational to ask about Tommy Roach... he's training with us.  I'm sure yuo guys delisted him for a good reason but I'd just like to know your opinions of him... strengths, weaknesses, worth a late pick, that sort of thing
Not given a go by the tigers.Well worth a late pick for Saints.
 
mb64 said:
angel said:
Hi all, just wondered down from saintsational to ask about Tommy Roach... he's training with us. I'm sure yuo guys delisted him for a good reason but I'd just like to know your opinions of him... strengths, weaknesses, worth a late pick, that sort of thing
Not given a go by the tigers.Well worth a late pick for Saints.
Selling young Thomas short there MB.Pick 9 tommorrow ;D
 
angel said:
Hi all, just wondered down from saintsational to ask about Tommy Roach... he's training with us.  I'm sure yuo guys delisted him for a good reason but I'd just like to know your opinions of him... strengths, weaknesses, worth a late pick, that sort of thing

Not AFL standard unfortunately. If only he was half as good as his old man. :'(
 
The_General said:
He needs to get his confidence back, as I think he lost it after his broken jaw.

Aye Aye General! But his kicking skills were always under pressure and never quite lifted to the level required. Everything else was OK. Very speculative pick - teach to kick under pressure and maybe.................... Great attitude though!
 
DUD,..... will never make it.

Keep thinking about that day in Morwell against the Bombers (the day when D-ROD done his knee).....in the huddle at quarter time and how disinterested he looked...standing 1 metre away from plough and ripping out the biggest yawn you'll ever see right into ploughs face, pissed myself laughing.