TW please play the kids | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

TW please play the kids

CarnTheTiges said:
If you look at a lot of the real good teams over the last 20 years a fair percentage of them gave their younger players a good solid apprenticeship at a lower level before playing them consistently at senior level. It may be frustrating for us supporters, but results show that it works.
Yeah agre CTT, some of these kids are still growing into their bodies.
Stress fractures occurring because too much workload, repitition before their frames are finished growing and strenghtened.
Anybody with young lads would be able to tell you about growth spurts etc, bloody painful to go through and their growth plates are still soft as well. Still need to strengthen as well as get some muscle mass to go with it.
Disagree with comment to "play the kids".
Allright for some youthful enthusiasm and spectators enjoyment to see them running around (and I sure some might do ok) but the long term effect could be damaging.
Wait untill they are ready, physically and mentally and we might be able to enjoy their careers all the longer
 
Phantom said:
The reality is that exposing kids to AFL level footy, too early in their apprenticeship, can shorten their careers.
The physical & mental pressures of AFL footy can render premature injuries & can inhibit skill development.

Phantom my pies mate reckons they've destroyed Josh Fraser by playing him to early driving him into the ground as his body was still growing, he also thinks he's footy is near the end with his continuous injuries.
 
Rimau Junior said:
There is always an exception as shown with blokes like Tim Watson but overall the young guys are surprised about the difference in the two levels of footy when they get the chance to play at elite level.

Agree and the demands of the game have changed immensely since Tim Watson played.
 
uhuh uhuh said:
What do you say to Richo and Brownie - sorry guys no wins this year because we are playing the kids...

Play the best 22 and lets have a go at some finals..

Yeah it would be wrong if we did not field out best 22 line up. There for we can have a crack at the finals for once in so many years. In saying that we should blood the kids and give them as many chances as possible. However they have to earn there spot like everyone else. Please Terry i want to see the likes of Jack and young edwards out there more often. Both have class and i want to see more of it
 
tigers#7 said:
Under 23's


FB: King Thursfield Rance
HB: Casserly Polak Raines
C: Connors Foley Tambling
HF: Meyer Hughes Morton
FF: Collard Schulz Edwards
R: Graham Deledio Polo
INT: Jackson Cotchin Riewoldt White

EMER: Gourdis Oakley-Nicholls Moore Silvester Cartledge Howat Collins Putt McGuane



Over 23's

FB: -- Bowden --
HB: -- -- McMahon
C: Newman Coughlan Tivendale
HF: Pettifer Richardson Hyde
FF: Brown -- --
R: Simmonds Johnson Tuck
INT: -- -- -- --

The recruiting nightmare highlighted perfectly

But still a great game as a charity 1off each preseason, maybe :)
 
tigers#7 said:
Under 23's


FB: King Thursfield Rance
HB: Casserly Polak Raines
C: Connors Foley Tambling
HF: Meyer Hughes Morton
FF: Collard Schulz Edwards
R: Graham Deledio Polo
INT: Jackson Cotchin Riewoldt White

EMER: Gourdis Oakley-Nicholls Moore Silvester Cartledge Howat Collins Putt McGuane

I have Polak, King and Moore over 23 as of today's date or is this as of start of this year?
 
Terry, Terry....

Here is some more evidence/benefits of playing the youth.

I also follow the Dallas Cowboys and have been thrilled with their progress... why youth.. its taken a few years but see parallels with RFC .

Please read this article / link


http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/spt/football/cowboys/stories/121307dnspotaylor.2d29f9f.html



IRVING – Although they occasionally drive you crazy because of their flaws, these Cowboys are a special bunch for one reason: They continually find ways to win.

An onside kick recovery against Buffalo and subsequent field goal on the final play. A blocked field goal return for a touchdown against Minnesota. Four touchdowns from Terrell Owens against Washington.

An interception return touchdown by Terence Newman against the Jets. Four touchdown passes by Tony Romo against Green Bay.

The list could go on and on and on.

Understand, the Cowboys used to find new and exciting ways to lose several games a year as recently as last season. And, no, it didn't matter that Bill Parcells was their coach.

That's not a knock on Parcells, simply a fact.

You remember the debacle against Washington last year, when the Cowboys somehow attempted a game-winning field goal on the final play of a tie game and it turned into a gut-wrenching loss.

How about the loss at Seattle in 2005, when Drew Bledsoe threw one of the worst interceptions in NFL history as Dallas allowed 10 points in the final 40 seconds to blow a seven-point lead. And we really don't even need to talk about the botched snap against Seattle in the playoffs last season.

Now, though, luck is on the Cowboys' side. All is right in the universe. God is, once again, looking through the hole in the roof and smiling on his beloved football team.

Whatever.

The Cowboys are 12-1 because their young talent stockpiled over the last five seasons has matured. These days – like all good teams – they find ways to win instead of lose. More important, Dallas can beat you multiple ways.

Cowboys/NFL

LOUIS DeLUCA / DMN
Dallas Cowboys TE Jason Witten's catch in last Sunday's win over Detroit capped a comeback from a 13-point deficit. Against Detroit, were you really surprised when Ware harassed Jon Kitna on the game's most important third down and forced an incompletion? Were you really surprised when Romo led a flawless fourth-quarter drive in the last two minutes? Or when Witten caught the game-winning touchdown with 18 seconds left?

"When a team plays as well as Detroit did," Jerry Jones said, "you're supposed to lose."

Except that these Cowboys have been making big plays with the game on the line all season.

It's the reason they're 6-0 on the road and have nine come-from-behind victories.

They never, ever panic.

Don't forget, they rallied from a 14-3 deficit to take a 24-21 lead over the Patriots before succumbing, 48-27. If not for Kyle Kosier's holding penalty, which negated a fourth-and-1 conversion in the fourth quarter, the game might not have been decided until the final minute.

At the time, the Cowboys trailed 31-24.

"This is the first team I've been a part of that plays all the way to the end in every game," said Flozell Adams, a man of few words. "We continue to persevere and hammer away until we win."

Perhaps that's why you didn't hear any players apologizing for their 28-27 win over Detroit.

In the past, they know the Cowboys would've lost that game. No doubt.

Times have changed.